A survey of 788 software development professionals finds 71% are using agile development methodologies within their software development life cycle (SDLC) but only 44% said it is working very well (11%) or somewhat well (33%) in the enterprise.
Conducted by Digital.ai, the survey identifies end-to-end visibility and traceability from business initiative through deployment as the top opportunity for improvement (44%), followed by an ability to measure cycle time, wait time and bottlenecks (34%), continuous testing (29%) and identification and measurement of technological risk (28%).
Nearly half (46%) identified too many systems as a primary reason Agile was not scaling, followed by siloed teams (37%), culture clash (34%), inconsistent adoption (30%) and the inability to measure business value (28%).
Despite these issues, nearly two-thirds (63%) said they have visibility into their Agile pipeline, with 55% claiming they have complete visibility. However, only 36% said DevOps teams currently work together as one team to accelerate innovation and deployment of high-quality and more reliable software. At the same time, only two-thirds (66%) claimed at least 50% of their applications were delivered on time and “with quality.”
Joyce Tompsett, general manager of the State of Agile project at Digital.ai, said the survey makes it clear many organizations are still trying to strike the right balance when it comes to developing software. For example, the survey finds the top two reasons organizations adopt Agile (tied at 41%) are to accelerate time to market and prioritize delivery and measure customer/business value. Most software development teams are being evaluated both based on velocity (33%) and the value delivered (29%), the survey finds.
The survey also identifies customer satisfaction (43%), time to delivery (39%) and competitive advantage (34%) as their top priorities for 2024.
In general, the survey finds that 33% of respondents reported business leaders and executives are actively leading and participating in company-wide agile transformation. However, more (41%) said there was not enough leadership participation. Well over a third (37%) said business teams simply don’t understand what Agile is or what it can do. More than a quarter (27%) said there is not enough training.
Not surprisingly, the most widely adopted methodology is Scrum (63%) with the Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe) being the most widely used (26%). Another 22% don’t have a mandated framework, while 12% said they have created their own.
The debate over what precisely constitutes agile development is, of course, ongoing. Each organization tends to adopt the elements of the framework that make the most sense for them, so the actual state of adoption from one organization to the next will vary widely. The one thing that is certain is the more complex the IT environment, the more challenging it can be to embrace agile development.
And there continues to be lots of room for improvement. If only two-thirds of organizations are delivering half (50%) of their applications on time with an acceptable level of quality, it means there are more projects that are failing to meet that standard than many software development teams might care to admit.
As more organizations become more dependent on software, however, tolerance for that level of failure will only continue to decline as businesses and leaders lose patience with application development practices that do not live up to expectations.
