Questions tagged [phd]
Questions about the Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D.) degree, including requirements such as dissertations and university programs leading to a Ph.D.
7,676 questions
Score of 18
6 answers
2072 views
PhD student is unfit for research, what do to?
I am one of the postdocs in the group who is unofficially supervising a PhD student who is now employed with us for more than a year. The official supervisor has given me essentially all ...
Score of 20
4 answers
2092 views
I love my PhD, but I am tired
I just finished my first year of PhD. It was tough, but I managed to get one publication at a very good conference and my advisors are happy about my work. Research-wise, I would say that, up until a ...
Score of 2
1 answer
200 views
Do you have to excel in undergrad in order to have a chance to get a PhD in law?
prospective undergrad student in Law here, about to graduate in July. In my university and my country academic environment overall, it's always an "implied" rule that to get a PhD, you have ...
Score of 9
4 answers
1881 views
Should I tell my advisor about working on unrelated side project during PhD?
I'm currently in my first year of a biophysics PhD in Canada, and I have an external fellowship, so my stipend doesn't come from my PI's own funds. The summer before, I spent time working on a ...
Score of 3
1 answer
897 views
How do Pure Mathematics PhD Admission Committees view Mathematics courses offered by other departments?
Certain courses—such as probability theory, stochastic calculus, quantum mechanics, and game theory—are often housed in departments outside of mathematics. These alternatives can be more rigorous, ...
Score of 4
3 answers
1097 views
Should I mention paper submission status to potential PI?
I am a recent undergraduate and an international applicant for Fall 2027 CS PhD programs.
I have been trying to publish my undergrad thesis work for a while now. Recently I submitted my manuscript to ...
Score of 16
5 answers
3332 views
What to do when one of the main results of a PhD thesis is generalized?
Assume the following situation: you start a PhD in Mathematics, you put in the hours, do the work and, in the end, have a couple published results. You then start writing the thesis based on those ...
Score of 11
3 answers
2963 views
PhD in Math and Artificial Intelligence
I am currently enrolled in PhD in Math. I have completed 4 years already. Here are some developments.
OpenAI and Anthropic has solved various open problems in math, involving one of the open ...
Score of 13
5 answers
3046 views
Temporarily leaving to observe the changes in the field?
I am about to finish the first year of my PhD. My goal is to become a professor at a research institution, publish papers, advise students, etc. Even if that doesn't work out, (perhaps due to the ...
Score of 1
0 answers
283 views
Would it be wise to pursue a second Ph.D. given my circumstances? [closed]
I am seriously considering pursuing a second Ph.D. I have already completed my GRE general test and plan to start applying to universities shortly. I am aware that pursuing a second Ph.D. is ...
Score of 10
9 answers
3656 views
Is it moral to use an LLM to assist proofs in a math/stats PhD dissertation?
Currently, I think it is now no exaggeration to say that LLMs, such as GPT and Claude, are able to produce math/stats papers with quality sufficient to be a PhD dissertation.
I am wondering if it is ...
Score of 1
3 answers
1275 views
"I do not have any PhD positions available, but would be happy to support applications for external funding" as an email response
I got a reply from a Professor at a UK university whom I approached regarding a PhD position:
Dear Rudraneel,
Thank you for your email and your interest in research in my group. I'm afraid I do not ...
Score of 1
2 answers
387 views
If a Ph.D. program asks for a proof of manuscript acceptance, is a copy of a manuscript with its submission ID and date of acceptance acceptable?
I am an international student who recently applied to an Australian Ph.D. program where having a peer-reviewed publication increases an applicant’s chances of receiving a scholarship. Thankfully, one ...
Score of 1
3 answers
479 views
What authorship criteria apply when generative AI performs most technical work?
Suppose a researcher (either a PhD or a PostDoc) identifies a published scientific method that appears unnecessarily complicated and develops an improved alternative.
The researcher uses a generative-...
Score of 0
0 answers
110 views
Transitioning from theoretical/mathematical physics to quantum information after a PhD [duplicate]
I recently completed a PhD in theoretical physics. My research was mainly in black-hole information and holography, although quantum-information concepts played an important role in my work, including ...