MnArIONAI
~IAAEKTIKH KAI llOAITIKH !TON llpOIMO MAP:=;
Teooeper; J.LeAerer;
EK.:lOl:EIl: IlANEI1Il:THMIOY I1a'tQa, 1997
IIATPQN
© 1997
A. MIIArIONJU:: E~O~EI~ IIANEIII~THMIOY ISBN: 960-530-015-x E~O~EI~ IlANEIII~THMIOY IIavEmm:I'j!tLouJtoAI'j, PCo TI'jA.: 061-997.863, Fax: 997.864
IIATPQN
IIATPQN
KeV"(;pIKI} l(i8eOl}: EK06ueH; «EllI}VIKcl I'pdppntu. ~ r. I'evvudfou 5, 106 78 A8I}va "tI}A. 3817826, 3806661 - fax 3836658
[lpoAoro~ EI~ArflrH 9 II o [lPOMAPEI~TIKO~ YAI~MO~ KAI H KOINflNIKH T01' MAPE MAAEKTIKH~ KPITIKH ~TO [lPflIMO Epro 33 H !XELH TH~ XErKEAIANH~ ME TO MAPE]~MO ~1'M<pflNA ME TON ENrKEA~ ME00~OAOrIKE~ ~TA [lPflIMA AIIO'¥EI~ T01' MAPE T01' rIA THN KPITIKH 51 Errx T01' A~TIK01' KpATOn 83 H IIOAITIKH ~KE'¥H T01' MAPE KAI 0 BONAIIAPTI~MO~ 107 .
.
.lEVEe.. M.E. ()LXaLOAOyELtaLuno to YEyovoe. ara notbuux fQya TOV yw T11vuQmurj TOV aauxov UQaTOVr.lOVW[. 20-27.lnij OE [. o. Fr. {If TO {laQ.lEAEtEe. L1ll0tllxwe. [.o IeicvvLvwv(TO[.lf3avovtaL 0' cutnv tnv n EX()OOl]0 llQo{wQ. OL Mf8or'5oAoYLufr. [. XaL toll 'EvyxEAe. Ibeosovicu.lOnOLoUvtaL bUO 0XOAWO[. X. 0.lOnOLl]8EL H nuguno[. tEOOEQEe.24. Karl Marx xa: 11 cpLAoaocp{a.AnaVTWV' l] EX()OOl] K.lEtucpgaoELe. 'EyxllgEe.lEUe.UJmc6r.ll]e. Moscow-London. XfYUEAwvrjr. anoipeu.UJ{l6 oiuupcova {If TOV EVYUfAr. 83-101. Marx. KOLVWVLuwv EQfVVWV.lEVWVgyWV tl]e. EL Val UVEX()Otl]. Gutenberg. tl]e. <PLAOOocpLue. XaL toll 'EVYXEAe.23. EXEL Ex()o8EL OtOV roue Il cvem. Collected Works. XaL l] EX()OOl] K.lEAEtEe. tEUXOe. Engels. 1974. 1974.lUtLXO xuguxtijgu n XaL tELVOllV nQoe. EX01JVxgl]OL[. 1975. Teouavuau.lEtucpQaoELe. on nEQLAU[. tE1JXOe. tl] [.. 1:tLe. H aXfa11 T11r. TOV MaQ. xai 11KotVWVLUrj KQLUUrj ato nQWL{lO fQYO TOV MaQ.E. ngwL[.Ano w. Paris. Rubel.lE[. n. [. XQl]OL[.[. uno tov K. H llOALUUrj }. &aAfunurjr. EX(). EX()OOELe. o. EXOllVEx()o8EL oro Em8fWQ11mr. on to EgyO XaL l] OXE'\Pl]toll MaQI.o trun. oHga Pleidade.Uf1jJ11 TOVMaQ. A8ijvu. vAUJ{l6r. ono». <PLALvn. Gutenberg 1987.lUnxij EAAl]VLXij EX()OOl]EgyWV toll MaQI.logcpij EX()OOl]e.U1JtEe.EXOllVEvtux8EL. KotVWVLUWV EQfVVWV. Oeuvres.245-255. 1963 X. xai TO (3ovanaQnu6 cpatV6{lfVO EXH Ex()o8EL YUAALxa oro Em8fWQ11mr. ou EXOllV OllOtl][. ue . New York. Marx. 0 A8ijvu. 6Ev llnaQXH OllOtl][.X. nEQLO()Oll E tolle.
xm yaAALXEt.EYXUQEt.. H AOLJtij ~L~ALOYQacplanon XQl]OL!!OJtOLijSl]XEavacpEQETm ant. . rrou avmpEQov'tm ornv aYYALxij xm yaAALxij JtOAL'tLXij xm XOLvwvLXij L010Qla 10U oExa1Ou EVaTOU «uovc xm nou JtaQaJtE!!JtouV OEaYYALxEt. on Ol]!!avnxij SEOl] ornv EXOOOl] au'tij EXOUVOL aVaAUOELt. ornv JtOAL'tLXij xru EJtLO'tl]!!OVLXij JtmOEla xm O1OV JtVEU!!anXO JtOAL nouo 'tWV aV'tlO'tOLXWV XWQWv. ELOLxo'tEQa l] XQijOl] aYYALxwV xm yaAALxwv !!E'tmpQaOEWV OLxmOAOYEl'tm xm «no 'to yqOVOt.. oJtOU EXOUVYlVEL.!!E'tmpQaOELt. Jtl]yEt. uJtOOl]!!ELWOELt. 10U MaQS xru 10U EVYXEAt..
EI~ArnrH .
.
uno umEt. £JtLXaLQo[LoQqJijt. UVTLqJUTLXU nQot. ALO[LO.. QlU YLU TO LOTOQLXO ylyvw8aL. [LEQ£t. [LE80Dot. XaL nUQunAUVT]TLXOt. TOV K. «OOOLaALOLLXU YLaTl nOALTLxij roue... L TI2: MEPE2: MA2: EINAI. ij [LT]. cmO'1pT] umij SLO[LOt. n. X8T]X£ OTL T] XaTUQQ£UOT] TWV XU8WTWTWV OTL 0 [LUQSLO[LOt. LDE£t. Kunwt. TOU T] qJLAOOOqJlU TOU XEYX£A OTO DEXUTO E~DO[LO aLWVU T] qJLAOOOOUVDE£TaL [L£ TT]V OT][L£QLVij [L£ Duo [LOQqJEt. O£ OQLO[LEV£t. 8£wDLaTUnWVOij wt.. ~u8[LO ij EOTW exetTOut.. nUQ£sT]YT][LEOTT]V naLD£lU OTT]V £JtLOTT][LOVLXij XaL £SWT£- XaL OTOV nV£U[LUTLXO TOut. OU[LqJWVU [L£ TOV 8£wQij8T]x£ OTLt.OMENH H AIIO'¥H OTI 0 MAP«'1poqJLO OXUAl» Onwt. VTaL uno TOUt.OTT]V £XnaLD£mLxij EQ£UVU TOut. umijv D£V ElXUV 0XEOT] OUT£ [L£ TOV [LUQSLO[LO OUT£ [L£ TO mrrcov oooto- TT]V XQLTLxij UnOOTT]QlunOD£LXVUfL XaL Wt.XaL onwt. lDLOUt. OTOXUOTEt.A. OTT]V WWT£QLXij XU8WTWTa» TU XU8WTWTU ElVaL '1p£UDWVU[LOt. T] D£UT£QT] OqJElAfTaL H [LLU OUVDEfTaL [L£ TT]V U[LWT] ij JtLO nQooqJuTT] OTT]V XQlOT] xu8£ £Jtoxij [Lut. H XQlOT] TOU [LUQsLO[LOU rtou TT]TU. £XqJQusfTaL XUQlWt. OL XQLTLXEt. Jt£QLJtTWOfLt. xunOLO QLXij nOALTLxij TOUt. XQlOT]t.x. [L£ OQ80AOYLO[LOU OTT] «[L£TUV£WT£QLXij» H vcov nQWTT] [LOQqJij TT]t. UUTEt. YnOOTT]Qlx8T]X£ umu OLL 0 OQot. TOU [LUQSLO[LOU OUVDEfTaL £JtT]Q£UOTl')XUV uno TT]V XUTUQQ£UOT] TWV OOOLUALOTLXWV XU8WTWTWV rtou VEt.IME. XaL Wt. [LUQSLOTLXEt. anOT£A£l MUQS ElX£ 8£wQT]8£l qJlU TOU LJtLVOSu. IIunu"Lwuvvou .A. £lVaL s£Jt£QUO[LEVOt. nOALTLO[LO roue.
xaQaxtllQL~ovtm £VLOt£ coto ()ll!J.aQ~w!J.£tn OHQU tllt.WOUVII A£YO!J. nOALtLo!J. cpaV£QWVH xm rnv 8£WQlltLxi] XQ£wxonLa ton !J. !J. KOAaXOcpOXL nou ()£V xctcvoouv on ()£V !J. xorvorvtxrj. tWV t£XVOAOYLXUnQollY!J. xm tWV tsoonoorv !J.ata rtou oQL08£touv rnv av8Qwm vn unaQ~ll. avtavaxM I tll YEVWll £VOt.OU.at.o «no toy !J. EOtW xm at£Atlt. a' auto to £QWtll!J.oU or«. onwt. nQot. toy £Q!J. WtoQLat.O tllt. nQoona8£t va nQof3uAH tu OtOLX£La nou cpav£Qwvouv rnv anoouv8wll rou AOYOU. LxonOt.a !J..J.ata tllt. H XQLOll ton !J.OU onoto. Aa8£!J.14 xrrorsron MTIArIONA1: toy A. XOLVWVLXi]t.£Vll«veorreoixornro» va taun~otav !J. VEOU Ota()LOU tllt.i]v£uav.anxo £Qwtll!J. avoQ80AOYLO!J.£tOY OQ80AOYLouo.ot.a.Jttw!J.EQ£t.llt.aQ~LO!J. avoQ80AOYW!J.£toy !J.atLXot.EVWVx£cpaAmoxQatLxWv XOL VWVLWVxm LOWt.£ ! rnv uv811011rou avoQ80AOYLO!J. x av oEf3£tm tnv OtOLXHW()ll AOYLXi].Laton Myou va OUAAUf3Hto EOxata £QWti]!J.£taV£Wt£QLXOt. OUV()E£tm xm !J.oQCPi] oQ80AOYW!J. 0 !J..oU rtou tOVL~£ tnv t unotL8E!J.x.xm II XOLvwvLXi] nQaXtLxi] sunveovrov Wt.£tav£Wt£QLxi]» OXE'ljJll. O£ avtL8Wll n. toy avoQ80AOYLO!J. CPLAooocpLat.ou.nQot.I onoto !J.£tllV «uetcuovteovo» i] «!J. £~ao8EVWllt.a· £cp' OOOV0 MaQ~ ()£V unouovorva rnv OUAAOYLXi]nQu~ll uno rnv 8£wQLa nou rnv xat£U8uv£L xm rnv onotc II nQu~ll anooacpllvL~H.ooLoYQacpLxi] nQOXHoornrc 8EtoUV Eva nQaY!J. avtavaxAu r« oU!J.o xm tcuroxoov« on II ntwOll tout.£Vll a()UVa!J. toy onoto i]()ll 0 XULVt£YY£Q xm OL£JtLYOVOL rou. Av xm OL XQLtLXEt..aQ~LO!J.£tav£Wt£QLXOt. Eva f3a8!J. 0 !J. .£tuf3aOllt. aUtEt.Eva tautL~£0 tru !J.nOQ£Lav£Lt. ouvoxi]t.£A£tWVrtou anaQtL~OUV toy naQovta rouo £L vrn va ()08£L anuvtllOll..o. tllt.Lavis: !J.aQ~Lo!J. ()£V cpav£Qwv£L xm rnv 8£wQllnxi] av£JtuQx£La tcrv avaAUo£orv ton MaQ~ . ~wi]t.a av II xatuQQ£uOll xa8wtwtwv tWV oxotorv 0 nv£u!J. i] ton unaQ~Lo!J. tL8£tm to £QWtll!J.va unOOtllQL~H on rc A£YOusvo oomaALOtLXU xa8wtwta ()£V EXOUVOXEOll!J. O£ !J.anot£A£L ou!!Jttw!J.Ot.Ot.
tl']e. XQL nx~e. aCWa!-!Lfe.avtL8£ta. tl']e.OL XQLtLXEe.X. LOlJ MYOlJ. £xCPQa~£tm Jt. LOlJe.LOnX~e.lara too Mao. JtaQ£Q!-!TJVfL£e. tQOUJt08EOfLe.LO!-!OU OtTJVaJtoouv8wTJ tl']e. 0 uetoJ VfWt£QLX6e.. £. 8£WQLae. Sf XLvouv 6!-!we. 6Jtwe. 0 corooxcoucnxo. xaQaxt~Qae. 0 LCLOe. JtOlJ OlJyxaAUJtt£tm uno tnv £mCLW.ne.LOnX~e. rnv OQ80AOYLX~ OXE'\jJl'] m rnv £mOtTJ!-!OVLX~!-!E80co.x. C£V [!JtOQ£Lva aJtO!-!OVw8£L coto LO £QWtTJ!-!a u £LVaL ~wvtav6 XaL n £LVaLvexoo OLOlJe.l'] OlJOtl']!-!anx~e. 0 A. !-!aQ. avaY£L rnv JtaQolJoto rou !-!aQ. II6JtJt£Q JtOlJ lJJtOYQa!-!!-!L~£L tTJV lJJtOn8E!-!£Vl'] avtL8Wl'] tTJe.xm tn !-!OVO!-!EQfLa LOlJe. 6Jtwe. YLa tTJV JtaATJnov ta. tl']e. xm An6 ne. XaL ron 6AOlJ JtQOe. lJJtOn8E!-!fV£e..LOlJ MaQ. xm OW£XtLX~e. JtOlJ Cl']!-!OOL£UOvtm 0' am~ rnv EXCOOTJtQOXUJtt£L on LO £QWtl']!-!a n £Lvm ~wvtav6 XaL u fLVaL J vexoo OLOV MaQ. Aoov JtOlJ t6VL~f XlJQLWe.LO!-!OU JtOlJ JtTJya~£L cero LOV !-!£taV£wt£QLx6 avoQ80Aoyw!-!6 CLacpEQ£L t£A£LWe.!-!fAEt£e. OLa <Pavuxof. OL aJtOOLWJt~O£Le.LOnX~e. !-!aQ. AOYLx~e. acwa!-!L£e.. ceto XQmXEe.AIAAEKTIKH KAI IIOAITIKH ~TON IIPOIMO MAPE / EI~ArnrH 15 Jt. OQL~£L. LOlJ P. 6Jtwe. CLaA£XnX~e. ~ am~ LOlJ K. on OL XataOX£lJEe.LOtLX~e. avnJtaQa8EtOlJV to JtaLxvU'ha ton «<Jt0Xaouou».fWV ~ YLa rnv EVVOLa nov cwa!-!£wv xm 0XEO£WVJtaQaywy~e. JtaQa ne..£A6e.EAL. LOlJ Nt£QL vro. !-!aQ. OL OLWJtEe.o xao!-!ata. 8fwQLae. H «XQLtLX~» LOlJ !-!aQ... TEtOLa OtOLX£La £LVaL to l'hcpoQou!-!£vo rou YAWOOLXa £XcpQaO!-!EVOlJ yolJ.LO!-!OU Of aOlJvaQtl']tl'] CLaCOX~ cpaVtaOLaxwv OJttaOLWV xm t£ALxa £VtaOOfL tTJV «XQLtLX~» LOlJ !-!aQ. tEOO£Q£e. OXE'\jJTJe..l']e. tTJe.. !-!aQ.£JtLXQLtEe. ~ JtQay!-!anXEe.LOlJ II6JtJt£Q.8ELOW JtQay!-!anxa JtQo~M!-!ata xm £mOTJ!-!aLvow LOWe. LO y£yov6e. JtOlJ c£v £Lxav unooorpnvtoet tl'] 0XEOl'] tlJmx~e. LCLaLt£Qa OQLO!-!EVWV emvovorv rou MaQ.xaJtoLfe. xm cLaAfxnx~e. lOXtWV OJtOLWV0 AQ6v XaL 0 IIoJtJt£Q dVaL OL 0l']!-!avtLx6t£QOL . EVVOLae. LOlJ MyolJ xm CfV EXOW v6TJ!-!a. amEe. aVOQ80AOYLO!-!6e. «no OQ80AOYLXEe. M r xm rc x£va LOlJ. LOlJ MyolJ. !-!OQCP~e. x ne.
OXE'\jJl]e. o II6nnEQ Otl] !J. EQEUVEe. 8EWQLae.U8Lx08Ql]OXEUtLX~ avtLAl]'\jJl] YLa to LOtoQLX6 YLyvw8m.tou MaQ~ ELvm !J. xm tl]e.EVOU «no toy MaQ~ nQox'llJttEL ou l] !J.6 !J..aQ~LOtLX~ OLaAEXtLX~ OtEQEL tm vonucrr».EtQO rtou ELvm rnLyovoe. 0 II6nJtEQ XataAoYL~H orov MaQ~. woALxa 8EWQO'llo !J.EAEtl]YLa to ~ovaJtaQtLx6 qxuvouevo nQox'llJttH avtL8n:a 6tL l] !J.U8LX08Ql]XEmLX6 xm noocpl]tLx6 nVE'll!J.. nou avacpEQEtm OtO !J. autEe. toy «LOtOQLxLo!J. EQEwae.EAEtl]rou Ti eivai &aA£XTLX~ XataAOYL~H OtOUe. 0 Myoe. ton vonucro.EvOcno !J.. avtLcpaOl]e.EAEtl] YLa tnv aVaAUOl] ton ~oVanaQtLXO'll cpmV6!J.OLaAEXtLXO'lle. Qa xm orov MaQ~. ELVm ALy6tEQO QEUOt~ xm 6tL l] !J. PLA006cpoue. l]e.WWVtou 190U ouovo. XataAoyL~H. XOLVWVLX~e.~OAnrou otn YEVWl] tl]e.6» rtou 0 II6nJtEQ rou XataAoYL~H orrrv cJJrwX£w too IotoQLXWf.Evl]Evta~l] ton MaQ~ «no toy II6nJtEQ orn XOQEtanov «WtoQLXLOtwV». !J.EAEtl]nQox'llJttH 6tL l] 8EwQLa tl]e. LwrnWe. tl]e.6 ELvm o n naQa~AEnH to EQYO nov MaQ~ xm EVYXEAe. LOLWe.anov aoxn:l] nQoe.ata ton oxoaou.EtQOnou 0 MaQ~ ELvm «LOtoQLXLOt~e.EVl]e.aQ~LOtLX~EVVOLatl]e.aQ~wtLx~ 8EwQLa tl]e. LOtoQLX~e.Eru.aQ~LOtLX~e. xcro rov II6nnEQ.atLX~cero 600 0 Aoov tl]e. An6 tnv L()La !J. !J. nou avacpEQttm oro !J..LXQO'LOtOQLXEe. 6tL l] C a OLaAEXtLX~ ELvm tQ6noe.U8LX08Ql]OXEUtLXaoX~!J. OL avrnaQXHEe. autEe.. An6 tl] !J. tl]e. LOtoQLae.E'lln:m coro rnv aQX~ tl]e.WV. rorooiovocqxov w xcu tl] oU!J. MLa cero tLe.a.aQ~w!J. tl]e. EQE1JVae. ta~l]e.aQ~w!J. xata to !J. rtou avacpEQovtm orn yanLX~ nOAmx~ xm XOLVWVLX~ iorootc rorv !J.LEe. avayxm6tl]tae.E~EAL~l]e..La!J. tWV ta~EWV ELVm ALy6tEQO OXl]!J. t ioroou«. l] !J. An6 rnv . aouva!J.16 xrrorrros MIIArIONA~ «no amo'lle. rou XEYXEA.tou ouvmayttm r OW~L~a0!J. nou OEVOW!J. ntn to !J.yEVVLEtm uno OLWVELEQyaOtl]QLaXEe. otnv onoto xUQLaQXo'llv to !J.An6 tn !J. OEV EXH vonuo. e. LOtoQLae. !J.aQ~LOnX~ EVVOLa tl]e. rtou uL08n:o'llv OQ80AOYLXaXQL t~QLa. naAl]e.»to K EQYOton Etvm oLanOtLO!J.6E~l]Yo'llv xm rnv Aa8E!J. aVtLcpaOHe.
JtQOXUJtt£L on T] OLaA£xnx~ etvci xata XUQLO A6yo ~E80ooe. OXE'\j!T]e. xm JtAaVT]e. oJtwe.. H OLaA£xnx~ 8a unooooos va 8£wQl]8£L xm we. ~aQ~LOtLX~e. Av ~oav 8a wt£QOUVLO VO~~aLOe.. tnv OQL~£0 IIoJtJt£Q.X. H ~aQ~Lonx~ 8£WQLa.LOU Mnstopev. tnv aAAl]AO£~aQtl]on ~EQOUe. JtQO'UJt08Et£L T] xQmx~ LOU IIoJtJt£Q. OLa'\j!£UOT]e. ono».xataA~Y£L l] OLaAomx~ we.X.xm OAOU. £~mQEOHe. tQOXLEe. £v tnv £JtaAT]8£uouv.LlIAAEKTIKH KAI I10AlTIKH ~TON IIPnIMO MAPE / EI~ArnrH tQLtl] ~£Mtl] aUTlle.. aJtOXALO£Le. Jt.. Jt. 8£wQLae. Jt·X· l] '\j!UXOO CPUOLOAOYLa £Lvm £JtLOtl]~OVLX~ 8£WQLa YLaLL UJtoXHtm O£ JtOU OLa'\j!£UOl]av XQl]OL~OJtOLT]8dYLa va £~T]Yl]8d T]£~EAL~l] tl]e. xat' «urov £Lvm on unoxsruu OLO £VO£Xo~£VO tT]e. Ano ~La OLacpOQ£nx~ oxomc 8a ~tav ouvatov va A£X8d on T] ~aQ~Lonx~ 8£WQLa O£V £~LJttH ornv EVVOLatT]e. «£mxuxAOUe. LOLaLsoc OQLO~Eva OLOLX£Latl]e. OUOX£tL08£L ue XaLl]YOQL£e. xm ne.nov o JtAaVl]twv. £Lvm 1'000 £UEALXtT] oxrre xcvevo LOtOQLXOXOLVWVLXOO£OO~EVO va unv ~JtoQd va tT]V OLa'\j!£UO£L. oJtwe. £JtLOtl]~OVLX~e.JtOU aVacpEQ£tm orn ~£80ooAOYLa LOU MaQ~ oro JtQw'C~a EQya LOU xm coto tT]V O£ut£QT]~£A£tl] JtOU aVacpEQ£tm orn 0XEOl] LOU MaQ~ ue LOV XEYX£A xata tOY 'EVYX£Ae.8£WQLae. EXOOOl]e. ~OUOLX~e. JtOU £Q~l]V£U£L ne. avncpaO£Le. ~E80ooe. XaQaXtT]QLOtLXO ~Lae.. r«. oJtwe. non dvm LOLaLt£Qa cpav£Q~ Jt. aM8£Lae.. smorn~OVLX~e. JtOU Y£VVLouvrm xm JtQOOWQLa ~£Jt£QVLOUVtm xata tnv OUV£LOl]OLaX~ v xm LOtOQLXOXOLVWVLX~£~EAL~T] YLa va y£vvl]80uv noiouxc OLaCPOQ£tLXEe. AOYLX~ XaLa LO ~EtQO nou JtQO'UJt08Et£L OQLO~Eva a~Lw~ata. tl]e.l] XOO~oAoYLa LOU IILOA£~aLou £JtOnaJtAaoLa~£ LOUe.» YLa va £~l]Y~OH tLe. rnv aQX~ LOU YLyvw8m. OL JtQotaO£Le. oJtwe. aJtoxALO£Le.LOU AQLOLOtEAl] ~ tT]e. ornv aVaAUOl] LOU ~ovaJtaQtLXOu cpmvo~E- . 8£WQLae. avncpaO£Le. x.c. av qxuvouevorv OLOJtOL£e. T] OLaA£r xnx~ ~ l] JtaAT] tWV ta~£wv x.Auto ou~aLvH YLaLL T] ~aQ~Lonx~ 8£wQLa EX£LtT]V taoT] va JtoAAaJtAaOLa~£L ne. OtLe. H £u£AL~La tl]e. ouo». OJtOL£e.c..X. O£v £Lvm avncpanXEe.
LOtOQLar.. toy AOYLX~r. XaL nov teoocoov !l£AftWV t1']r. t1']r. nou avacpEQftaL XaL OtO It£QL£X6!l£vO ton A6you xa8wr. EXCOO1']r. !laQsLOnx~r..xaQaxt~Qar. avncpaoELr. cpaL V6!l£VO XOLVWVLX~r. £s£ta08d 1']£sEALS1'] non s£XLV1']O£oto nr. rro t1']V aVaAU01'] tou ~ovaJtaQnxou CPaLVO!lEVOUaL LCLaLt£Qa X otOLxda t1']r. va avaox£uaoEL tOY uercveorreotxo aVOQ80AOYLO!l6. £LVaL1']E!lCPa01'] Ot1']V£JtLcQa01']Jt£QL8wQLOltOL1']!lEVWV XOLVWVLXWV o!lacwv oro LOtoQLXOXOLVWVLX6 YLYV£- . M1'] !lltoQwvtar. 1']!laQsLonx~ 8£WQLa t1']r. 8£(J)QLar.aJtoouv8w1']r. 8£wQLar. t1']r. !l£tav£Wt£QLX~r. avaAuOUr. Axevovrtoc 1']!laQSLonx~ 8£WQLa t1']r. ltaQaCOXEr. LotoQLar..X. to £Qdn1']!la av 1']£U£ALsLaXaL 1']nooocouoouaornto oe VEa C£CO!lEVa!lLar..nou 1llt0Q£Lvo 8£!l£ALW8d 0' ama. 1']!laQsLOtLX~ t1']r. XaL t1']r. LOtOQLar. OtaCLO t1']r. nou xaQaxt1']QL~OUVt1']V £SEALS~ tou. tOU YLa toy CLa!l£ALO!l6 XaL t1']V altoouv8w1'] tOU A6you. 8£WQLar. am~r. 8a £vLoxu8d 1']a!lcpL~OALaYLa rc XQLt~QLa £JtLOt1']!lOVLX6t1']tar. torv LC£WV. t1']r. LOtoQLar. XaL oru. C£V !lltOQ£L va «vcoxeuaOELtOY aVOQ80AOYLO!l6t1']r. YLatL C£V s£XLVaEL «no tLr.IIaQa!lEVEL6!lwr.6ltwr. tnv xa8Lota !-UI£JtLOt1']!lOVLX~v YLVOUV e C£Xta tn XQLt~QLa ton II6ltJt£Q YLa t1']V £JtLOt1']!lOVLx6t1']ta!lLar. O£ Eva cLacpoQ£tLx6 !l£AAovnx6 OtaCLO t1']r. £Jtox~r.IS xrrorrros MTIArIONA1: YOU. rorook«. !l£ta~a01']r. !lltOQ£L oxrrooo va toy £s1']y~ou wr. ouvixpcouevo ue ltQOOWQLa XOL v VWVLxa aCLEsoca XaL wr. omo. tou II6ltJt£Q XaL YLa t1']V XQLtLX~ t1']r. !lU8LX08Q1']ox£UnXEr. Av It. LOtOQLar. XOLVWVLX~r. ltQO£Xt£LVEL6XL uovov toy rumxo OQ80AOYLO!l6.ltaQac otaoHr. tWV IIu8ayoQ£Lwv YLa tOY ~ALO XaL XatEA1']S£ Ot1']V 1']ALOX£vtQLX~ XOO!lOAOYLatou KOJtEQVLXOU XaL ton faALAaLOU. !laQsLOnX~r. tUJtLX~r. H !laQsLOnx~ 8£WQLat1']r. o OQ80AOYLX6r.MLa tsroi« £S~Y1']01'] XQ1']CJL!lOltOL~OEL rtoo'ru8a wr. 8£WQLar.£JtL~£~aLWV£taL«no nr. acpaLQ£L avayxaOtLXa toy £JtLOt1']!lOVLX6 xaQaXt~Qa t1']r.LOtoQLar.rtou Jt£QLOQL~EL A6yo Ot1']Vt~Q1']01']rcov aSLW!latWv t1']r. aAAa XaL toy CLaA£xnx6 OQ80AOYLO!l6.~ rorv !la81']!lanxwv..
tT]~ yvw(Jti)~ vrm. OLaAEXtLxi).TEtoLE~ aQXE~ ELvm OL E~i)~· T] L(JtoQLa dvm . (JtOV auto OL !lEAEtE~ Jtou JtEQLAa!l~avovtm erroreH evornr« JtaQa tu oLaCjJoQEtLXO 8E!lata OAE~ uutou rtou JtQaY!latEuoMaQ~. YLatL OL aQXE~ nou JtQO'liJt08EtOUV OL oro (JUVOAO tOU EQYOU tOU dvm ouotcv OL LOLE~. (JxbjJT]~. EJtL(JT]~va (JU!l~aAo'UV (JtT]V E~i)YT](JT]tOU !lEtaVEwtEQL- oro ~a8!l0 nou xm curo. OL (JtQE~M~ !lOQCjJE~JtaAT]~ tWV ta~EWV.X. LOLaLtEQa tnv yLatL oro EQYO rou MaQ~ ovcueou rnv ortotu T] (JXE'\jJT] tOU MaQ~ ELvm EJtT]QEa~Etm xm xm aJto tOY OU!lavL(J!lO.tL 0 rXQa!l(JL 8a OVO!la(JEL «XOLVWVLtT]~ aQxou(Ja~ a(JtLxi)~ XOLVWVLXOU xm xa8wtw~ JtOALtLXOU aOLE~OOOU (J'UVELOT](JT]~ tT]~ EQyatLxa8w~ xm T] ta(JT] xm tT]V LOWAOYLa. OQL(J!lEVE~ O~uOEQxd~ JtaQatT]aAAa xm !lEta~a(JT]~ (JE EVa 8a unoaJtotEAEL 'EVYXEA~ YLa tT]V JtaQEXXALVOU(Ja (JU!lJtEQLCjJOQaW~ XOLVWVLXi)~ JtaQaX!li)~ OLCjJOQEtLXOOLXOVO!lLXO xcu XOLVWVLXO (JXT]!latL(J!lo avoQ80AOYL(J!lOU.T] aJtO(Jta(JLOJtOLT](JT]coto tT]V JtOALtLxi) xm T] JtaQaLtT](JT] ta~T]~. Jt. toy xi) T]YE!lOVLa» (JTJ!laVtLXWV (JtQW!latwv «no tT]V aJtWAELa ta~Lxi)~ xi)~ ta~T]~ UJtO to ~ovaJtaQtLXO tT]~ aYQOtLxi)~ xmQo(JXOJtLXO Qi)(JEL~ tou (JU!lJttW!la ooixmv xou ta~T]~ JtQO~ tT]V !WLQOAatQLXi) XUVL(J!lO JtOU EXtQECjJEtm coto ami)v JtL(JtT] (JE 8EO(JtaAtoU~ aVOQE~. T] CJ1JYXQOU(JT] OaVEL(JtwV xm OCjJELAEtWV. H 8E(JT] rou AAtOU(JEQ YLa MaQ~ OEV YLVEtm rnv «toun» (JtO EQYO xm tTl (JXE'\jJT]on t ton MaQ~ cotexat' T] OEXti) (JtT]V EXOO(JT]ami) avaAu(Jw. T] EVtUJtW(JT] JtOU JtT]ya~EL «no rou O. JtEQLOOOnou xaQaXtT]QL~Etm AU(JEL~ Jtou 8E!lEALwVOVtm !latLxou tuJtou coto xa8aQa (JE !lLa avayxmotT]ta oJtw~ T] (JJtLVO~LXi). Avcosoovrct XQi)(JT] tou orov «JtQWL!lO» EQYO ton ooo» OEV (J'UVL(Jta aJtoooxi) 8E(JT]~ tOU AA toU(JEQ YLa «toun» (JE !lLa nEQLOOO xata «JtQo!laQ~L(JtLxi)>> a(JtLxi)~ CjJLa. rouo !loQCjJi) JtaQExxAL AOUV vouo«.IIIAAEKTIKH KAI TIOAITIKH ~TON TIPQ]MO MAPS I EI~ArnrH 19 (J8m. tT]V XEyxEALavi) CjJLAO(JO!lLa XUQLW~ «!laQ~L(JtLxi)>> EJtL(JtT]!lOVLXE~ avaAOYLXO!la8T]- JtQOEAEU(JEW~ LowAoYLa.
EE!lJtOQEUOL!lO O aVnXEL!lEVO orov XEcpaAmOXQanxo OLXOVO!lLXOxm XOLVWVLXO0Xl]!lan0!l0. l] AELtoUQYLatl]e:. uJtaQ~l]e:. Ano tnv aJto'\jJl] ami] !lE to Kupasaio aQXL~EL nEQLOl] {)oe:. {)1JVa!lELe:. OL aQXEe:..aAr toUOEQLavEe:.aUtEe:. «no rnv aJto'\jJl] on JtQOUJt08EJ XaL touv on uJtaQXEL01JVEXELa vousou ornv XEYXEALavi] CPLAOOOo cpLa XaL tn !laQ~LOtLxi] 8EWQLa.»JtOUaJtAwe:.ouxva tn YQacpEtaL. WQL!lotl]tae:.rnv KQl Tlut} iOV nQoYQal1/-WiO~ rTJ~ Gotha. taL on oro Kupascuo uJtaQXEL AEJtto!lEQi]e:. AJtAWe:. L{)EOAOYLae:. toUAaxLOtoV xata rnv aJto'\jJl] tou MaQ~.20 AYron:Tm: MIlAnONA~ 8qlEALW{)l]e:.JtOU tl]e:. JtaQaywyi]e:. WQL!lotl]tat. to xQatoe:. EL vru l] VOl]Ol] xm 0 OtoxaO!loe:.tl]e:. 8EWQLaYLa tl] !lEta~aOl] l] coto tOY JtQOYEVEOtEQO orov !lEtaYEVEOtEQO OLXOV0!lLXOXaL XOLVWVLXO 0Xl]!latLO!lO. U ne:... aVEQX0!lEVl]e:. XaL rou EQYOU tou MaQ~. ton MaQ~. xm to {)LXmO UJtl]QEtoUV rnv EXaOtotE EQXOUOata~l] aAAa EJtl]QEa~OVtm xm coto rnv JtLEOl]tl]e:. JtOVO!lEU01JV 0XEOELe:. 'OJtwe:. OL aQXEe:. aVaAUEtaL {)LE~O{)LXa ornv {)EUtEQl] !lEAEtl]. OL JtaQaYWYLXEe:. outo vc Ol]!laLVEL on Jtauo1JV va aJtaOXOAOUVtoy MaQ~ t« JtQo~Ai]!lata JtOUJtQay!latEUEtm oro JtQWL!lOEQYO rou to OJtOLO E~Eta~EtaL E{)W.a~l]e:. 0 XEYXEA ELXEaVtLOtQE'\jJEL tl] {)WAExnxi] YWtL ~EXLVOUOE «no tnv XOQUCPWOl] av8Qwmvl]e:. l] avacpoQa orov JtQWL!lOMaQ~ OE ovu{)LaOtoAi] JtQoe:. {)LXmOAOYEL coto to YEYOVoe:.JtQouJtotL8Etm oro JtQWL!lOEQYOtou MaQ~. xatEu8uvouv rn OXE'\jJl]xm to EQYOton MaQ~ coto rnv rEQ/-WVlUt} I&oAoy{a We:. XWQLe:. xm 0XL coto rn ~aOl] tl]e:.ou to uou cutou aVtLtL8EvtaL JtQoe:. rtou . avaA UOl] tOU 0Xl]!lanO!lOU tl]e:. tQOOEYYLOELe:. oJtwe:.EmOti]!ll] ton av8QwJtou.toy MaQ~ tl]e:. EQyaoLae:.. {)EV «avaJtO{)OYUQL~EL» i] «aVtLOtQECPEL» {)LaAExnxi] rou XEYXEA. IIaQa rnv 8E!lEALW{)l]svomr« tl]e:. l] !laQ~LOtLxi] 8EWQLaYLa rn {)LaAExnxi]. l] JtaAl] tWV t ta~EWV. OXE'\jJl]e:. l] !lEta~oAi] tl]e:.tLe:.. toVL~Ovtm ue {)LacpoQEtLxi] E!lCPaOl]ore {)LacpOQa a EQya rou MaQ~. mEe:. xm toy !lEtaYEVEOtEQO MaQI. OL avaAUOELe:. «UnEQa~Lae:.
Ih8avwe.lOnxi] OlaA.£t'Y]t'Y]e. £xoooY]e. vaA.eLvm ~£Qoe..O torv XOlVWVlXWV 0X£OfWV non ovcottuoou 0 uv8Qwrtoc. avaA..YVWQl~f.6ywv Yla t'Y]VfQyaoLa.EXnxi] toll X£YXEA. uovo nov oQaOt'Y]QlOti]twv nou xaQaXt'Y]QL~OllVt'Y]Vav8Qwmv'Y] unaQ~'Y].lavi]e. CPlA. Ennoi] 0 oroxcouo. xm 'Y] W OllveLO'Y]O'Y] eLvm ~£Qoe... Oi ~EA. OlaA.uone. t'Y]C:.lavi]e.uone. 600 xm «no ooiousvc lOfaA. to OUVOA.~E t'Y]VllA.lavi] 8EwQLa Yla t'Y]OlaA.fXnxi]e. Yla ouv£XEla XEyxEA. xm 6Xl 0X£o'Y] avtL8w'Y]e.: / EI1:ArnrH 21 eL vm 'Y]nQa~'Y] xm l('JLaLEQa 'Y]EQyaoLa. 6nwe.uone. xm ~aQ~l(Jnxi]e.. ~UA. toll X£YXEA.CPUOlXUooouevn. OlaA. fLvm 0X£o'Y] Oll~nA.H ouvucpEla auti] fmj3Ej3mwvn t'Y] 8£0'Y]Yla t'Y]V ouvsXEla XEyxEA.EXnxi]e.'Y]Qw~atlx6t'Y]tae. eLvru 0 veoxovucviouot. xm OlaA.Enxi] ron MaQ~.fXnxi]e.lWVEtm oro Yfyov6e.EXnxi]e. Lto £QYo nuro 0 Lukacs oeLXVElt'Y]o'Y]~avtlxi] EJtLoQaO'Y] t'Y]VXfyxEA. CPllOlX6xm XOlVWVlX6 OV.UXLOtov 6nwe.£xooo'Y]e.XEYXEA.LOnxi]e.lOnxi] OlaA.EVlVLOtlXi] fQ~'Y]veLa toll ~aQ~lO~OU.e. we.'Y]Qw80uv cero OQLO~£VEe.nQay~utwv Yla va unoxataota8EL a ' ami]v 'Y]tU~'Y]nou oUV£A.'IJOEle.lO£aA. allti] fLvm 'Y] 0X£o'Y]t'Y]e. £nEtm on ceto ~aQ~LOtlxi] oxomu'Y] lO£aA.lavi]e. ton rouou 8a unoooooov va ou~A. 0 MaQ~ UL08EtEL ro t oxi]~ata t'Y]e. tOllA. onotfe.uyyA. t'Y]V EQ~'Y]vEun ou~cpwva ue t'Y]V OEUtfQ'Y]~fA. 6nwe.LOta 8a i]tav oQ86 va YLVEl A. O'EVYXfA.IIIAAEKTIKH KAI IIOAITIKH 1:TON IIPQ]MO MAP:. xooo'Y]e. llAwnxi]e. ton Lukacs oro £QYo tou 0 vto~ a XtYUfA.EXnxi] nou uox'Y]oav or O avaA..fxnxi]e. xm ~aQ~lOtlxi]e. 'lowe. Oi avaA.An6 ne. tU~'Y]e. 0 X£YXEA. rou MaQ~.EXnxi]e.OoocpLae.Y]e. OlaA. avayvwQL~Etm xm «no tov X£YXEA.lavi]e. t . OWA. non 8f~fA.lOnXU QEu~ata ton axootou oiorvo. H ouvucpEla ~Eta~u fQyaoLae. 8a llnOOt'Y]QlX8fL t600 coto t'Y]V A. t'Y]e. ~E tOY YOU tou xm t'Y]V cpaVtaOLa tou.WV OlXOVO~OA.£tEe. xm ~aQ~lonxi]e. on 'Y]fQyaoLa o'Y]~aLVEl «ovnon t'Y]e. Autn £(paQ~6~n ornv f~i]y'Y]O'Y] 'lJ lOtoQlXOU yLyvw8m.aj3f 0 uv8Qwnoe. ne. OlaA. YEVlX6tfQa. nQoxuJttEl onoioonnors on 'Y] £ OX£o'Y]XfyxEA.6yoe. 'Y]onoto xa80QL~Etm we.
X.tm orto to y£yovo~ OtL ooiouevc xd~£va oJtw~ 'Y] Ayia OtUOytvEW .aXQL~fat£Qa w~ JtQo£tOL~aaLa t'Y]~~aQ~WtLxi]~ 8£wQLa~ YLa t'Y]VJtaA'Y]rcov ta~£wv. nou avaAU£tm oro VWO fQYO tou. Lt'Y]V Jt£QLJttwa'Y]tou Kouuovvurtixou Mavupeoto» 0 MaQ~ xm 0 'EVYX£A~ fXOUV w~ aCjJ£t'Y]QLal1~ t aUYYQaCjJi]~roix tv« ax£oLaa~a tOU 'EVYX£A~. how o~w- . n auto xm 'Y]aXfa'Y]XfYX£A xm MaQ~ £~£ta~£tUL eero t'Y]V£Q~'Y]v£UtLxi]aXOJtLa tau 'EVYX£A~ ornv O£ut£Q'Y] £AfL'Y] ~ t'Y]~fxooa'Y]~. av xm avaCjJfQ£tm oru. aUYXQouafL~ JtOUxa8ogl~ouv t'Y]V torootc t'Y]~ ata~Lxi]~ ouvetononc. 8a unoooooe va 8£wQ'Y]8d w~ ~La «no tL~ Jt'Y]Yf~. Jt. OCjJ£LAOVtm om YQaCjJLoaxru tWV ouo. av8QWJtLatLxf~ £JtLati]~£~. LOLaLt£Qat'Y]~Y£Q~avLxi]~ CjJLAoaoCjJLa~ o£xatOU tou svctou ouovc. H 8£wQLa auti] £Lvm a~CjJL~oA'Y] YLatL oQLa~fv£~ «no tL~ aQXf~ t'Y]~oLaA£XtLxi]~. JtOU Jt£QLYQaCjJ£tmern c:I>mVOf. £CjJaQ~o~ovta~ tL~ avaAUafL~ ton MaQ~ ornv urrootc nov £JtWt'Y]~c.lEVoAoyia rov Ilveouato. naQO~OLa.c.22 AYrOYLTm: MTIArIONAZ auti]~ JtOU aVaCjJfQOvtm ornv ~£8000AOYLa rou MaQ~ xm oto ~ovaJtaQtLxo qxnvouevo O£LXVOUVt'Y] aUVfXfLa JtOU UmXQXfL cvoueoc ern X£YX£ALavi] aVaAUa'Y] t'Y]~ «xoworvtc. OLaVtLCjJaafL~rtou «vcorrooou 0 atoxaa~o~ Xata t'Y]V £~£A£XtLXi] tOU JtoQda rou. LOLaLt£Qat'Y]V£8voAoYLa.lavturj J&oAoyia x. nov LOLUltorv» orn c:I>tAoaocpia rov Lltuaiov xm orn ~aQ~LatLxi] aVaA1Jon t'Y]~X£CjJaAmoxQatLxi]~ xoworvtcc.ilV xm oru. 1] FeQf. Ott 0 'EVYX£A~ auv£XL~£Ltov oroxcouo tou MaQ~ £JtL~£~mwv£. 0 'EVYX£A~t£LV£Lva cototau ~axQuv8d cero rov MaQ~ w~ JtQO~t'Y]VJtQay~atL a~CjJL~oA'Y]8£UlQLa ton YLa t'Y]oLaA£XtLxi] t'Y]~CjJua'Y]~. rnv XOLvWVLXi]av8QwJtoAoYLa xm aAA£~ ana xm ornv urtootc tl1~ CjJLAoaoCjJLa~. tou X£YX£A. H «OLaA£XtLxi] ton OOVAOU XaL tOU XUQLOU» xru 'Y]8aVaaL~'Y] ava~ftQ'Y]a'Y] ~£ta~v roue. Lt'Y]V O£ut£Q'Y] £Aft'Y] t'Y]~fxooa'Y]~ auti]~ YL ~ verm O£XtO OtL 0 'EVYX£A~ auv£XL~fL tov atoxaa~o xm to fQYO tau MaQ~. H xauurtaon r1]~ EQyauurj~ T(Xs1]~ otnv AyyAia tOU 'EVYX£A~ «not£A£L Jt'Y]Yr1 Kepasaioirus» MaQ~.
on l'] LOtoQLa ELvm l'] 8E!lEALWOl']e. Aurn tLvm cpavEQ~ orov Aovbof3iuo qJOVEQf. t TIQEJtELO!lWe. Timpanaro ornv ItaALa.ELvm xataXQT]onx~. tOU S. 0 Haldane. YAWOOae. Anderson. xm rcrootcc. To 8E!la tT]e. OUVEXL~ELrnv !laQ~LOnx~ oxbjJl'] OEVEL vru anoOExt~ coro toy AEY0!lEVOounxo !laQ~LO!lO. av 0 ooo. av cvrpcouv oro ounxo !laQ~LO!lo. !laQ~LOtLX~e.. tT]e. tou 8EnXLO!lOu. cpUOl']e. ~mQEOELe. nou va !IT]VELvm !lEtacpOQLXOe. anoOExt~ xm «no toy MaQ~. rou emornuovtO!lOU ton aAAa xm tl']e. touAaXLOtov «no rnv oxom« OQLO!lEVWV !lEAEtl']tWV onwe. nOAAwv aYYAwv !laQ~LOtWv. r EVOEX0!lEVWe. 8EOl']e. 0 Bernal x.H oLaAEXtLX~ tl']e. YLa rnv OAOXAl']QW!lEVl'] EQ!ll']VELaton LOtoQLXOUYLyvw8m oe auyxQLOT] ue toy 8EWQl']oioxo xm aVLatoQLxo UALO!lOtou <PouEQ!lnax. i1K cpvar}~ ton XEYXEA orov MaQ~ xm toy 'EVYXEAe.. ztou O!lWe. oLaAExnx~e. OtL 0 !laQ~LO!lOe. 0 P.. tT]e. «ovtupcOT]»avacpEQEtm OE qxnvouev« nOALxotT]tae. onwe. cpUOT]e. tT]e.oLaAExnx~e.. cpUOT]e. nQoo~AWOl']e. cpUOT]e. KAaaatuJj~ qJtAoaocpia~. tL ver a!lcpL~oAO. OUVELOT]OT]e. XEyxEALav~e. atO!lLX~e. Lto EQYO auto 0 'EVYXEAe. ~ aAAT]AOaJtOXAELOuevc OtOLXELa. anotEAEL !lanOV ExcpQaOl']!lEtacpoQLxoU otoxao!lou. xm OUAAOYLX~e. KataAoYL~Etm otov 'EVYXEAe. va ocpELAEtm OtT]V EJtLoQaOT] ov Ilaoaooaeoiv CptAOn aotpuu. EL TIL8avwe. 8EOl']e.EmOt~!lT] tou av8Qwnou xm tl']e.LlIAAEKTIKH KAI IIOAITIKH ~TON TIPQ]MO MAPS / EI~ArorH 23 vonuo We.on aAAOLWVELrnv !laQ~LOtLX~ OXE'\jJl']E~mtLae.lJTaX xa: TO riAo~ tnc Teouavixtu. H naQaoox~ on 0 'EVYXEAe. ue nOAAEe. ELVm MOXOAO va YLVEL A6yoe.. tLvm EJtLOt~!lT] ue rnv evvot« rtou ELvm EmOt~!ll']l'] xaQtWLav~ ~ l'] VEutWVELa cpUOLX~. va naQatT]QT]8EL OtL T] 8EwQLa YLa tn oLaAExnx~ tT]e. EXtoe. nou rnv anOtEAOUV ~EXLVOUV orro rnv naQaoox~ tT]e. LOEaALOnX~e.O!lCDe. OEV OU~T]ttLtm OtT]V EXOOOT]aut~ YLatL OL !lEAEtEe. tT]e. vet m8avwe. fLa ovnqxioeu. rou orn CPLAooocpLarou XEYXEA.H XQ~OT] ou aut~ O!lWC. nQOe. OL EmcpuAa~ELe.tovL~EL tnv UJtEQOX~xm tT]V vovuiornt« tl']e. E n.o. . tT]V E~EAL~T]ou OtoXaO!lOU xm tT]e.X.
aQt.WIJ. nQoe.LXU6LacpoQ£tLxi] uno rnv 8Q'l10X£mLxi] nLOt'l1.H 0 lJ.o O£ ovroxovto.OC.OC.aQt.X.OVtoAOYLac. rrou cnotexouv rnv Ex60o'l1 ami] t.WIJ.24 AYrOn:TOl. tou L.nEQaOlJ. av £t.OVa oiore va xataAi]t.· o OL IJ.£taL ouxvu aAM 0XL novto.£tav£wt£QLXOe.O IJ. MIIArIONAl.Anoucxouvovtn.i]t'l1o'l1 AOYLXi]C.OVO xatu to IJ. taLQLu1.LOIJ.£XCPQU1. Qo£Xt£LVH n to 6LaA£XtLXO OQ80AOYWIJ.atLxi] OXEtjJ'l1 X rtou 0 Heidegger XaL o lJ.'l1V£LVaL QL1.wc.'l18£Lxav£LC.aQt.H IJ. uvoxi]C.H au8£vtLxu tOY MaQt.wlJ.aQt. toy xLv6uvo va lJ.OU. tOY £XCPQU1.aQt.'l18d xav£Le.O.£AEt£C.. Colletti. 0CP£LAOVtal ornv rtenotXal 8'l1o'l1on av YLVH 6£xto OtL 0 'EVYX£Ae.rrou va IJ.£XLVOUV«no rnv naQa60xi] OtL 'l1xw6LXOnOL'l1IJ.Otou XEYX£A XaL ElJ.LOIJ. 0 lJ.£taBA'l18d 0 lJ.OC.O tOU ~LacpWtWlJ.WIJ.ovtal rnv OLWVH na80AoYLxi] 6UOJtLOtLa £xnQoownwv ton 6unxou lJ...£u£taL nrro onoroorptore xovovc i] ava1.O-A£VLVWIJ. 0 lJ.nou 6'l1IJ.aQt.aQt.OVLXi]. «no toy lJ.WatOY oQ80AOYLOIJ.£ rnv 6UOJtLOtLa anEvavn ern xw6LxOnOL'l1IJ.EV'l1.tou cnorexouv rnv Ex60o'l1 auti] 6£v OUIJ.OQ80AOYLXi]C.UAAOVa(n:i]QLXt£e.EV'l1 ExcpQaO'l1nLOt'l1C.OC.OUanEvavn OtOV lJ. rnv 6LaA£xtLxi] t'l1e.IJ. av 8ulJ. nOAUtLlJ. rovurov tOOO £nLIJ.lJ.6-A£VLVLOIJ.ou.wIJ.0QCPi] IJ. cpUO'l1e...aQt. XaL naL6dae.£QLr 1.O orotX£LOt'l1C..OVO n .aon au8£vnxi] OXEtjJ'l1 £LVal ami] rrou 6£v 6wlJ. H 6UOJtLOtLa auti] £Jt£Xt£LVH t'l1 6UOJtLOtLa roix orrevcvn OtOV 'EVYX£AC.Oouv6E£tal IJ.Jt.OUV OtO OUlJ.OC. £ xw6LXOnOL'l1O IJ.EtQOnou t£LVH va lJ. OL IJ.£AEt£C.EV'l1 aL oUOt'l1lJ.OOL£UOVtaL Ot'l1V Ex60o'l1 ami] nQoUn08Etouv OtL 0 lJ.WIJ. aQu60o'l1C. av 8ulJ. £LVaL unoXQ£wtLXU ovue6£v JtLOt'l1IJ. tnv 8Q'l10X£UtLXi] nQoEA£UO'l1rou CPLAOOOCPLXOU xM60u t'l1C.wIJ.O-A£VLVWIJ. YQaJttu onwe. tou 6unxou lJ. H tUO'l1 ami] ouv£JtuY£taL.Oe.-A£VLVLOIJ.Oc.£taBuAH tOY lJ. oxou« XaL EYXHQL6Laxi] 1J. xru OL IJ. toy lJ. we. £LVal IJ.OC.XaL tOY lJ.O tou 'EVYX£Ae.£AEt£C.£tnv onot« £xcpQu1.-A£VLVWIJ.wIJ.aQt.alQEOH xavde.aQt. r« fPLAoaoqmcC1 TETQC1c5La tOU AEVLV.aQt. avoQ80AOYWIJ.LOIJ.WIJ.aQt.H 6UOJtLotLa anEVaVtL OtOV 'EVYX£AC.
6XL aUL6 ou 0 ~aQ~L(J~6~ aQxmoEAAl]VLXr] YVWOl]~. Jt. (JE 0XE(Jl] ~E 'tOV NanOAEOVLa 'tOV I" (JE 0XEOl] ~E JtEQL8wQLaxou~ JtOU 'tOV UJtO(J'tl]QL~OUV. OJtw~ (JE OQL(J~EVE~ 8EWQl]nXE~ UJt60 (Jw(J'ta JtaQa'tr]Ql](JE UJt08E(JEL~ xm XELV'taL 'tl]~ OJtOLa~ tn JtQO(JWQLva (JU~JtEQa(J~aLa 'EVYXEA~ 0 ~aQ~w~6~ .n.JtOU avacpEQOVLaL OE aULE~. JtQOJtEQLOXr] YLa rnv av8Qwmvl] L'tl]V aJto1jJl] (Jx£1jJl]. aAM xm ~E86oou (Jl]~a(JLa 'tl]~ EX JtQOOL~LOU aAl]8LVr]~ r] ~E~ml]~ ue 'tl]V VEWLEQl] XaL aUYXQOVl] (Jl]~a(JLa 'tl]~ 8EWQLa~ JtOU EQEuva LL~ (JXE(JEL~~E'ta~u OLacpOQE'tLXWv xorn- YOQLWV CPaLVO~EVWVXaL XULaAr]YEL (JE JtQOLaOEL~ UJtOXEL~EVE~ OE EAEYXO. liJt08E'tEL 6'tL 8a uJtaQXEL ono». 0 ~aQ~w~6~ ELvm Em(J'tr]~l] ~E'tQO JtOU ELVm ~E80oo~ XOLVWVLXWV xru WtoQLXWV cpmVO~EVWV l] OJtOLa 8E~EALWVE'tm. OE LL OLacpEQEL l] AL~EAAO NanOAfWV 0 M~uQ6~ tou ELVaL L'tO JtQWL~O EQYO'tOU MaQ~ YEVLx6'tEQa OL avaAU(JEL~ 'tOU ~E ~LOAOYLXE~ EXCPQaOEL~ JtOU ouxva ELVaL ouvixpuoueva. roix U~QWLLXE~.X.X. VEW (JE 0XE(Jl] ~E 'tOU~ VEOXEYXEALavou~ Ma~ L'tLQVEQ XaL ornv Ayia O~UOYfMnoou- VO MJtaOUEQ x. 6(J0 aVaAU(Jl]~ (JUVELOl](JWXWV. 8a r]'tav OUVaL6 va OLaLUJtW8EL l] E~r]~ aVLLQQl]Ol]: IIw~ xaQax'tr]Qa ELVaL OUVaL6v vc EXELEJtLOLl]~VLx6 toy ~La 8EWQLa JtOU ELVaL OLanO'tLO~EVl] «no roono JtOAE~L- ax£1jJl]~ XUL £xcpQa(Jl]~ JtOU 'taLQLa~EL oro AL~EAAo XaL xr]. xa8E Em(JLl]~OvLXr] nnvto xMOLa ayvw(J'tl] nou OEV ~OQOU~E ELvm 8EwQLa. YVWQL~OU~E 'twQa. (JE OLaQxr] EAEYXO. MaQ~ cero toy tnv CPaLV6~EVOJt. 6XL ~E 'tr]v EJtW'tr]~l].TON IIPQJMO MAPE / EIl.AlAAEKTIKH KAI IIOAITIKH l. Ayvw(JLO 6~w~ ELvm aUL6 rrou OEV vo YVWQL(JOU~E. OEV EXOUV JtAr]QW~ EJtaAl]8EULEL. LE 6LL acpoQa to ~vanaQnx6 ~EA£'tl] rou OuyXw. anav'tr](JEL ~E 'tL~ aVaAUOEL~ tou OL EXCPQa(JEL~ .ArnrH ~E to ELOO~EXEL 'tl]~ EAAOYl]~ JtL(J'tl]~ JtOU EXELW~ aV'tLXEL~EVO vo n~ UJt08E(JEL~ XaLCl to 6Jtw~ nou (JUYXQOLOUV ~La EJtL(JLl]~OVLXr] 8EWQLa. (JU~~aLVEL ~E xa8E Em(J'tr]~l]. H anaVLl](Jl] ornv aVLLQQl](Jl] au'tr] 8a ~OQOU(JE ro EQW'tr]~aLa oro vo EL vm 6'tL OL OUYXL Vl]OLaXa cpOQn(J~VE~ EXCPQaOEL~ 'tOU MaQ~ E~l]YOUV tn EVOLacpEQOV'ta JtOU xa80QL~ouv OJtOLa 8EAEL vc.
. etvru 0 xa8oQWtlx6t. ~E tOY fAEyxo tT]t. ~oQEL va Evtax8EL OtT]V ~EAl~T] tT]t. E~cpavL(. wt. 8EwQLat. TEAlXa T] aAi)8ELa t tT]t. lOtoQLat. EvoW~atW~EvOl OEaVaAUOELt. XOlvWVlXi)t. tQ6no1Jt.EL xm V1JXtWVEl.Etm orov aQXL(. WtoQLat.tOY KaQtE<JlO.Etm orov to «nvEu~a» EXEl OAOXAT]QWOEl tT]V ExcpQaoi) t01J ueoo «no tOY nOAltlo~6 Ev6t. 6nwt. WtoQLat. to n01JALtT]t.EL ava(. orto». tOY Spinoza. EXElxru CPlAOOOCPlxo xaQaxti)Qa. tOY XEYXEA%. An6 tT]V aAAT]~EQla OEVcpaLVEtm va tOY anaoxoAEL otoorptote CPlAOOOCPlxo nQ6f3AT]~aa1Jt6 xa8' Ea1Jt6 6nwt. nQoxuntEl on 0 ~aQ~lo~6t. ~aQ~Wtlxi)t. CP1J<Jlxi)t.T]ti)~ata . YnaQXEL ouo». WtoQLat. 8EwQLatT]t. tT]t. ~aQ~wtlxi)t. VE6tEQT]t. naQaywv tT]t. nQOtELVEl«vtceron01J XQLvOVtm oro OEoo~Eva n01J ELXE 1Jn6\jJT]01J. m oUYXQOVT]t. i) tT]t. n01J E~~wa tOY aJtaoxoAEL OtT] ~EMtT] t01J Yla to f3ovanaQtlx6 qxuvouevo x. WtOQLat..8EwQLat. WtoQLat. trov avaAUOEWV t01J. A va . x rnWtT]~Ovlxi)t. xQLvEtm T] aAi]8Ela tT]t.«. oxE1jJT]t. Yla tT]V OlaAEXtlxi) xm tT]V ~E8ooo avaA1JOT]t.T]tELolacpoQEtlXOUt.. Yla (. tT]t. XOlVWVlOAOYlXi)t. XOo~AoYLat. H XQltlxi) tT]t. 8a xQl8ELonox. E~aAA01JELvm YVWOti)T] rQirt] Otot]to1J MaQ~ Yla tOY <p61JEQ~ax oU~cpwva ~E tT]V onoto ot CPlAOOOCPOl EQ~T]VEU01JVtOY xoouo ~E owcp6Qo1Jt.26 srrornros MIIArIONAl: amEt. Oi CPlAOOOCPlXOL nQof3AT]~atW~OL ELvm aJtAWt.t01J Durkheim. tOY acpoQw~6 t01J XEYXEAOtT] CP~AOOOtpux rov /sixaiou ouuqxov« ~E toy onoto.. ELVm aOXEtEt. M6vo rote T]~aQ~lOtlXi) 8EwQLa tT]t. O1JVEf3mvEE tOY Aoiotote~ AT]. ami)t. aAi]8ELat.erot xru T] CPlAOOOCPlXi) OXE1jJT] E~cpavL(. H EVtUnWOT] mi) OT]~101JQYELtm to EvolacpEa coto QOV tou MaQ~ Yla tT]V WtoQLa tou nQo~aQ~WtlXOU 1JAW~OU ornv Ayia Oixoveveux. T] YAauxa. 8EwQLat.. lotoQLat. x(3aVtlxi)t. VEmWVElat..0... 8a ayvoi)OELtT]V 01JYXlVT]<JlaXa CPOQtW~EVT] cpQaoEOAoYLatWV XEL~EVWV t01J MaQ~ xm 8a EMY~ELav oi E~T]yi)OELt.tT]t. EXOOOT]t. LtT]V 8EOT]ami) 0 MaQ~ 1JnmVLOOEtmnQocpavwt. oocpLat.tT]t. T] anaLtT]OT] Yla ~Etaf3oAi] t01J xoouou. «XOO~O·LOtOQlXOUaou» xm aQXL(.XOlVWVlXi)t. Ano to nEQlEx6~EVOtUN ~EAEtWVtT]t.
AmrH tQ6noUl. YlatL 'l1aYQotlxi) xa8£Otw~ i) YlatL (JE6AOU~ £JtLOQa(J'l1.lX6 xaQaxti)Qa XWQL~rnrto va (J'l1[!aLVH6tl «notfAfL tUCPAi) xm aXQl tn. roo Lt'l1 (JXf'IjJ'l1tOU MaQs avaYftm nQoun08ftH [!aQsWtlxi) L(JW~'l1 evvoio fQYOU tou i) va OAOXA'l1Qwvftm ue tnv evvotn t'l1~ XQltlXi)~ non to (JUVOAOtou [!f80ooAoYLa. o'n 'l1CPlAo(JocpLa mo nOA U tOV va aAAa{. H CPlAO(JOCPlxi) OXf'ljJ't']!JtOQfLvo rov fQ[!'l1VfU(JH. .H to ~ovanaQtlx6 tOu~ nOAl tlXOU~ OlXOVO[!lXOU~ xm n.TON IIPQIMO MAP" / EIl.6Xl 6[!w~ va tov [!fta~aAH. XOl VWVlXOU~ (JX'l1[!atl- (J[!OU~ 'l1naA'l1 trov taSEWV a(JXELxa80Qwtlxi) o MaQs OEV cpaLVEtm v« unO(Jt'l1QL{.X.oU[!f xm Oi (JtW"LXOL xm 0 Descartes uno(Jti)Qlsav [!a~ Oloa(Jxfl ecuto XfYXfA va fJtlOlWXOU[!f x6(J[!0. Yla rnv (Ju[!cpwva naQaOO(Jlaxi) onotor. tas'l1 unO(Jt'l1QL{. fXCPQa(J'l1~. [!a~ naQa tov 0 MaQs. H xQltlxi). v« rtoo- (Jna8EL v« (JUAM~H [!la evvoia t'l1~ CPlAO(JocpLa~ nA'l1QfatfQ'l1 uno rnv ava{. ELvm 'l18fWQ'l1(Jlaxi) CPlAO(JocpLa XfYXfA. A.fl auti) rnv uurnv XUQLW~ unruvtoottru evvoux xm Av xm rc XfL[!fVa ton MaQs OfV fXOUV fV(JW[!aTWVOUV CPlAO(JOCPlXf~ rtou anO~Afnouv (Jt'l1V a[!lYW~ CPlAO(JOCPlX6 xaQaXti)Qa CPlAO(JOCPlXf~ avaAU(Jfl~ anavt'l1(J'l1 oe [!'l1CPlAO(JocplxafQWti)[!ata. 6nw~ tnv fVVOEL0 MaQs.x. H Jt£QlYQacpi) auti) YLVftm ornv KQmx~ rTJ~CPtAoaocpia~ rov Aixaiou rov XEYXEA. H 8fwQ'l1(Jlaxi) CPlAo(JocpLarou xatfu8uv(J'l1 (JUVfXL{.LlIAAEKTIKH KAI IIOAITIKH l. nQfnH va fXH Ql{.XOQucpw[!a t'l1~ t'l1~ CPlAo(JocpLa~va aAAa nfQl YQacpftm. 6nw~ avacpfQEtm otn tQLtn [!fAft'l1 tou touo» outou w~ «xQltlxi)>> i) «6nAo t'l1~ XQltlxi)9>. 'EtOL 'l1CPlAO(JOCPlXi) (JXf'IjJ'l1 f[!cpaVL{.i)t'l1(J'l1 XQlt'l1QlWV aA'l18ELa~ xru OlaXQW'l1~ aAi)8fla~ xm nAaV'l1~ rrou [!E rnv ntuv to XUQLO fQYO t'l1~ CPlAO(JocpLa~ CPlAO(JocpLa.ftm otov fVa~ nOAm(J!!6~ fXH WQl[!a(JH xm aQXL(JHva 6UH. (JXfMv [!'l1xaVWtlxi) a[!cpw~i)t'l1(J'l1. ! o MaQS avacpfQftm L(JW~xm (Jt'l1V XAa(J(Jlxi) CPlAO(JocpLa.fl to (JtfQELtal «Ocvcro t'l1~ AHtOUQYLa~ 'I(Jw~ CPlAO(JocpLa~»i) rnv ano'IjJ'l1 o'n auti) orov XfcpaAmOXQatlX6 XOlVWVlX6 (JX'l1[!atw[!6.
JtQO'to.XWQLe.LCEOAOYLXEC.E'tLC.nQo<J8i]xl]. ELVaL. 1'0 onAo 'tl]C. H IJ.ihring <JUVUYE'tm on l] ~La ELvm W'tOQLXOXOLVWVLXO cpmVOIJ.a'tLXO'tl]'ta.E «XQL'tLXi] 'tWV onAwv». avacpEQE'taL orn rotm iJ.<JELC.<JELC. <JUVEXL~ELXaL nQolin08E'tEL W1'OQLXo.. Tl]V nEQLYQacpi] 'tOU MaQ~ yw rnv XQL'tLXi] <JUVEXL~EL 0 'EVYXEAe.tnv XAa<J(JLxi] XaL 8EWQl]<JLaxi] UV'tLAl]'ljJl] YLa tnv CPLAO<JocpLa ouuqxovc IJ.AalJ.PL~LXi] XQLLLXi] ELVaLau'ti] JtOU 8EIJ.E«to onAo» nQocpavwe. CEV nQo'tL8E'taL v« EA8EL <JE<J'UI-!~L~a<JIJ. rn <JUAAOYL<J'tLXi] 'tl]C.JtaQE~l]Yl]IJ.E'tacpOQU au'ti] 'tOU MaQ~ naQ~l]yi]8l]XE ono noAAOUe.OVOava~i]'tl]<Jl] aAAo.aQ~L<Jnxi] EWOLa 'tl]e.cpOL'0 xrrvouv <J'tOV <JxO'tELVO8o. I)ELXVELmrto rtoi: ELVaLXaL 0XL curo JtOU cpaLVE'taL. Anrn 'tEL ceto rnv LI)EOAOYLa evcvttov 'tl]C.EVO.] avayxmo'tl]'ta l xm i] EJtL- .Ernv ortotn au'ti] EL VaL 0XL IJ. TO<JOono OQL<JIJ. on 'Onwe. EL VaL (J'Uvucpa<JIJ. XaL «vnmuooovror. YLa tnv aAij8ELa. JtEQLEXOIJ.EALCDVEL IJ. 1 roix. ami]e. onotox <J'tQECPE'taL anO<Jacpl]vL<JEL vo «uto nou ELVaL. VOl]lJ. lJ. <JUIJ. 'tLC. avaAU<JELe.EAE'tl]'tl]e. l] onoto 'UJtoxa8w'tu tn EJtLXELQi]IJ. Xa'ta<JXEUEC. onwc.EVWVEmO yovwv 1'OU XEYXEA <JUlJ. nUQa'tl]Qi]<JELe.cpwva IJ. YnO<J'tl]QL~EL O'tL l] UAW'tLXi] I)LaAExnxi] naQoU(JLo. XQL nxi]c. IJ.. H XQLnxi] ELVaL «onAo» evcvttov 'tWV LCEOAOYLXWV EXELVWV xa'ta<JxEuwv nou avanol)oyuQL~OUV rnv JtQaYlJ. ExClO<Jl]e. H IJ.Lo. ~Lae.nO'IjJl] au'ti] l] lJ.aLVEL l] XQL'tLXi] non a<JxEL'taL evovttov 'tl]e.JtQO'to. <J1'OVAnti-Di.E'to vo 'tl]C.1'OU 'EVYXEAe. a<J'toxa<J'tl] xm 'tEALXUavoQ80AOYl] anoAOYLa 'tl]e.. LCEon OAOYLae.O 'to 'ljJEUl)oe.EVa UJtO<J'tl]QLX8l]XE.EVEe. XQLLLxi]e.a. 'ljJEul)oue. QWIJ. XQL'tLxi]e. EQIJ.XalJ.E Ano rnv o. nou 'til 8EIJ. nou avanol)oyuQL~EL tnv nQaYlJ.l]xavi]e.EALWV01lVXaL v« anoxaAU'ljJEL 'to nQaYIJ. onwe.28 xrrorsros MIIArIONAl: OJtWC.tOU MaQ~ O<JO ' xm uno ne.a'tLXO 'tl]C..l]VEU8l]XEwe. <Jl]lJ.Ernv FEQllaVU<7'J Ioeosovia.~EL tnv CPU<Jl] we.0 'tl]e.E'tacpOQLxi] <JU<JXEn<Jl]'tl]C.EaJto<Jacpl]VWIJ. XaL aywvae.EVEC.anxo'tl]'ta. nQoxumEL nrro rnv KQ[uuJj rTJ~ l[J[AOaocp{a~ rov Aixaio» rov XtYUEA XaL onwe.EVO trtv IJ. IJ.a'ta. OL CPW'tOYQo.~aLVEL IJ.
tou LJtLv6sa x.'l1~xorvorvu«.lEtQ'l10'l1m 6XL ue tOY AEy6[.(. O'l1AaO~ '(.lEALaXE~'l18LXE~ OXEOEL~ tou «ou[. (L06t'l1ta~ OLXmW[.lEtQ'l10'l1 xaQaXt'l1QLSfl t600 to otoxao[.lJtQaXta [.aywVLO[. QU8[.a.'l1~EAEu8EQLa~ YLatL ue cuto 'l1'l18LX~XaL 'l1EAEu8EQLaJtauouv vo aJtOtEAoUV aJtAa xm uovo UJtOXEL[.lE '(.l'l1VEu8ELEtOL 'l1avacpoQa Ot'l1V «xQmx~ nov 6JtAWV» 'l18E0'l1tOU MagS anOtEAELouvEXfla t'l1~ UJt01jYr]~'l1~ JtaQaooOLax~~ CPLAOOOt cpLa~. H xQmx~.lWV.lBavEL 0 JtOAL- sw~~ . LU[. EcpaQ[.lOU~ t'l1~ «xowrovk«.lEV'l1 rnv OUVELO'l1OLax~ xm rnv XOLVWVLX~'l18LX~.lLXWV av'(.lftOEJtacp~~tOU~ xm 8E[.Av EQ[.lcpwva us tOY XEYXEA «uro xata xaJtOLo roono xOQUCPWVfltL~ 8E[. Qot600 'l1[.lEALWVflrnv evotntn tOU~. Autn oUVLOta to O'l1[.lBoAaLou».latLx6t'l1ta» t'l1~ 'l18LX~~ XaL '(. [. tOU AQLOtotEA'l1.O[.l60t'l1XE6Jtw~ JtQOXllJttEL aJt6 t'l1 tQLt'l1 [.la. tWV LOLWtWV».lEtacpOQa t'l1~ <<XQLtLX~~ 6JtAWV»avacpEQEtm OtYlVUJt01jJ'l16tL'l1XQLtLX~ torv OEVJtQOUJt08Etfl uovo 8EWQ'l1tLX~ aOLaAAasLa aAAa ouvrnaYEtm aOLaAAasLa xm W~ JtQO~tOY toone xm oQao'l1~..(.lqxovo [.latwv xru UJt0XQEWOEorv). 0 MaQs. 6Jtw~ tnv EWOft 0 MaQs.tLXEU[. ern XaVEVa roono 'l1BLa OEVanOtEAEL xa80QLOtLx6 K JtaQayovta t'l1~ LOtOQLX~~ ESEALS'l1~.L~Eu8uVE~ rtou avaAa[. mJ[. 0 'Iow~ 0 VEO~MaQs va tOVLSfl JtEQL006tEQO orro toy 'EVYXEA~trtv BLa w~ JtaQayovta tOU LOtoQLX01J L Y yvw8m.aLOUYXEXQLB uev« XaL E[. 6Jtw~ UJtOOt~QLSE Diihring.lEVLX6Lw[. 0 MaQs aocpaAw~ 01JOXEtLSflrnv xQLtLX~ ue rnv aVa[. EXO'l1Awvov. 01JVEXLsOvta~ toy XEYXEA. 600 xm tnv JtQas'l1. 'l1 ortoto rnv anooacp'l1VLSfl.cpaLVEtm va OEXEtm 6tL 'l1aVa[. trov a.lEtnv onoto 'l1avas~t'l1O'l'] t'l1~ aA~8fla~ O1JVrnaYEtm xm JtQOtiJt08Etfl avaAoyo roono sw~~.lEVO x oLaAoyo.lOQCPOJtOLft EsatOJ.l6. To xQatO~ xata tOY XEYXEA «noteAEL tnv «JtQaY[.LllAAEKTIKH KAI IIOAITlKH 1:TON IIPOIMO MAPE / EI1:ArnrH OQao'l1ton OJtOLOU JtOLXLAAflavaAoya ue LL~ LOTOQLXOXOLVWVLXE~ 01JV8~XE~.n. X.lEAEt'l1 t'l1~ EXOOO'l1~m~~ ot'l18EwQLa a rou XEYXEA YLa to xQato~. t'l1~ JtOLV~~.lLSEL tOU~ aVtaywvLO[. rou ITAatwva. H «xQmx~ tWV 6JtAWV» cnotEAEL tnv JtQaXtLX~ JtAEuQa t'l1~ OtOxaoLLx~~ xQmx~~.
ouoto Xal n~ AEltOUQYLE~ EVO~ 8EOJtOlT]!J.EVE~.JtOQEL aUV01jJw8EL atT] 8EaT] on 0 va XEYXEA avaJtoooyuQL~El tTl aXEaT] xQatou~ xru xoworvtoc. 0 XEYXEA 8EAH va xcrcnoAE!J.30 A":TonTOl: MIIArIONAl: tT]~ EVaVn rcov xQanxwv Geouorv. t OEV aJto8EwvEl to xQato~ ours uJtoatT]QL~H on to xQatO~ JtaQaYH n~ xot VWVlXE~ aXEaH~.L~Ovtal oi avaAoya !J. 0 XEYXEAxata xcvevo rocno OEV8EOJtOlELo xQatO~ outs E!. !J. n~ o o MaQ!.EQla!J. tOY XOlVWVlXO Xata!J.~aH tOY UJtOxH!J. H xQmx~ tOU MaQ!. rou Fries Xal rou Haller.OJtW~JtaQatT]QEL otoot« 0 Eric Weil orn !J. to xQatoe JtaQaJtOLEL os xaJtOLo Ba8!J.Ernv 8EOAoyLa.Olt WVH tnv JtOAmx~ !J. tl~ JtaQaywYlxE~ aXEaH~.EVla!J.EAEtT] tou touou. JtQOXUJttH on T] JtOAltlX~ rtou avacpEQEtal orn 8EwQLaXal tnv .alQEtlxa YOVl!J. Ano tnv 8EaT]a1Jt~ tou MaQ!. Kot OtT] 8EwQLa tOU Yla to xQato~ 0 XEYXEA!.EVlXE~la8EaH~ rou xa8Evo~. auvEJtaynal.X. Krrru to Xal !J. auwpwva !J. Jt.EAEtT]OU 0 XEYUEA xa: TO UQ6TO~.lXE~avn8EaH~ rtou «uro. H XQl nx~ tOU MaQ!. XQovlxa oi xmvwvlxE~ axEaEl~. H JtaQaJtOLT]aT] 1Jt~ 6EV a tovL~Etal EJtaQxw~ otn tQLtTl !J.H~. H xQmx~ ton MaQ!.iJt08EtH rnv xowcovt« w~ oMtT]ta avtaywVWtlXwV ta!. oJtw~ to aWJtEQaa!J.OU JtaQaynal «no n~ JtQOXEL!J. JtaQaywYlxE~ ouva!J.E roix OJtOLOU~ xmvwvlxE~ aXEaH~ JtQEJtHva QU8!J.lXwv aXEaEWVXal 0Xl to cvttotoorpo.o tT]~ Xal tl~ ta!.Exlv~aH «no tn «BaaT]» nou ouvtorutm or«. oxrrooo ELVal E!.O Ola<:P0QWV qJlAEAEU8EQWV oroxcororv tT]~ EJtOX~~rou. 0 XEYXEA. aJtoOLOH orov XEYXEA rnv aJt01jJT]on to xQato~ 8EOJtmEL tal Xal on «no to xQato~ JtaQayovtal Xal AOYlxa.O!J.EVOU xQatou~. tnv EQyaaLa ton av8QwJtou.a EVO~aUAAoyw!J.o n~ 8EaH~ rou XEYXEA. T] JtoAmx~ aJtotEAEL VEOtEQOunoxctuotccto tT]~ 8EOAoyLa~. Yla rnv 8EwQLatou XEYXEAYla.E aXQl tE~ UJtOXH!J.EtQOnou T] JtoAmx~ aJtOtEAEL 8EwQLa Yla rnv cpuaT] rnv .ExlvaH coto tT]V xOQuCP~ ovrt vo !.T] crto tnv aJto1jJT] n unoo aacpT]VL~H Jtw~ Xal AOYlxa xru WtOQlXOYEvEtlXa to xQato~ rtoo'i.
avan:6Cjl£uxtl] ornv atasLxi] XOLVWVLa mElbi] auti] xaQaxtl]QL!.fV£~aQatl]Qi]OEl~ n rou 'EVYX£A~ YLa tOY BLOlJ.£to £8VLX6 nAaLOLO oro onOLO ami] «vcnruooetrn.Ou. n. OtL~ VOOl]Qf~ IJ. H anoQQ6Cjll]ol] rou xQatou~ coto rnv XOLVWVLa ouv£JtaYEtaL XaL rnv an:oQQ6Cjll]ol] tl]~ n:OAL TLxi]~ coto tnv 8£WQLa YLa TL~ AEltOUQYLf~ XaL tnv £SfALSl] evo.OUV tL~ IJ.aVLxi]~ £QYatLXi]~ taSl]~. 'Onw~ tOVL!.a~.fVl] !-!E evo» £saLQ£TLxa £AaoTLx6 xorcIJ. 6nw~ Sa fA£Y£ 0 AQWtotfAl]~.£VO.BaLVEl ' cumv 10 XOLVWVLX6 0 Jt£QL8wQLO.6 tl]~ £QyaoLa~ rtou £mtQfnEl bwatoti]twv rnv avant1JSl] 6AWV uov tl]~ av8Qwm Vl]~ nQoowmx6tl]ta~.OVtfQV£~XOLVWVL£~ lJ.aQaolJ.x.£VO0 xQatO~ n:Qfn:El va unoo1 QOCjll]SELno IJ. i] ornv XOLVWVLa ono».OU tOU XQa1Ou~ XaL an:oQQ6Cjll]oi]~ rou coto rnv xorvorvtc. t'n 8£wQLa XaL ore £JtLCjlaVElaXa abLfsoba tl]~ xa8LOta £saLQ£tLxa £JtLXaLQl] XaL y6VLIJ. ornv naAl] rcov tas£WV.LXOU XOLVWVLXOU XaL 0Xl]lJ.LXQoaOtoLi] OL aYQ6t£~.OQCjlL£~ tl]~ naAl]~ tWV tas£WV orn raAALa ton bfxatou evcrou cuovo.IilAAEKTIKH KAI IIOAITIKH 1:TON IIPmMO MAP3 I EIl:ArnrH 31 n:QaXTLxi] n:OU fXEl W~ aVTLXELlJ.w~W~ nOALtLxi] vOl]8d l] 8£WQLa XaL l] nQaXtLxi] nou aVaCjlfQ£taL ornv n6Al].l] w~ 6Qyavo aVaAUOl]~ tWV XOLVWVLXWV£XQi]s£wv xm oUYXQOUO£WVrrou rou xaQaxtl]QL!. H ~fALSl] auti] ELVaL u roi. H £SfALSl] ami] £LVaLOWUCjlaOlJ. An6 to LOtOQLOYQaCjlLx6 fQYO torv MaQs XaL 'EVYX£A~ nQoxuJttEL 6TL tn .£Aftl] a1JtOU tOU t61J. An6 TL~ naQatl]Qi]oEl~ roo MaQs YLa TL~ LbLOIJ.EtaIJ. rtou ot£Qouvtm taSLxi]~ OWElbi]o£w~.6tav avayxaL6tl]ta tl]~ nOALTLxi]~.oU 0 MaQs b£v aQVLftaL rnv n:OALtLxi] £V yfV£L.OvtaL tl]~ IJ.£6n:w~ Sa to 1OVLOEl0 'EVYX£A~.CjlaOl]10U MaQs. 8a n£L 0 MaQs. OtL~ naQ£XXALOEl~ tl]~. cero bLabLxaOLa lJ. orov n:aQ£IJ. w~ nQo~ to BovanaQtLx6 qxuvoIJ.£QLOlJ.aQX XaL roo. AQVLftaL rnv nOAL- tLXi] W~ 8£wQLa yLa to xQato~.atwIJ. 6nw~ XaL «no OQLOlJ.OQCjlL£~ naAl]~ nov tas£WV nQrnEl va OUOXEtL!. nQoxuJttEl 6tL OL LbLOIJ.OL IJ. aywv£~ tl]~ Y£QlJ. 0 t£A£1JtaLO~ 8a un£Qaom!.La8£WQLaYLa rnv xotvorvln. tnv H flJ.OQCjlf~ tl]~. Av 61J. OLXOVOIJ.EtaL ern tQL tn IJ.
LEyaAUTEQl] Ol][. XOLVWVLXOLOXl][.LOU TO OUf.LEVU Tl]e. L01OQLUe.LEtn vo perennis.LUQsW[. Tl] 8EOl] Tl]C.Ll]VELUa'UT~ Tl]C. OUf.LaQsW[. 0 we. EAEX8l] on l] [.LOVOV OTL 0 [. OEV EJtETQEJtUV JtQoe. LOEOAOYLX~ XaLUOXEU~ ELOLXOTEQUcote XOL OXl][. OL EUAOYEe. EVVOLU TaU E8voue. IIaVTWe.32 E8Vl] xm Aou80uv 0XL OL OLXOV0I-UXOLxm vc xrrorsroa MlIArIONAl. Lvm l] aSEJtEQaOTl] E ELVaL OUVaTOV philosophia EXEL SEJtEQaOTEL TO sEJtEQUO[.Lue.LOU mrtou JtEQUOTl] CjJ AOOOCjJ a Tl]C.LU Ol][. EJtOX~ LaQTQ xm sLO[.LJtEQaO[.LUQSLO[.LUQOTl]V UJtO a'UT~V JtOU aVOQ80AOYl] on [. UJtOXEL[. EVVOLUe.LaQsLO[.LU 0 [. OTY]V[.. JtuQaOOOl]e. OEV EVU ELOOe. TOU. YLU l] USETOU [. OLa1jJEUOEL Tl]V JtEQLCjJl][.Lan av JtuQa[.LOe. [.LOe. EmCjJUAaSELe. Q~Ol]e. JtOU 8a TOU.LEQw80uv ELvm on TOV CjJLAOOOCjJLXO XUQaXT~Qa TaU TO[.Lae. L L . CjJOQEe.LaTLO[.WTaQLUC.LaLWi-WL ESUXOJtUQ' OAO JtOU XOLVWVL- ELVm TU UJtOXEL[. EJtOx~e.LL- OUQYl]8EL OL LOTOQLXOXOLVWVLXEe.LETa[.LETOV IIQ6Aoyo rl1~uQmuiJ~ rl1~JiOAmuiJ~ OtuovOl] aJtO'\jJl] on 0 MUQS 8EWQEL Tl]V uuu. TOU LaQTQ [.LOU-AEVLVLO[.LOe. [.LCpWVU[.LEVOLEXJtQOOWJtOL TaU O'UTLXOU[. OQW[. to JtUQOV YLaLL OEV EXOUV aXO[. 8a OLxmwvomv EVVOLU 10U E8voue. XaL on aJtOTEAEL 0 Q~Ol] TOU a'UT~ OTL 0 [. E8vLX~e. EJtOx~e.LUQsLO[.TaU E8voue.LOU JtOU UJtOOLOEL [.OUV8~XEe. WTaQLUe. Av YLVELOEXT~ l] EQ[.LaQsLO[. [.LuQswn- X~ 8EWQLU TY]e.La TOU LaQTQ xru SEJtEQUOTEL EVVOOUOE CjJLAOOOCjJLaTl]e.LEVaTOU xm OLU1jJEUOETm cno TO LOTaQLOYQUCjJLXO EQYO l] JtQOOEYYWl] TaU [.LLXOLm x we.LaOLa Tl]e. JtQOC. Kru JtOAAa XEL[.Ll] Q~Ol] OEV EVVOOUOE [...LOVTEQva.Lae.LOL. ELvm JtQaY[.LOe. anoOLOouV IIOnEe.LEVOTl]e.LOU. ELVm OL OLXOVO[.
o IIrOMArEI!TIKO! T AI!MO! KAI H KOINflNIKH KrITIKH ITO IIrflIMO Erro TOTMArE .
.
OLaOLxaOl£C. XQT]OL[!OnOLd 'tLC. naQu tT]V avmuQxuu LOU dvm WLOQLxu xm AOYLXUavayxaloc.aU'tEC. u<'hx6't£Qa yw nurov rrou nQoExU'ljJ£ coto rnv mo8T]maQXla LOU Aox. KaLU xunoLO toone 0 OLaA£XLLa x6C.. UAw[!6C. FeQ/WVtXrl I&oAoyia.LOU MaQ~ YLa LOV nQo[!aQ~wLLx6 UAw[!6. 0 Olivier R.T]XaLu'ta~T]... 'tLC.. nwc.. OLa~U~OU[!£ornv Ayia OtXOY£VEW.£X nQw'tT]C. xm 6 T]aVUAUOT].[2]unuQXu. U'tEc. 'tT]V Ayia OtXOY£VEW.. cpVG'Y]t.. Etvru a~LOOT][!£lWLO 6LL LLC. VO[!l~W. umuvtooetru i]OT] T] XQOVOAOYLXU nAT]mEO't£QT]nQoc. La 'tOY Y [!£'tacpumx6 UAw[!6. O£ av. Avcueoo O'tT]VunO'IjJT]'tT]C. Bloch. YLa 'tT]V OQ80AOYLXi]OXE'ljJT] VOT]LLXEC.Ayiat. aXQL~EO't£QaT] UAW'tLXi] o LaA£xLLxi]...OLaOLxaOl£C. UAw[!6C.an6'IjJ£WC. OtXOveveuu. nou nQOExu'IjJ£uno tT]V aw8T]maQXla LOU Aox nQO£LOL[!U~U 'tOY oootcxiouo xm LOV xouuouviouo.aQVT]'tLXEC. O£V XaLaQyd LOV ueroqnxnxo UAw[!6 anu LOV OU!!JtAT]QWV£L.'tT]V [!£A£'tT] au't11 nQo'tl8£[!m va unoo'tT]Ql~W. xm OLmw'ti][!£c. xm OQW[!EWC.OuvEX£Lac.aVu[!wa OtT]V EVVOLaLOU UAW[!OV rtou nQoxvJt'tu coto L · . rtou O'tT]Ql~OV'tm 0' aU'tEc.onote. 0 [!£'tacpuoLx6C.OLaXQlO£LC. rtou OLa'tunwvu 0 'EVYX£AC. 6'tL 0 UAw[!6C. KaLU 'tOY 'EVYX£AC. XQlO£LC. oev EQXOvroi O£ aV'tlcpaOT] ue tn OLUXQWT][!£'tacpumxov OT]Aaoi] rroo[!aQ~wnxov xru OWA£XLLXOV UAW[!OV aou avan'tVOO£L 0 'EVYX£AC.l8wT] ue [!£A£'tT]'tEC. T]ta~LV6[!T]oT] xa8wc.[l] 6LL OL 8E'tLXEC. OLOV Anti-DUhring xru 'tTl L1wAEXnXrl T'flt. 0XEOT] WLOQLXi]C. [!£800LXEC. YnuQXu mlOT]C. UAw[!6C. XQlOUC. £cp' 600v £lvm avayxal£C. 0 [!a'tacpuOLx6c.6nwc.
n.xrrorsros MIIArIONA~ rnv Ayia Ot. [!£'taY£VEO't£Q££6LaXQLO£L£ron EVYX£A£ AOYLX'r] XEOl] aVUAOYl] ue ami]v rtou aVu[!wa O£ EVa 0 AOYLX6YEVO£XaL tu £L6l] oro onoto £LVaL6uva't6v va 6LaLQ£8d. l] XLVl]Ol] evo. To Eva. ~) coto 'tOY 'llALO[!6 no'll nQO£'tOL[!UO'tl]X£ uno rou. IIQo'tL8£[!aL va 'llnOO'tl]QLSW'tL£ 'lln08EO£L£ amE£. 0 MaQs 6LaxQLv£L 6uo 'llALOtLXU Q£u[!a'ta. ou[!cpwva ue rnv OQoAoYLa tou EVYX£A£. no'll nQoxun'tO'llV W£ nQo£ rnv XOL VWVLXi] nQaXtLxi] XaL rnv XQLtLxi] 'tl]£ a) «no 'toy [!l]xaVLO'tLx6 'llALO[!6.6nw£ nQOXUJt't£Lozro 'tL£ mQLYQaCPE£ ton MaQS ornv A via OtUOYfVEW. £s£'tU~Ovtr«. nQoEX1l'ljJ£uno rnv xaQ'twLavi] CP'llOLXi] aL X anoQQocpi]8l]x£ oao 'tl] CP'llOLxi] JtLo'ti][!l] tou 6Exa'tO'll oovoot: £ ouovc. nQouno8E't£L 6tL 0 rtoo[!aQsLO'tLx6£ 'llALO[!6£ dVaL 01lV'llcpaO[!EVO£ ue 6w6LxaoL££ aVUA'llOl]£.A. ouuqxovc ue tnv n£QLYQacpi] rou. VO[!LVaALO'tE£ XaL nQOEX1l'ljJ£ «no rnv aL08l]OLOxQa'tLa rou Boxorvo XaL rou Aox. . LOXU£L yw tnv £si]Yl]Ol] 'tl]£ nQay[!atLx6'tl]'ta£ oro otrvoxo 'tl]£. H EVVOLatou 'llALO[!OU6nw£ rnv naQO'llOLU~£Lon£Q[!a'tLxu EO'tW l] Ayia Oixoveveux nQo£'tOL[!U~£L 'toy 6LaA£x'tLx6 'llALO[!6 XaL. 'tL£ O'llVEn£W. ou[!cpwva ue 'tOY onoto 0 'tQ6no£ A£L'tO'llQYLa£[!La£ [!l]xavi]£. 'tQOXou 'tl]£. Ou[!cpwva us 'toy Mandeville. H EVVOLarou 'llALO[!OU. xatu 'to [!E'tQO rtou XQl]OL[!£U£LW£ £QyaAdo YLa rnv aVUA'llOl] av'tLcpa'tLxwv xcrccrcoecov. ami] aou 'llnuQX£L ovcueo« O'tL£ a'tO[!LXE£ «xaxL££» XaL ru 6l][!6OLa wcp£Ai][!ata..WYfVEW XaL w. tasLv6[!l]ol]£ x. £S£ALS£WVXaL 0XEO£WV. 6nw£ mQL YQucpov'taL nzro 'tOY MaQs ornv A via Oixoveveux: Onw£ £LVaL vvoxrro. ornv naQEx~aOl] 'tl]£ Ayia~ OtUOYfaou avacpEQ£'taL ornv LO'tOQLarou 'llALO[!OU. 0 VEW~. zrou nQoxaAd'taL «no Eva [!oXM 'tl]£.x. rtou xaQaxtl]QL~OUV 'tOY «uetuqnxnxo 'llALO[!6». 0 onOLO£ avi]x£L O'tOV nQO[!aQsLO'tLx6 aAAU nQO£'tOL[!U~£L'toy 6LaA£XtLxo 'llALO[!6. n. orto». IIQ6x£LtaL YLa 'toy [!l]xavLotLx6 'llALO[!6.
ornv WtoQLa toll llAW!!OlJ. 0 llAW!!6£ xataAi]YH fJtLyfw Of 6ll0<pi]!!f]0f] llALO!-!6£ Etvc.o I1POMAPSIl:TIKm: YAIl:MOl: KAI H KOINONIKH KPITIKH l:TO I1POIMO EPrO TOY MAPS 37 !!f]xavwnx6£ XLVf]Of]£ orou. x JtOll xaQaxtf]QL~OllV nou 6LEJtOllV rnv em6fV fmBfBmwVftm «vrupcoecov ue ama xaJtoLO Ota6LO tf]£ XOLVOOVLXi]£ toQLa~. xaQaxtf]Qwnx6 toll <pllOLxi]. JtOLonxi] ret180 VH fJtLOf]£ va avayayn o rnv ornv JtOOOtLXi] !!ftaBoAi]. llAW!!6£ V6!!Oll£ tfLVfL va avayaYfL rou. V6!!Oll£ tf]£ nou 6Lt~JtOllVrnv XLVf]Of] 00£ coo«. H o1JVmayooyi] ami] Qf]ta aAAa E!!!!Wa coto aou ava<pEQftm rnv JtaQExBaof] tf]£ A vicu. 6. Oixoveveuu. oO<pLa£ uno rnv EVYXfA£ ouuqxovn ue oro OlJVoM rou tfL VH JtQo£ rnv OJtOLa 0 VfWtfQO£ llALrnv aJtoQQ6<pf]0f] tf]£ <pLAOJtQay- rnv fJtLOti]!!f]. 6!!oo£ a~LOOf]!-!fLOOtoou i]6f] oro JtQwta YQaJtta toll on o MaQ~ JtaQatf]QfL !!f]. H <pLAOOOolJ!-!<poova uno tOY MaQ~ orov «a<pf]Qf]!-!EVO»i] !-!f]xaOJtOLOll dvm . mwti]!!f] 6f]Aa6i] XQLvnm f] tllmxi] !!a aou Of]!!aLVfL 6tL f] <pLAooo<pLaxa8LOtatm H aJtoQQ6<pf]0f] allti] torv JtQo<pavw£ ollvmaYftm f] aVaAllOf] on tf]~ <pLAooo<pLa£«no rnv f] XOLVOOVLXi] QLnxi]. «uovc ~ftm coto tf] <pllOLxi] emornun. !!fta<pllOLxi] xOO!!OavtLAf]'ljJf] xm aQvi]8f]Xf JtQay!-!anx6 JtQo£ rnv xaQtwLavi] xm JtOAlJ ALy6tfQO JtQo£ tnv xaQtfOLavi] llAW!-!6. 01JVxm to a~LOAOYLX6. va fJtLBfBmwoH rnv aJtO'ljJf]on f] llAWtLXi] <pLAooo<pLa JtQOOQL- va aJtoQQo<pf]8fL M6 tnv H aJtO'ljJf] ami] aJtO'ljJf] toll uno- QfL va 8fOOQf]8fL 6tL JtQoftoL!!a~fL OtOV Anti-DUhring ouo. !!f8060AoYLa tf]£ <pLAooo<pLa£dvm tf]£ fJtWti]!!f]£. toy tfLvH AOLJt6v !!f]xavwnx6£ llAW!!6£ aJtoQQO<pi]8f]Xf xata H f~EAL~f] allti] fmOti]!!f].tL 6f aJtO!!EVfL 00£ cvnxstuevo AOYLXi]xm f] 6LaAfXtLxi]. JtQEJtH va ovtunoW Of XQLti]QLa avaAoya Otf]!!OVLXi] OxE'ljJf]. '1000£ f~mtLa£ tf]£ !-!fta<pllOLxi]£[3] xm eovoet rnv ~ooi] xm tnv fmOti]- tf]£ fJtL6Qaof]£ non 0 !-!f]xavwnx6£ 6EX8f]Xf coro n£ <pllOLXE£fmOti]!-!f£ 6E8f]Xf ue !!La vatollQaAwnoxi] tf] 6LaxQWf] ava!!wa oro 'EtOL 0 Hobbes avtLtL8ftm <pLatoll evrcoottm vumxo xm aOXf]Of 0' amE~.
XOLvwvLxa XaL '\jJ'llXOA.a ornv svvoui tTj~ asLa~ ev YfV£L.~ uio8£t£L JtaQO[LOLa O'llA. CPLA.£L YLa va XQl]OL[LOJtOLi]O£L Mva[Li] tou. rnv onoto avaYH O£ JtQaY[LatLxO 6£6o[LEVO.£L YLa v« aJtoxtTj8£L xatL. oJtw~ rnv evvoet 0 Hobbes. 0 'Evyx£A.OyLOtLxi]orov £JtLXQLV£L tnv IIaQLOLvi] . L6LaLt£Qa rnv mavaotatLxi].A.OOOcpO'll~».A.ia. Mot£A. OJtw~ ami] £JtLX£LQi]8TjX£ no « toy A. 0 Hobbes aQvLftaL JtQocpavw~ tTj <'haXQLOTj vcueoc oro JtQaY[LatLxo XaL to asLOA.LO[LOU ana XaL toy [LaQsLOtLXO'llA. v JtaoTj Jt£QLJttWOH amOA. JtLO JtQwtot'llnoix.d JtQaY[LatLxo 6£6o[LfVO rtou £sTjyd rrn LOtoQLxa.wv £[LJtoQ£'ll[Latwv» [51.0YLxa.~ OtTj 8QTjox£La. mLB£BaLwV£taL XaL «no tL~ avacpOQf~ ron MaQs XaL tou 'Evyx£A. Ano tnv JtQWL[LTj Eumywyr) otnv Kgmxr) rl1~ l[>tAOaocp{a~ rov Aixaio» rov Hegel ron MaQs JtQOXUJtt£LOtL Tj 8QTjoxda.A.0YLXO c orcv unoOtTjQL~£L otov Af{3u'xf)av OtL Tj asLa £VO~av8QwJto'll 'W'lltL~£taL [L£ to tL[LTj[La rtou £LVaLxaJtOLO~ JtQo8'll[LO~vo xataBaA.£yO[L£VO [LTjxavLotLxo 'llA.xrrorsros MIIArIONA1: [L£ rnv Ayia OtXOYEVnaTj avaywyi] tTj~ xLVTjOTj~ 0XfOTj y£wO£ [L£tQLXWV[L£y£8wv [4]. Tuui xai KEg(50~ tou 1865 xaQaxtTjQL~£L tOY Hobbes w~ «Eva coto rou. AvacpEQ£taL orov Af{3u'xf)av XaL JtaQatl]Q£L OtL Tj avaywyi] tTj~ asLa~ oro tL[LTj[Lartou dVaL xavd~ 6Lat£8H[L£VO~ vn xataBaA.OLJtOVrnv avaywyi] tTj~ asLa~ O£ JtQaY[LatLxO 6£60[LfVO.iJt08£t£L A.LO[LO. OL aVtLcpaoH~ oev dVaL ouvctov va s£Jt£Qaotouv [L£ rnv XOLVWVLXi] JtQaxtLxi]. 0 MaQs oro A.ayi] rou JtQO[LaQsLOtLxoU 'llA.LO[LO. H e 8QTjoxda av8£L O£ [Lw xowcovto XaL moxi] tTj~ oaotr«. «aJtot£A.d tn BaoTj YLa toy xa8oQLO[LO tTj~ asLa~ tTj~ £QyaoLa~ XaL nov aA.0YLxa. «nou £L VaL to Jtv£u[La XaL Tj o'llv£L6TjoTj [LLa~ moxi]~ XWQL~ Jtv£u[La XaL o1lV£L6TjoTj». H aJto'\jJTjami] ton Hobbes tTj oev avacpfQ£taL £L6Lxa ornv asLa tTj~ £QyaoLa~ aA. "OtL Tj avaywyi] tTj~ asLa~ O£JtQaY[LatLxo 6£60[L£VOxaQaxtTjQL~H 0XL [LOVOrn [LTjxavLOtLxi] JtaQaA. H [LaQSLOtLxi] 8£wQLa tn~ asLa~ XaL Tj [LaQsLOtLxi] XOLVWVLXi] XQLtLXi] Y£VLxot£Qa JtQo'i.A.
.nQwL!-la xm !-lEtaYEvEotEQa. av !-lEta~Al]8EL l] xorvorvte. OE toll xm «vo anaYOQEUOELto 8E6» !-lnOQELva E~aAHqJ8EL uovo orov «ue OLatayi] uou- qJti]». nrrvroouvuut« tl]t. allti] nQooEYYWl] tl]t. nQaY!-latLx6 OEOO!-lEVO OEV8EWQELxm 6tL l] avaywYLxi] a8E"(o!-lou. onoto EllnLOtLa xm YLa a1Jt6 !-lnoQEL va xaQaxtl]Qw8EL xm OEEva OEUtnv m08l]OLaQ- Wt. nmOELat.oLaqJEQHcoto rnv !-laQ~wtLxi]. ouvcvetru 6tL. «no nl]YEt. av8Qwmvl] ~tl]V [7]. nLotl] YLatL 8EAl]OE va !-lEta~aAH 6AOllt. rou nQo!-laQ- n. l] coto tl] Ata81jxl1 toll avaqJEQEtm ornv o» xm l] amOAOYLxi] E~i]Yl]Ol] tl]t. rron nl]ya~EL «no to llALOtLx6 QEU!-laztou nQOEXll'l!JEcoro rov Aox xm roix nQooQ6- rou. l] tEXVl] tou 0Xl]!-latLO!-lOU VOl]tLXWV avtLAtl'l!JEWV i] LOEWV. LOEaALOtLXi]. H 8Ql]OXElltLxi] E~i]Yl]Oi] tl]t. tEQO llALOtLx6 QEu!-la to A yia Oixoveveux 0 MaQ~ avaqJEQEtm onoto nQoxuJttH «no XLa toll Aox xm nQoEtoL!-la~Etm cero to VO!-lWaALO!-l6xm tov Boxcovo.o IIPOMAPEI~TIKO~ YAI~MO~ KAI H KOINQNIKH KPITIKH ~TO IIPQ]MO EPro TOY MAPE 39 Kouuouvo a8Wllt.x. H amaxi] ore !-laQ~LOtLXa XEL!-lEVa. xm tl]t. vc naQatl]Ql]8EL 8Ql]OXE1JtLXi]t. ~u!-lqJwva AOLn6v ue rnv Ayia OtXOYE- . nLOtl]t. H E!-lnHQLa xm OLa!-lOQqJwvovtm coto rnv nmOELa.. An6 rnv anO'l!Jl] YLa rnv 8Hat. l] avaJttll~l] l] ollvi]8Ha nov naQaOtaOEwv nl]ya~ollv «no rnv E!-lnHQLa xm tl] ollvi]8Ha». An6 to QEu!-la «uro nQoxuJttH 6tL «OL aw8i]oHt. EnLOQaOHt. Ol]!-laLVH Wt. roix nOALtEt. 8Ql]OXElltL- «no tOV A~~a Meslier. E~aAHqJ8ouv tn aLtLa rrou tnv nQoxaAouv xm rnv E~l]YOUV.. OE ~EXWQLOti] a~LOAoYLxi] JtEQLOXi]. An6 tnv «E!-lnHQLa xm tl] ollvi]8Ha» E~aQtatm toll av8Qwnoll oro ouvoM tl]t.Sa EnQEnE 6tL aVtL!-lEtwnL~Etm tru 6tL avi]xH LOWt. rrou aoxEL to XOLVWVLX6JtEQL~aAAOVornv ato!-lLxi] OllVELOl]Ol]. [8]. 01JVi]- tl]t. nQOEtOL!-la~Etm ~WtLXOU llALO!-lOU xm A~~a Meslier xi]t. aVEqJaQ!-lOOtl] xata tl] YVW!-ll] ton [61. Ol]Aaoi] cero tLt. 8a uem- ~Al]8EL xm l] nmoELa aQa xm l] E!!JtHQLa xm l] 01JVi]8Ha rtou xa8oQL~ollV tn OllvELOl]OLaxi] xm HOLX6tEQa tn VOl]tLXn avaJttll~l] toll av8Qwnoll.nLOtl]t. !-l0llt. E!-lnHQLat. OXl]0 urmouo.
oOOLaAw!-to~ xm 0 xouuouviouoc.' aQxijv tTl CPLAOOOCPLXij xQLtLxij tT]~ unotVT]~ OtL llnuQxollv Ota8EQu xaQaXtT]QWtLXU OtT]V av8QwnLVTj CPUOT]. onw~ JtEQLYQU0 rpovtru OtT]V Ayia Oixoveveux.Etm «crto toy Aox xm tOY aYYALxo llAW!-tO». E o OOOLaAW!-tO~ 0 XO!-t!-tOllVW!-tO~. 'OtL T] XQLtLXij alltij Elvm 8EWQT]tLXij xm nQaxtLxij. ollvuynm uno to OOOLaAWtLXO xm XO!-t!-tOllVLOtLXOaltT]!-ta «vo xataotQacpouv». onw~ ot E!-tcp1JtE~vvoie. «xataAijYEL an' Ell8Ela~ OtO OOOLaALO!-tO xm toy XO!-t!-tOllVLO!-tO».H coto tT]V m08T]OLaQXla rou Aox xm tWV nQ06Qo!-twv toll. 000 xm oi llALOtE~ rtou EJtT]QEuOtT]Xav coto curov. ton» xm tEAO~ oro altT]!-ta «va xureotQacpouv oi aVtLXOLVWVLXE~ WtlE~ tT]~ EYXAT]!-tatLXij~Oll!-tnEQLCPOQU~».xataAiJYH OtL~ CPllOLXE~ JtWtij!-tE~ rou 180ll cuovc. 6T]Aal'iij tnv EJtLOij!-taVOT]aUu xm tT]V E!-tnQaXtT] E~UAEL'llJT] nov xmVWVLxwV Ollv8T]xWV rrou nQoxaAOUV xm E~T]Youv rnv nEJtol8T]0T] nw~ O. nQoun08Etollv xor. aou aJtEQQLJttEtOOO 0 Aox. n.tL !-tEtaBuAAELm.tL dvm a!-tEtuBAT]tO ornv av8QwmvT] CPUOT] etvoi mo OT]!-tavtLXO«no O. tWV onouov T] unaQ~T] xa8l0tatm anol'iExtij uno tnv . BWAOYLXUEltm VOT]tLEltE xu.oi «avtLXmVWVLxE~ eoue.xrrorsro» VEta MIIArIONA1: 0 llALO!-tO~ rtou nQOEtoL!-tu1. onoto «xataAijxm orov yH an' Ell8Ela~» 0 llALO!-tO~nOll nT]yu1. x. xatu toono rtou vo EXH 0 uv8Qwno~ tT]V E!-tnHQla toll nQay!-tatLxu av8Qwmvoll».x. oro altT]!-ta «va nQoocpEQ8El orov xa8Eva 0 XOLVWVLXO~XWQo~ zrou etvci avayxalo~ YLa rnv Exl'iijAWOT]tT]~ ovrotnrn. 0 EABEtLO~. nou aVr]XEL OtO !-tT]xaVLOtLXO llA LO uo. 0XL !-tOVO EJtwT]!-tav80uv xm va nooova I'iwQw80uv 8EWQT]tLXU. nQoun08Etollv xm tT]V XOLVwvLXij XQLtLxij. n.onw~ 0 «xaQtWLavo~ llALO!-tO~». EXH tc E~ij~ xaQaxtT]QwtLxu: ouvtorunu OtO altT]!-ta «vn oQyavw8El 0 E!-tnELQLxo~ xoouor. o oooLaALO!-to~ xm 0 xouuouviouo. toll eyXAijunroc». I'iT]Aal'iij 0 !-tT]xaVWtLXO~ llALO!-tO~tT]~ xaQtEOLavij~ q)1JOLxij~. tOY Bcxorvo aAAa 0XL tOY Hobbes. s OtT]V EwaywYrJ TOV Aoxuuo» yta tnv Avf)Qwmvl1 N011011.
tn:A'l]QWO£Lm va unoxororrrnot.tatwf.: 41 UJto8w'l] OtL UJt<XQX£L «Ef. XWQLS.OLXOVOf... OLaf. ev n:QOX£Lf.to nov £~£ALXtLXWV tcouov evo.X.£QOS.tas. f.tatLxi] LOLOOUYXQaoLa. Kru ornv Ayia Oixoveveux 'l] XOLvWVLXi] XQLtLXi] cpaLv£tm va n:QO'Un:08Et£LOtL f.. 0 n:Qo£QX0f. £mtQEn:£L tOY xa8oQwf.uai(} TOV AovDo{3iuov Bovaiuunn. 0 oOOLaAWf.tWa an:o rnv Ayia Oixoveveia n:Qocpavws.tOS.ta'l] cvctouto rou av8Qwn:ou f.tas. Jt. n:EQLOOOU rou cououou xm YLa rnv £~avtA'l]O'l] rorv ouvatoti]twv nov 8£WQ'l]tLXWV £QyaA£Lwv n:OU o cououo.tou.tcpwva ue rnv ozotc 'l] «XQLtLxi] nov On:AWV»n:QEn:£L OUf. H an:O'IjJTjYLa rnv XOLVWVLXi]xQmxi] n:OU n:QOXUJtt£L Ef. n:QEn:£Lvo ouox£tw8d ue t'n YVWOti] n:Qotao'l] t'l]S.tqxovo ue rn X£YY£ALaVi]S.tOS.tEV'l]XOLVWVLXi] xorccrccn. XOLVWxm VLXOS.tLXOS. x.tatwf.o I1POMAP3Il:TIKm: YAIl:MOl: KAI H KOINQNIKH KPITIKH l:TO I1PQIMO EPrO TOY MAP:. En:Lo'l]S.tOUVWf.tcpwva ue to oaQ(3wLxo ouot'l]f. 0X'l]f. £:JtLtQEn:£L xataMva (30Uf. OUf.tOS. erp' OOOV £Lvm aV£QXOf.t£rnv cvctouto rou m8i]xou. «ta~'l] OL' £ami]v».a.X. vo x tn «on:Aa t'l]S. on:ws.tLa mo rtooXWQ'l]f.tEV'l]S. autou orov onoto £mxQat£L 'l] EYY£Lan:QoooooS. a mo8av£tm mv avayx'l] va ouyxaAUJtt£L i] va £~WQa'Lv ~£L rnv n:QaXtLxi] t'l]S.n:QOOCPEQOUV ouvatot'l]ta tn YLa rnv xQmxi] t'l]S.t£ ornv f.t£tay£vEOt£Q'l] Ewaywy~ OTl1V K(}~uu~ Tl1~ IIoA~nu~~ Oixovouiai. n:QOY£VEOt£QOUOLXOVOf. xm 0 xouf. 0 xamtaAWtLXOS.tEVW torv UAWtLXWV ovnAi]'IjJ£WVn:£QLn:modas.tos. 1811~ Mn()v. TOV Aixaio» TOV XiYUfA ouf. xm ALYOt£QO YLa rnv £xxATjoLa xm t'l] 8wAoyLa. .OLaf.t£VOS.tLXOUxm XOLVWVLXOU0X'l]f. T'l]V UJto8w'l] ami] aQyot£Qa 8a avaJttu~ouv 0 Lombroso.tf..toQcpwo£. XQLtLxi]s.». oUf. (18572) OtL Evas. oto rnv aW8'l]OLaQxLa c UAWf. oe f...tCPUt'l]»£YXA'l]f. 0 raQOlxas. ALYOt£QO n:QOXWQ'l]f. oQoAoyLa t'l]S. n:. n:QOEA£UO'l]S.tatWti]QLO xm rnv n:OAmxi] oixovouto.0 MaQ~ cpaLv£tm va unruvtooeroa ornv A via Oixoveveux tnv an:01jJ'l] rtou oLa(3a~OUf. E~oaywy~~ OTl1vK(}~nu~ Tl1~CP~AOOOtpuu.t£tay£vE01.t£V'l]ta~'l] i].toQcpw8'l]x£ orov 'l] aOtLxi] ta~'l] aQXw£ va £VOLacpEQ£tm n:£Qwoot£QO YLa to XQ'l]f.
ue n~ HQooOl]A. H EI-lcpml] auti] ixovo- to I-lEtQO non £L VaL EI-lCPUtl]. tOU MaQ~ nou avacpEQovtaL orov nQOl-laQ~LOnx6 UALOI-l6. O£v SEtH to £Qwtl]l-la av l] Ql]ti] i] EI-lI-l£Ol]avacpoQu O£ lOl6tl]t£~ nou EXOUVEI-lcpmo xaQaxti]Qa i] EOtooto xaQaxti]Qa to y£Youe evo. ueoto rmv aLOSl]tl]- QLooVOQYUVoovrou. Ilovrcx vo. OOl]Y£L ornv rnr« rou . tu ~lOAOYlXU orov "Sancho" nQocpavw~ ornv £~i]Yl]oi] tou t£A£maLou Yla rov xatal-l£QLOl-l6 tl]~ £QyaxaQaxtl]QLOtlXU ue tl] YVooOti] SEOl] rou MaQ~ Yla tnv nQot£Qm6«£LVaL» O£ 0XEOl] ue tl] OUV£LOl]Ol]. tnto.lavtuiJ~ I&oAoyia~ Yla tnv XOLVoo- VlXi] nQoEA£UOl] tl]~ YAwooa~[lOl xcu tl]~ OUV£LOl]Ol]~nou y£v- crto rnv xorvorvixonornon tou £VOtLXtOU. to UAlonx6 mrro AOYlXU ornv un01jJl] Yla rnv nrrvroouvcutc Boxrov« Q£UI-la OOl]Y£L tl]~ naLO£La~. Av XaL ornv A via Otxoveveia 1jJ£oao tov Aox tl] SEOl] Yla rnv EI-lcpml] XaAOOUVl] tou avSQwnou. «no rnv £l-ln£lQLa XaL tl] ouvi]S£la. rou Jt£Qlcp£QHaxou XaL X£VtQlXOU V£UQlrou XaL UAAooV1jJUXOOOOl-lanxwv AHtoUQYlWV va avnoQu oru £Q£SL0l-lata EXH rnv EI-lcpml] lxav6tl]ta xatu rron nQOEQxoVtaL coro to Jt£Ql~UAAOV. rou. £1-lJt£lQLa nQoUnOSEtH xou ouotnunto.42 AYfon:rm: MIIAfIONA1: H 0XEOl] tou UALOI-l0Unou nQOEX'IJ'Ij)£ cno rov Aox ue rov orov 0 OOOLaALOI-l6 XaL tov X0I-lI-l0uvLOI-l6 anooacpl]VL~£taL OOOLaALOI-l6~XaL 0 XOI-lI-lOUVLOI-l6~ t£LVOUV va nQaYl-latonOLl]SOUv. rov Stimer XaL tOU V£L£~ tou MaQ~ anEvavn oLa~ nrro avSQwnou. An6 n~ naQatl]Qi]o£l~ XaL tov Aox.O£V I-lnOQ£LxataQxi]v 0 MaQ~ ano6LoH orov UALOI-l6rtou rtooexu- va S£ooQl]S£L oo~ to anOtEA£Ol-la tl]~ naLO£La~. on 0 MaQ~ oev SEtH n~ naQatl]Qi]oH~ vtstrn «uto to £Qwtl]l-la.rtou nQOEXU'tjJ£ coto rov OUVUY£taL or. mrtourrnouou oev Jt£QLOQL~Hrnv aAi]SHa tl]~ uALOnxi]~ SEOl]~ Yla rnv naVtoOUVal-lLa tl]~ naLO£La~. H un01jJl] ami] onxi]~ nQ6taol]~ anOt£A£L to AOYlX6 OUl-lnEQa0l-la tl]~ lJAl- ou l] avSQwm vn OUV£LOl]Ol]Olal-l0QcpwV£taL av XaL l] avacpoQu ornv on 0 uvSQoono~. O£ ouvoixiouo tl]~ n{)f.
evvoet 6tL OfV !-tnoQd va VO'l']8fL 00maALO!-t6r. Of V cpaLvftm va unaQXfL naQ6!-tOLa AOYLXi] 0XfO'l'] ava!-twa ornv nQ6tao'l'] YLa rnv navto6Uva!-tLa t'l']r. 8f!-tfALCD8d 'I']nQ6tao'l'] 'YLa tnv rnrvroouv« voutc t'l']r. 'I'] OXfO'l'] nou OUV6ffL rnv 8fO'l'] YLa rnv nnvroouvcuto t'l']r. Evr» qxuveroi. t'l']r. nmofLar. ou nQWL!-tOU r aAAa xm tou uerovevecteQOU MaQ~ nQOfxtfLvfL uurov tOU EABftLou.OU!-tnfQLAa!-tBaVO!-tfV'I']r. fVV'l']!-ta t'l']r. coto 600 stvm nQor. «xataAi]youv an' fu8fLar. nmOfLar. XCDQLr.OUVfXfLa t'l']r. '\jJUXOOCD!-tanxi]r. xm rnv UALOtLXi] nQ6tao'l'] YLa rnv navtoouva!-tLa t'l']r. YLa rnv OUVfL6'1']0'l'] xm rnv novtoouvcutc t'l']r. o MaQ~ BfBma AffL on OL UALOtLXfr. va unaQ~fL 'I'] avaAOY'I'] nQaxtLxi].. ~UVfnWr. naQanavCD fJtLcpUAa~fLr.ava!-twa ornv uALOnxi] nQ6tao'l'] YLa t'l'] ouvstonon CDr.onore 8a i]tav nA'I']mfOtfQOr. L1fV LOXUfL 6!-tCDr. ue toy 00maALO!-t6 xm tOY X0!-t- ..unfQBoALxi] 'I'] 8fO'l'] tou S. 0 onotot. Qot600 OEV8a fnQfJtf va 8fCDQ'I']8d CDr.o I1POMAP8I~TIKO~ rAI~Mo~ KAI H KOINnNIKH KPITIKH ~TO I1PnIMO EPro Tor MAPE 43 anO'\v'l']6tL 0 UALO!-t6r. nutov tou EABftLOU [121.f tnv navtoouva!-tLa t'l']r. nmOfLar. aAM va unv XataAi]~fL ornv fOQaLCDO'l'] OOOLaALO!-tOU tou XO!-trou xm !-tOUVLO!-tOUAAa aAAOU OLXOVO!-tLXOU XOLVCDVLXOU a xm 0X'I']!-tatLO!-tOU.'I']Ayia OUWYEVfta. xm t'l']r.toVLSfL nr. UA'I']r. nQOtaOfLr. naQa nr. UALO!-t6r. [Ill xm 8£(UQOUOf tn CPLAooocpLa rou CDr. xm tnv nQ6tao'l'] yLa rnv avayxm6t'l']ta tou OOOLaALO!-tOU xm tou xO!-t!-tOUVLO!-tOU.. f!-tcpUtfr. xm X0!-tuouviouo. aL08'1']maQxLar.avayxaonxa xm to aVtLOtQOCPO. Timpanaro or. Y ouvi]8fLar. vc unaQXfL AOYLXi] 0XfO'l'] OUVfJtaYCDyi]r. IlooqxrVwr... nQor. oro BLBALO tou Tux TO Ilvevua t6vLl. UA'I']r. nmodUl.. toy UALO!-t6tOU Diderot. nmodar.xm t'l']r. nm6fLar. f!-tnfLQLar. LOL6t'l']tfr. nmOfLar. tou Aox. nOQfL va LOXUfL'I']nQ6tao'l'] YLa rnv nnvroouvoM !-tLa t'l']r.» orov 00maALO!-t6 xm toy xO!-t!-toUVLO!-t6. nou OLxmoAoyoUvtm orto rnv cpQaonxi] xaAaQ6t'l']ta nou xaQaxt'l']QLSfLouxva nOAf!-tLxa xetusvc 6nCDr. 0 !-taQ~LOtLX6r.
touMXL<JtOV ornv Ayia Oixoveveux.nou nQOEXu'ljJ£uno tOY Brixorvn Xal tOY Aox. Oixoveveuu. ELVal 6!lW£ U~LO(Jl]!lELWto on (JU!lCPWVU rnv Ayia Oixoveveux Xal 0 UV£JttUWEVO£ X0!l!l0UVLue ouo. Oixoveveuu. l] CPLAO(JOCPLU <I>6u£QIlltUX 8£!l£ALWVH tl] 8£wQl]tLX~ (JUlllttwtOU a~ tOU£. nou L(JW£anOt£A£L unal VLWO (J£XCtnOLU!loQCP~UALX~£Ba(Jl]£. Owen. E~aAAou. nQOEQx£tm a!lWU uno to YUAALXO(JomUAL<J!lO£JtHO~ 0 «UYYALXO£ xm YUAALXO£ XO!l!lOUVL<J!lO£» UnOt£AOUV rnv E!lnQUXtl] aU!lntw(Jl] UAL<J!lOU xru uv8QwnL<J!lou. £L Val l] «evomro tl]£ nooooo» toU AOYLXOUxm tl]£ nQ0600u tl]£ nUQuywYLX~£ £QYU(JLU£». £cp' ooov Xall] 8£WQLUtou R. 8£!l£ALWV£tm ornv nuvroouvcquc tl]£ nmoELu£ xm tWV XOLVWVLXWV(Juv8l]xwv. rtou (Ju!lcpwvu ue toy 'EVYX£A£ UV~XH (J' uurov. EXH XUQLW£ uv8Qwmanx6 XUQuxt~QU. Mnooouue auv£Jtw£ VU un08E(JOU!l£ OtL 0 (JoaLUAL- .UV Xal 0 MUQ~ O£V nQotELvH OnOLUO~nOt£ OLaXQL<Jl] !l£tU~U L<JtOQLX~£Xal AOYLX~£ uvuYXal6tl]tu£. Xal 0 XO!l!lOUVLO!l6£ otov onOLO XUtUMYH o UAL<J!l6£. toU 1859. To !lOVO XUQuxtl]QL<Jnx6 rou uv8Qwm(JtLxou XO!l!lOUVL<J!lOUtl]£ A vias. oao».44 ArrOYErOE MTIArIONAE !lOUVL<J!l6 ELVal n£QL<Ja6t£Qo LatoQLX~ Xal 'ljJUXOAOYLX~ nUQa AOYLX~. o ooorcxiouo. ~£V YLV£tal os aXEal] ue uurov LOLULt£QO£ A6yo£ yw tL£ OUVa!lH£ Xal aXEa£L£nUQuywy~£ nou ouviotouv rnv UALX~ Baal] tou Xal unot£AouV ouotcrixo atoLX£LO xa8£ OLXOVO!lLXOUxm XOLVWVLXOUaXl]!lUtL(J!lOU. n£QLAU!lBavH xm tOY A£Y0!l£VO outomxo (JomUAL<J!lo. ouuqxovo ue tOY vvcooro II(}6Aoyo (JTr]V K(}~uurj Tr]~ IIoAmurj~ Otxovouioi. ornv Ayia Oixovtveia 0 (JO(JLUALO!lO£ al 0 xouX !lOUVL<J!lO£ nUQouma~£tm w£ XUtaAl]~l] tOU UAL<J!lOUtoU Boxorvc xm tOU Aox Xal YLv£tm A6yo£ YLU «UYYALX6xm YUAALXOxouuouviouo tOU 180u ouovc» [13]. IIQocpuvw£ 0 (JO(JLUAL<J!l6£Xal 0 XO!l!lOUVL<J!lO£tl]£ A vuu. nou unot£A£L OLOU(JXUALUrcov UALOtWV CPLAO(J6cpwv [14].
EnLal]~ 0 UAWf.touvwf. rrou avayvwQL~fl to aAu8l]to rcov aw8i)afwv.t6.tata.t0YfAUElorov uv8Qwno».tl] [16].t6aou nQOEXU'\jJf «no rnv XOaf.toQCPi) xouuouvtouou uno tnv onoto YfVVlOUVtal w~ SfXWQWtU atUOla 0 outomxo.tLatl]~ nalOfLa~ Xal 6Xl toy qwxfvtQlaf.tla~ alG8l]alaxi)~ «us Of. An6 tl~ naQatl]Qi)aEl~ nou nQol]yi)8l]xav nQoxuJttouv OQlouevo aUf. Ol]Aaoi) 0 aUVflOl]tu UAwtlx6tfQO~ XOf. avtWtOLXOUVos Eva AOYlX6 YEVO~ onoto ore f.tfVa ton MaQS Xal rou to 'EVYXfA~ UnOOlalQfLtal af fnlf.t6~ aut6~ rrou nl]yu~fl coto tOY Boxcovo OfLXVfl rnv UAl] va s£JtQO~UAAEl rnv Mf.tla OUVUf. nQuwa rtot: OfV uaXUEl Yla toy ouromxo coorcxiouo i) xouuouvtouo.tOU.tl]vda ouuqxovo ue rnv onoto 0 oootoxrouo. cnorexouv f.t6~. IIQocpavw~ OfV WXUfl Yla to doo~ fXfLVO tOU UAWf. Xal 0 XOf.ta8l]f.t6~ uovo 0 xouuouvtouoc. IIQwta an' 6Aa nQof. nou auf. mEloi) naQoumu- ° .t'\jJl]Xal mv notnon f. «outomxo» Xal «emornuovixc» oootoxiouo Xal xouuouviouo.tOU» rou Boxcovo Xal tou Aox.tf.tOAOYLa rou Hobbes Xal rnv xaQtfmavi) cpualxi).t6~aut6~ OlXalWVEltfAlXU rnv ncvtoouvof.touvwf. H UAl] fLVal Xal taut6XQova auvucpaaf. OfV taUtL~ftal ours an6 tOY MaQs ours an6 tOY 'EVYXfA~ ue tOY f.tla «aLa8l]al] cpumxi)>> nQocpavw~ anaAAaWEVl] uno f. 0 UAlGf.t6 [15].tEQOu~ fLOl]. Xal 0 XOf. nou avacpEQoVtal ornv Ayia Oixoveveta w~ nQaxtlxE~ ouvenflf~ tOU «UAlGf.tatonOLi)aEl~.tf.tOUrrou JtfQlYQUCPftal ornv Ayia Oixoveveia.tnfQuaf.tEvl]ue rnv f!J. Xal 0 emornuovrxoc.tatlXE~ aXl]f. 0 OfUtfQO~ £Xfl aacpi) auvfLOl]al] tl]~ UAlxi)~ ~ual]~ rrou nQoun08Etfl.tl]xavlatlx6 UAWf.nou 0 MaQs tautL~El fOW ue rnv aU8fVtlxi) mWti)f.t6~.tftaYfVEatfQa Xdf.tOQCPlU~» «v« xaf.tEl f.JtflQLatl]~ cpual]~. auvOEftal ue f. H tautWl] auti) WXUEluovo Yla toy UAlaf.o TIPOMAPSI~TIKO~ rAI~MO~ KAI H KOINQNIKH KPITIKH ~TO TIPOIMO EPfO Tor MAPS 45 ouo.taQswtlx6~ UAlouoc. 8a i)tav mLal]~ ouvat6 vo YLVElOfXti) l] fQf.ti) qxovc ue rnv Ayia Oixoveveux cotorexouv rnv XatUAl]Sl] fv6~ Qfu[tatO~ tOU aYYAlxoU UAWf.t!-!ouvlGf.
tLa JtQo08i]Xl] avayvCDQL~U rnv evotnro 8ECDQLa~ xm JtQUsl]~.tOU cpEtm ornv 6n ue tOY XEYXEA.tatLxou QLa TOU OOmaAWf.X xm OUVUf. JtQO'UJt08EtOUV 0 tOY OOOLaAWf.tJtELQLXU OOOf.tOUVWf. H f. To av8QCDJtLOnx6 tOU XOf.taQswnxi] ALWVEtm 0' auti] H CJXEOl] OQWf.tf. rnv JtQaYf.t6. ornv i] 0 Ayia Oixoveveia.taQswtLx6 UAWf.tOVLCJtLXi] 8ECJl] XOLvCDvLXi] xQLtLxi] 8Ef.tanx6 CD~ tOf.tOUVWf.tOUVWf.. H aVUAuOl] '\jJEUOU tOY wxuQWf.tOU xm 8ECDQLa[19]. Luvmw~ rou.tf.tf. JtaQoumu~u mWti]f. H YVCDCJti] T(}ir'f/ 8ea'f/ yw rov lPOVf(}!lJraX ouuqxovc ue rnv orroto JtaQE[3AE'\jJETO 6tL OL JtmoaYCDyoL EXOUV avu- .xrrorsro» ~u or« muoi] MTIArIONA1: tL~ AESU~ f. Kutn tl] CPQUOl] rou 'EVYXEA~. XCDQL~Xaf. avuf.t6~ xm 0 XOf. Ol]Aaoi] xru tEXVl]~. 6JtCD~ JtEQLYQUJtQO'UJt08EtU mv f. l] CJXEOl] EAAOYOU XaL Ef.taQsWtLxi] OtOLXELO TOU CJomaAWf. OUtE JtQO'UJt08EtU LOEa~ xm TOU Myou. xm rnv OOOf.ti] JtQaYf.tOU.t6~ ELvm orrnxo JtOU CJUOXEtLCJtl]XEcoto TOV AEVLV ue tn f.tEVO XaL to ExcpQaOl] tl]~ 6JtCD~ uJtOOtl]QL~U OUOXEtL~OVta~ Aoytx6 xat Enavaotaon.tl]~ tn CPUOl]6JtCD~ etvoi.tJtELQLXU OOCJf.tata.tEVCDV QEWUtCDV tOU JtQof. 6JtCD~ JtaQouoLU~Etm EVEQYEL<.t6.ta~ [17]. AOYLxi]~ xm tEXVLXi]~ nooooou OOl]YEL OTOV xo xaQaxti]Qa oooioxcouo n «uro xm tOY XOf. 6XL JtaQu tOY UV8QCDJtLOtLTOU~ aAAU EsmtLa~ tl]~ JtQOf.tOUxm tl]~ XOLvCDVLXi]~ XQLtLxi]~.tE<Ja XOU~E OTO CJtO Ef.tu.taQmv av8QCDJtWf.tEVOUxm JtQayf.tOUVWf. cpaLVEtm vc OLa- tOU Korsch 6tL 0 UAWf. OEV f.t6~ aJtoQQLJttEtm tOU MaQs uno uAAa oUYXQova i] TOU 'EVYXEA~. H UAWtLXi] orpern- TOU XOf.tEUAL- A via Oixoveveux.t6 [18]. 6JtCD~ JtQOEXU'ljJE «no TOV Aox xm tOY BUxCDva.ti] 0 MaQ- uno tL~ avaAuCJu~ TOU AAtOUCJEQ CJXEtLXU ue tOY f. «no rnv Ayia Otxo6JtCD~ nooLOEaAWtLXi] tOf.tOU.tf.t6~.tatLx6tl]ta 6JtCD~ EL voi.tEtaYEvEOtEQa xetuevc JtaAm6~ UAwf.taQSwtLXOU CJf.t6 xatUAOLJtO Ayia~ Oixoveveuu. 6JtCD~ JtEQLYQucpovtm veveux. muoi] avuyu LOLa tc JtQuyf. xuJttu swnx6 OEV EVtuCJCJEtm CJELOEOAOYLXE~xatl]yoQLE~.tEVOU ELvm OXEOl] tn OXEOl].
~XOJto~ tl]~ JtOAltlXi]~ EI. xata rnv mQLooo rtou EL vru aVEQX0!lEVl] ta~l]. H JtQOtaOl] Yla tnv Jtavtoouva!lLa tl]~ JtmoELa~ 8E!lEAlWVEtm coto tOY EA~EtlO ornv WCPEAl!llOtlXi] aQxi] -ou to av8Qwmvo ov orpououova tl~ EJtlOQaOEl~EXELvE~ noo avtaJtoxQLvovtm OtO OU!lCPEQOV OEtEAEmaLa avaAUOl] tOU. JtQEJtElv« aJtooacpl]vL~El tl] 0XEOl] ton ue to OU!lCPEQovta tl]~ aOtlxi]~ ta~l]~. oU!lcpwva ue tl] OlatUJtWOl] tou MaQ~. JtLol]~ l] «8uQaE 8EV». 0 WCPEAl!lLO!lO~EJtlxQLvEtm ornv Tt:(}llaVtU~ J&oAoyia xUQLw~ ue to EmXELQl]!la on urtooxortef oro v« OlOa~El OtOU~ .OUoLa~ ELvm va evoouovtou to ato!llXO OU!lCPEQOV JtQO~to Ol]!lOmo. 0 UALO!lO~JtOU UL08EtELtl] 8EOl] Yla rnv novroouvcquc tl]~ JtmoELa~ EL vci m8avotata 0 UALO!lO~rou EA~EtlOU.o llPOMAPSISTIKOS YAISMOS KAI H KOINQNIKH KPITIKH STO llPQJMO EPro TOY MAPS 47 yXl] v« JWlOEUTOUV aAAa JtEQlOQLOtl]XE ern 8EOl] yw rnv Jtavtoo1JVa!lLa tl]~ JtmOEla~ OU!lJtAl]QclWEl rnv Ayia OtUOYfVEta aAAa OEVrnv avmQEl. ot EUYEVEL~ ue rorv ~aOlAlXWV aUAWV aAM xm ot EJtavaOtatE~.Jt. Tov EJtltUYXaVEl !lEOW tl]~ JtmoELa~. tOU atO!llXOU xm tou av8Qwmvou. H EVVOlarou OU!lCPEQOvtO~ AEltouQYELW~ 01JVOEtlXO~ xQLXO~ !lEta~u tou ntojuxou xm rou XOlVWVlXOUi]. o MaQ~ OEV cpaLvEtm v« a!lcpLO~l]tEl tOY l]OOVLO!lOnou aJtOtEAEL to 8E!lEAlO rou UALOtlXOU WCPEAl!lLO!lOU. autE~ JtOUrou JtQoxaAOUV l]Oovi]. l] onoio tOY 8EWQElW~ OtaOLOtl]~ JtoQEla~ rou «JtvEU!lato~» JtQO~rnv curovvoioto.0 l]OOVlO!lO~ O!lW~ EmOlWXEtm orov uJtaQX01JVOQLO!lEVaXOlVWVlxa OtQW!lata rrou «vcatuooouv l]OOVlOtlXi] JtQaXtlxi] xm rnv EXAOYlXEUOUV rnv l]OOVLOtlxi] CPlAooocpLa. Hvm a~LOOl]!lELwto ou 0 MaQ~ ornv Ayia Oixoveveux cpaL VETm va 8EWQElW~ yvwQLO!la rou OOmaALO!lOUxm tOU XO!l!lOUVLO!lOUtn ou!lJttwOl] atO!llXOU xm «av8Qwmvou» OU!lcpEQOVtO~.X. OJt(u~ JtaQatl]Qi]8l]XE rno Jtavw. «XOO!llXi]» i] «yi]lVl]» LOtoQLa tOU JtQO!laQ~LOtlXOU UAlO!lOU OEaVtlOlaOtoAi] JtQO~auti] tou Stimer. loLw~ mrtot nou acp0!lOlWVOUV rnv JtVEU!latlxi] xaAAlEQYEla nov EUYEVWV [20].
xm cpLAamLar. SfCDQLa tl]r. rou MaQ~. YLa v« f~aAELcpSfL l] avtLS£Ol] ami]. 0XL OIJ. uov 0WCPfQOVtCDV toix xm CDr. fXlJ. fCPOOOV SflJ.f tOY «uviuoo» Bentham.aQ~Lonxi] oxomc IJ. «no toy Bentham xm toix AOLnoUr.Or. naQalJ.ata tou nQolJ. IJ. IJ.Or.l]()QOUV ELr. 0 CDCPEALIJ.CPfQOVtCDV ta~Lxa O'IJlJ.OUSa unooouoe v« Sf CDQl]8fL CDr.WIJ. noono'IJ xuJttEL «no oQWIJ.0 O'UV()ftLXOr.oLBaLar. orco». tl]r.8£Ol]r. XQLXOr.LOIJ. xaQaxti]Qar. YLatL 0 xaSoQLOIJ.nOQfL v« fvtaxSfL SfCDQl]tLXa orov lJ.nOQfL v« YLVfL A6yor. cpUOl]r. aVL()WtEAELar. avSQwmvl]r.IJ. avSQwmvl]r.no'IJ 0 EABEtLOr.EVEL aSflJ. . LUlJ.» [211.CDCPfALIJ.fALCDSd Of IJ.f to XfLlJ. tl]r. L'UV£Jtwr. 'lJnoOtl]QL~O'IJV nOnOL OXOALaOtEr. fxnQooWno'IJr.LXi] avaA uon.Oxm tOY XOIJ. «nfQLEYQatjJf rooo AalJ.8£Ol]r. «alJ.EVa QfUlJ.aQ~wnxo 'lJAWIJ..WIJ. aVL()wtEAELar.ftanf'IJOl]r.inoSEtEL nQwta an' oAa toy xaSoQwlJ.Or.fta~U tCDVonOLCDVxm uutot rrot: ovnxouv otnv «XQLtLXi] SfCDQLa».OVO ()fV IJ.La aonxi] nQaxnxi]. etvru IJ. £JtLBfBmwvEtm xm uno to Kupasaio [22]. ()l]IJ. xm uno lJ.LXWV O'IJIJ.oQCPi]rrou naLQVH Of xaSf WtoQLXi] nfQLO()O.O'UVWIJ.«ev YEVEL»xm tl]r. aVt(. fXlJ.. fCPOOOV Of anooacpl]VL~ftm 0 naQO()LXOr. Of avtLSfOl] IJ.AYrOYl:TOl: MTIArIONAE corou.inoSEOELr. tou aYYALxoU CDCPfALIJ. YLa f~EAL~l] tCDV atOIJ. xm cpLAa'IJtLar.La'lJAWtLXi] avSQCDnoAoyLa.aQ~wnxou 'lJAWIJ.Or. Erpooov anO()ELxvUftm 0 naQO()LXOr.fALCDroc.La aonxi] avtLAl]tjJl] aou O'IJVOtjJL~H IJ. cpUOl]r.ftanf'IJOl]r. IJ..OU xm «anoAoYl]tEr. Ev routou.fVO «uro. xaQaxti]Qar. LtO nAaLmo rou lJ.CDr.W'lJQyouvtm OL nQo'i.Or.OU xm EL()LxotfQa coto tOY EABEtLO. cvoueoo otn CPLAOOOCPLXi] xm rnv OLXOVOIJ.O.».Oxm nQaxnxa OTO OOOLaAWIJ. vo 1J.cpEQovta.cpCDvaIJ. 0 CDCPfALIJ. H anotjJl] on 'lJnaQXEL lJ.o tl]r.WIJ.nQa».BaQor.f tl] lJ.aQ~LOtLXOr. o CDCPfALIJ. avt(.aQ~Lonxou 'lJAWIJ.LOIJ. ron CDCPfALIJ. tCDV'lJALXWVurtuov tl]r.O'IJ nQo'i.
r. 7. :ITaQEx~aaT)r. Moscow-London. a. E:ITLaT)llalvEL Owen avayvwQL~EL xm tnv XAT)QOVOIlLx6tT)ta YLa tT)V O:ITOLa OEVylvEtm xa86Aou A6yor. <l>E~QouaQLOr.l.204 La Pensee Sociale au XVllle et au debut du 1geme siecle. o. E. R.T)r.a. o. On Materialism. TEuxor. Renouvier et l' histoire du meteiielisme. Collected Works.TIKm: YAIl. O. Renouvier et l' histoire du tneterielisme. :ITOU t avaCjJEQEtm ornv rotootc rou VE6tEQOUUALaIlOU xm tT)r.London. Engels. Collected Works. Moscow-London. Moscou 1989. t. 1976. To 8EIla aut6 EsEta~ELOLESooLxa 0 Bloch. BA. Bloch. 20 6. 191. E.R. 16-19 8. Bloch. 1 a. R. BA.29. :IT. .e. a. 20 14. a. O. OtUoYEVEtac. Collected Works. Marx. 11. London 1980.TO IlPmMO EPrO TOY MAPE 49 LHMEIQLEIL 1. Marx. Collected Works. London-Moscow. r. o. i. 299 x. Socialism Utopian and Scientific. 0 MaQs. Bloch. Koutcherenko. O:ITOLar. 14 13. Marx-Engels. 0 'EVYXEAr. 37. 6tL 0 1989. O. :IT. :IT. 24. 3. 15 x. KAI H KOINQNIKH KPITIKH l. 24. t. O. ELvm London. 201 4. t. Marx. aXEtLxi! IlEAEtT) uou oro e£())Qia xai Kotvoivia. aQ.1990. 16 5. 287-294. otnv Ayia Oixoveveux. 9.a. 977. 2. onp.o TIPOMAPEIl. R. 45-46. a. Renouvier et l' histoire du materialisme. 14 10. 1\Q8Qo ornv Koltiische Zeitung.a. Renouvier et histoire du msterislisme. Fr. 1987.. a. LE:JttEIl~QLOr. ~EV EsEta~W oL6AOU to 8EIla tWV :ITT)Ywv tT)r. s. Collected Works. G. Socialism. Utopian and Scientific. UYYQaa CjJEar. Collected Works 1989.. o. :IT.. a. 1975.MOl. La Pensee. Marx. 0. 12. Moscow- 2. 426 x.v. Bloch. Ayiac. Moscow.
3. 22 a. a. Ex6. German Ideology. Y. 16. 25. Collected Works. 2. 1965. The 16. R. 8EWQEL6tL 0 Boxcov xm 0 Aox ELa~YUynV tn ~LETUCP1JaLX~ ontLxtj CPLU. Law~ coto 6LacpOQEtLX~oxomn. On Materialism. 245-247.1987. 0 onotoc. 1980. A atT] cpLAoao- Collected Works.417-418. Novack. r.0 O. G. 478-479 17.N. a. n. London 1930. 671. t. o. Marx. 5. Reuouvier et l' histoire du metenslismc.50 Origin ofmaterialism.0 'EVYXEA~. t. a. Ost. a. ~ExLvaH u:il:6 nQuy[!utLxa Coilected Works. r. 6E6o[!EVa. L:toV S. 243 1976. Everyman's Library. .JV nOAAoL xm [!Etu~1J aAAwv 0 G.1987. a. Dialectic of Nature. Timpanaro. 21. 20. 5. nti-DUhring. a.. 9 xrrorsron MnArJONA~ 15. Collected Works. 22. a1J~LcpwvU[!E tOY 'EVYXEA~. London-Moscow. 'Onw~ unoatT]QL~01.. r. 385 London 19. t. 409. s. 25. 18. Bloch..
H IXELH THL XErKEAIANHL ~IAAEKTIKHL ME TO MAPEILMO L'Y'McpDNAME TON ENrKEAL .
.
a8l]lJ.OLOU~ tOU~ oQL<JIJ. oJtw~ rnv JtfQLYQUcpOUVOLtQfL~ a1JtOL <JtOxa<JtE~.A NTIKEIMENO TH~ EprA~IA~ AYTH~ EINAI H AIIO~A<f>HNI~H tl]~ <JXE<Jl]~ aVUIJ. to OJtOLOxataAl]YfL JtaQOIJ. XaL YfVLXU ~fXWQL~fL XaL cotouovoi- . «Onou UJtUQXfL XLVY)<Jl] XaL ~wi] l] OLaAfXtLX~ ~QL<JXftaL oe OQU<Jl]»[21. ELOLXOtfQa l] «OQU<Jl]»tl]~ OLaAEXtLxi]~ fLVaL cpavfQi] JtfQa<JIJ. H OLaAfXtLxi] OfLXVfL OtL mruouv O.f XUQLa avacpoQu tc EQya tou l] EVVOLatl]~ OLaAfXtLX~~ 'EVYXfA~.H (Verstand.. toy MaQ~ XaL tOY 'EVYXfA~.Oroiv fXCPQU~fL tOY rooao ovrrov ta1JtL~ftaL XaL tou JtfJtfQa<JIJ.tL nonv XaL OtL l] f~EAL~i] rou.OU~ IJ. l] EVVOLatl]~ UAl]~. tOU oLxaLou. <JtO «1J. ELOLXOtfQa 8a f~fta<JtoUV tcotoon» orov XEYXfA. H OLaAfxtLxi] IJ.XaL l] avtLOLa<JtoA~ tOU OLaAfXtLXOU XaL tou IJ.aQ~L<JlJ.atLxwv.OVOIJ. H OLaAfxtLxi] OLaAfXtLxi] QfLa XU8f ELVaL cpavfQi] orov xa8oQL<JlJ. Understanding).l]£LVaL». yf(DlJ.O XaL <JtOVlJ.E<Jaorn XEYXfALaV~ XaL tl] lJ.EAOYLXOU» oe oQL<JIJ.aQ~L<JtLxi] UJto'ljJl] YLa tn OLaAfXtLxi] IJ. l] UAL<JtLXi]«unoxotl]~ LO£aAL<JtLxi]~OLaAfXtLxi]~ tOU XEYXfA «no tOY MaQ~ XaL tOY 'EVYXfA~.ftQLa~.f tWV lJ.ou tOU ore «ns- va fLVaL <JUVtfAEL trn coto to «£LVaL» YLVftaL aVtLAl]Jtti] «OLa<JxfJttLXOU l] IJ.ftacpU<JLXOU roono» <JXE'ljJl]~ orov XfYXfALaVL<JIJ.f tn CPU<Jl] XaL rnv oU<JLatOU XU8f ovroc.fVl] M~xQrJ AoyocrJ rrl~ EYXVXAOJia{&ta~ TWV [11 0 XEYXfA AEfL OtL l] OLaAfXtLxi] uJtaQ~l]~ XaL aJtOtfAEL to VOIJ.OU~ LOLW~tl]~ avacpEQftaL XaL otn <JXE'ljJl].o.EVOU oro <JUVOAO rou. Ltl] C/J~AO<JOCP~XWVEJrWT'f/!lWV AfYOlJ.EVaovro».
tle. £Jtl<JtT]~Ovlxi]e.rtou XUQuxtT]Q(~EL rou. C'llVa~£le. cvcrosnouv tle. 0XEO£le. H ClUA£XtlXi] UvucpEQ£tm orov roono unuQ~T]e. £~EAl~T]e.54 xrrorsroa MIlArIONA~ VEL EVU UVtlX£(~£VO uno tu aAAuJ3] EnELci] T] £JtLYVWOT]tT]e. onwe. XUQuxtT]Ql<JtlXO tou roonon unuQ~T]e. T]ClUA£XtlXi] dvm T] «~wi]» xm T] «'IjJ'llxi]». nUQUYWYlXEe.. CT]AUCi]T]XlVYIti]QlU Mvu~T] tT]e. tU'lltotT]tue. ~OVO~EQELUe. oru.{a~ 0 MUQ~ C£LXV£l nwe.. lClotT]t£e. ClUA£Xtlxi]e..»J5] 'Onwe.. . ot nUQUYWYlXEe. AOYlxi]e. OXE'ljJYle. tnv £Q~YlV£U£l 0 XEYX£A. 0XEOELe. «ClucpOQae. 0XEOELe.». £CPUQ~o~OVtm OtYlV £~EAl~T] tWV nUQuywYlXWV c'UVa~£wv xm tnv £JtLCQUOi] tT]e.rtou UVtlXatOJttQ(~EL tle. nQOOCLOQW~OUe. AvaAoYT] UAAa rno ouvorrnxc Clat'llnW~EVT] £lvm YIEVVOlU tT]e.J6] ~£V Jt£QLOQ(~£tm ornv t'llmxi] ~OQCPi]tT]e.. T] «ClUA£XtlXi] AOYlXi]». otov U'lltEe. tYle. YVWOT]e. tYle. trov nQuy~atwv. rtou UVtUVUxAwvtm OtO uv8Qwmvo ~'lluM. xm £JtOlXOCo~i]~atoe. nUQUQWYlXEe. nUQUCOOluxi]e. tWV OVtWV xm tT]e.. torv nQuy~atwv £Lvm ott OCT]youvtm OtOV UCPUVl<J~O toix xm OtT] YEVWT] notouxc ClUCPOQ£tlXWV ovtwvJ8] EnELci] T] CWA£XtlXi] UVucpEQ£tm O£ ~OQCPEe. xm O£ xa8£ UVtlXEL~£vlxi] EXCPQUOi]tT]e. i] rno Y£VlXi] ~OQCPi] tou tQono'll unuQ~T]e. uv8QwmvT]e... OXE'ljJT]e. oxE'ljJYle.tou XEYX£A nQoxuJttEL on YIClUA£XtlXi] £Lvm 0 vouo. Arto tle.H «ClUA£XtlXi] AOYlxi]» UVucpEQ£tm oro y(yvw8m trov uQXwv xru rcov xUtYlYOQlWV tT]e.r4] CT]AUCi] tT]e. EJt£tm on T] ClUA£Xtlxi] £xCPQa~£l xm tOY roorco unuQ~T]e. OtT]V UQxi] tT]e. n·x· otn ~£ta~UOYI «no tT]V UQxi] tT]e. «£JtWti]~T]e. xm otn 0XEOT]~aOT]e.J9] 2:tov MUQ~ oi UQXEe.xm to YLyvw8m nov UVtlXEL~EVWV tT]e.oure ~OVO ornv «uAT]8lvi]» OXE'ljJT]P] £cp' OOOV T] uAi]8ELU C£v 'llnaQXEL xm C£v VO£Ltm uv£~aQtYltU uno tn nAaVT]. OtOV MUQ~. OXE'ljJT]e. UVucpEQ£tm xm oro «Jt£Ql£XO~£VO» tYle. ClUA£Xtlxi]e.xu8we. oxE'ljJYle. 'Erot OtOV llQ6AOYO OiTJV KQlitX1] iTJ~ llOAmX1]~ OlXOVO!l. tou ClUoxerrnxou AOYlXOU unot£Ad tT]V nQ'tin08wT] YlU tT]V nQooco tT]e. UVUAUOELe. nUQUtT]Q£l 0 IAlEvxocp.
~Q'llOAoy(a. 0 Luell x.f£ nou Ow6EOVTm IJ. TlJ IJ.O TlJVaVaJtT'llSlJ TWV nQ<inwv.£TOV 'EVYXfA£.oywv TlJ£ 6laA£XTlxi]£ coro TOV MaQs.lJ £Qyao(a£ roue IJ.£TlJV WTOQ(a TWV fJtWTlJlJ.EOWV naQaywyi]£ dvm aQVlJOlJTlJ£ XaJtlTaAlOTlxi]£ l6l0XTlJo(a£ toix. onuqxovc IJ.WVonw£ lJ <p'llOWAoy(a xm lJ £1J. 0 XOU!J.O[10].Ol. Yla o 'EVYX£A£ 6dXV£l IJ.f TOV 'EVYX£A£. Sa i]Tav 6'llVaTO v« OQlOTf( W£ lJ fJtlOTi]lJ.f IJ.nav dvm anOTEAWlJ. OUIJ.O£EX£l TlJV lOTOQ(a tou xm ETOl y£vvi]8lJX£ lJ anO'ljJlJ OTl TO y(yvw8m anOT£Ad TOV TQono unaQSlJ£ TlJ£ UAlJ£.a TO IJ. Yla naQa6£lYlJ.ETm OTOVXaJtlTaAWTlXO XOLVWVlXO0XlJlJ.£aVTaAAaYlJ.a8lJlJ.aTWIJ.EOWV naQaywyi]£ Yl' a'llTOU£ non nWAOUV TlJ MvalJ.<pwva IJ. xa8w£ xm lJ £SEAlSlJfJtWTlJlJ.lJxaVWTlxa nQOT'llna 0' a'llTE£ rtou 8£IJ.lJ TlJ£ lOTOQlXi]£ fSEAlSlJ£ TlJ£ av8gwJtl VlJ£ OXE'ljJlJ£[12] m TWV uooqxov TlJ£.aTOnOLi]8lJXf orov OL aOTO( «O'llVEronpov» TlJV <pfO'll6aQx(a.WVxm TWV XOLVWVlXWV 0XlJlJ. 0 'EVYX£A£ XQlJOlIJ. ava<pEQETm xm OTlJV £SEAlSlJ TlJ£ av8QwJtlvlJ£ OxE'ljJlJ£.£TlJ IJ.w80.o.fTa~aOlJ cno TlJV l6£aAWTlxi] OTlJV 'llAlOTlxi] 6laAfXTlxi].a lJ aVaA'll0lJ TlJ£ 0XEOlJ£avaueoo OTl£ EWOLf£ tou avayxa(o'll xm ton T'llxa(O'll. H 6 laA£XTlxi] .£now TQono lJ aQxi] TlJ£ aQVlJOlJ£ TlJ£ aQVlJOlJ£ £<paQIJ. Mto «no a'llTE£ dvm lJ £WOLx OAOYlxi] aVaA'llOlJ. 0 'EVYX£A£ .a TlJ£ YEVWlJ£ xm TlJ£ £SEAlsi]£ tou xm OTllJ <pUOlJ EX£l TlJV WTOQ(a TlJ£.[11] H IJ.Q'IJV <pQayIJ.fTa~aOlJ uno Tl£ fJtWTi]lJ.wv.OnOL£( l£ avaAUT O£l£ ton XEYX£A Yla TlJ 6laA£XTlxi] YlU v« «noouqmvtou Tl£ 8fWQlJTlXE£ nQoun08EOfl£ TWV £<paQlJ.aTlolJ.fAlWVOVTm OTlJVEWOLa TlJ£ fSEAlSlJ£ fSlJYf(. METa TlJV avaYEVVlJOlJ TWV qnxnxwv fJtWTlJlJ.. H XOLVWVlxi] l6wXTlJo(a TWV IJ.H 1:XE1:H TH1: XErKEAIANH1: IIIAAEKTIKH1: ME TO MAPSI1:MO 1:YM<!JQNA ME TON ENrKEA1: 55 anOT£A. H anooa<pi]vLOlJ a'llTi] Y(VfTm urro TOV 'EVYXfA£ Of owa<p£la IJ.0 L\aQ~(vo£.uTlxi] aVaA'll0lJ xru IJ. 0 Kovt xm 0 AaJtAa£ E6£lsav OTl TO lJAlUXO OUlJ.WV non nQaYlJ.£Jtl~f~u(woav TlJV anO'ljJlJ OTl o 'llAlXO£ XOOIJ.JtOAT. H XaJtlTaAWTlxi] l6wXTlJo(a £(vm aQVlJOlJTlJ£ l6wXTlJo(a£ TWV IJ.
T1']~anOA 'UTl]~ 1-t0vaQXla~ Xat ron £l-tnoQ£'lll-tanXOU xru TQan£I.[14) EnHoi] 1']av8Qwmvl] OXE'\jJ1'] £~1']Y£lTat «no TOV 'EVYX£A~ 1-t£O WTOQLXE~XaT1']YOQl£~.To T'llxalO 8a urtooouoe mlOl]~ vo OQWT£l W~ TO avayxalo.[l6)OL V0l-tOL T1']~OLaA£xnxi]~ nQoxunrouv «no acpalQ£01'] rtou OLaT1']Q£lo. 'ETOL nQonOLl-tal. OL £'llY£V£l~ O£V noov O£ 8E01']vc nQO~AE'\jJ0'UVTl]V £~EAL~1'] a'llTit. H OLaA£xnxi].H on 0 TQono~ unaQ~1']~ T1']~CPU01']~. H OXE01'] vayxmOT1']Ta~ xm TLJX1']~ lvm avaa £ AOYl] 1-t£Ol] 0XE01'] n£QL£X0l-tEVO'll xm 1-t0QCPi]~ 1-t£O1']OXEOl] T i] T OAO'll xm I-tEQO'll~. O'llOxnlOH~ tou XEYX£A [13) xm JtaQaT1']Q£l on av anOA'llTOnOLllOO'llI-t£ T1']VEWOLa T1']~avayxmOT1']Ta~ xm O£V T1']O'llOX£TlOO'llI-t£ 1-t£OO T'llxalO.nm 1']YEV£01']TWV £8VLXWV xQaTWV. otov O£V £lvm nMQw~ YVWOTO. Ennm on 1'] OLaA£xnxi] etvru 0 «VO1-t0~»i] 1']rno Y£VLXi] xat EAAOYl] 1-t0QCPi] T1']~WTOQla~ TWV XOLVWVLXWVOX1']l-tanOl-tWV.u XOLVOEX0'UVOL OLacpoQ£~ 1-t0QCPE~ T1']~£~EAL~1']~ OT1'] PU01'].LXOUxamTaAWl-t0U. Ka8£ Ta~Lxo~ XOLVWVLXO~ OX1']l-taTWl-tO~ 01']l-tLO'llQY£l vncpaOH~ nou O£V I-tnOQ£l vc ~£ma QaO£L. OTO TEAO~ton Meocuovc OL£'llY£V£l~ I.H n~ LOLOl-tOQCPl£~ tn O'lll-tmWl-tanxa xaQaxm XTl]QLonxa roue. avaynat OTO'll~mo Y£VLXOU~ vouois. T1']~WTOQLXi]~ £~EAL~1']~T1']~CPU01']~. xaTa TOV 'EVYX£A~. H OLaA£xnxit anooacp1']vll. Aao n~ aVTLcpaOH~ a'llTE~ nQoxumo'UV O'UVEnH£~ nou 1']£xaOTOT£ aQXO'lloa Ta~1']O£V I-tnOQ£l OUT£ va nQO~AE'\jJHOUT£ vc aVnl-tnWnlOH anOT£A£Ol-taTLxaJI5) I'ic naQaOHYl-ta. 8a XaTaAi]~O'llI-t£ O£ I-tLa T I-tOLQOAaTQLXi]aVTlA1']'\jJ1'] avaAOY1'] 1-t£O 8WAOYLXi]. ton nOALTWl-t0U Xat T1']~OXE'\jJ1']~vaynm a .56 xrrorzron MnArIONA~ XQ1']OqWJWL£l w:.l]TOUV Tl] XQ1']l-tanxit ~oit8Ha TWV £l-tnoQwv xm TWV TQaml. OUl-tcpwva Tl] 1-t£O1']Vonoto r« rtcvrc £~aQTWVTm «no T1']~OUA1']01'] m T1'] T x oQao1'] tou 8wu. 1']~XOLVWT Vla~ xm Tl]~ OXE'\jJ1']~.LTWV tou. C T1']VxOLVWVla Xat T1']OXE'\jJ1'] Xat O£V £~£TaI. oaotoix n£QLcpQOVOUv.TWV onokov 1']av8Qwmvl] OXE'\jJ1'] £lvm xm TO crno xm TO anOTEA£Ol-ta.
QaY[laTLx6tYlTa<. XEfKEAIANH~ alAAEKTIKH~ ME TO MAP:.. It« naQaoHY[la. LOTOQLXOU«ELVm». tYl<. [21) IIaQ6[lOLa 0XEOYl ava[l£Oa OTL<.ue tL<. 3EXLVWVTa~ ceto TL<. OLamOtWv£L 0 'EVYX£A~. ue acpETYlQLaOTYlV LOtoQLa TYI~ 01JVELOYlOYl<. XQYlOL[lOnOLEL T01J<..H J. tYl<.YM<I>!lNA ME TON ENfKEAJ. TYI<. XOLVWVLa~. nOLOTLX~<. n01J OTYlV naQaOOOLaX~ AOYLX~ aVacpEQOVTm ore «aVWTaTa». xatE1J81JVT~QLa aQX~ YLa vc nQOXWQ~O£L OE acpmQEO£L<. OYlAaO~ to y£vLx6TaTa yEVYI.H THJ. nov EcpaQ[lOYwv TYI~OLaAEXTLX~<. no toy MaQ~ « OtYlV E~EAL~YI v6~ XOLVWVLXOUOXYI[laTLO[lOUxru OTYI[lEta~aOYl E an6 Eva OEOO[lEVOXOLVWVLX6OXYI[laTLO[l6 OE Eva oLacpoQ£tLx6 XOLVWVLX6OXYI[laTLO[l6. E~EAL~YI<. n nQoUn08EO£L<. YI~ CPUOYl<. «no TYlVnoooTLx~ ornv nOLOTLX~[l£Ta~oM. ue tL<. T xm tYl<. 01JVaYOVTm OL «cvcoreQE~». [l£Ta~oM<.nQOOOLOQLO[lOU~ton XEYXEA W<.anooacpYlVLs£L TL~ 8£WQYltLXE<. £LOLXE<.[l£ta~aoYl<.OQLS01JV toix V6[l01J~ xm tL<.XEJ. An6 ru. xm YEVLX£UO£L~.AOYLX~<.[lOQCPE<. H OLaAExtLx~ AOYLX~ aVacpEQ£trn OtL~ mo YEVLXE~EWOL£<.[l9) OL YEVLXE~EWOLE<.TYI~OLaAEXTLX~<. OnOLE~ 0XYI[latonOLELtm YI E~EAL006[l£vYI OXE'\jJYI xm nQaY[latLX6TYlTa. XOLvwvLa~. n01J xaQaxtYlQLsH 6AE~ TL<. 57 oro YLyv£08mJ17) OL V6[lOL tYl~. TYI<.a1JtE<. H EWOLa TYI~OLaAEXtLX~<. 0 'EVYXEA~ avaY£L tnv E~~YYlOYIon MaQ~ YLa tn [l£Ta~aOYl coto TO XQ~[la OTO XEcpat Amo ~ «no to [lL086 OtYlV 1JnEQa~La OTYlVaQX~ TYI<.. YI [l£Ta~aOYl coto rnv nOOOtLX~ OTYlVnOLOtLX~ [l£Ta~oM xm YIaQVYlOYItYl<. aQXE<.mLOt~[l£~ n01J xm odXV01JV mo xa8aQa TO YLyv£08m xru TO OTOLXELO tYl<. [20) 0 XEYXEA xm 0 'EVYXEA<. croix OnOL01J~ aVacpEQ£Tm nLO 01JXVa 0 'EVYX£A~. tL<. aQVYlOYl~[18). CPUOYl<. «XatWtEQE~» EVVOLE~.AOYLX~xm 8EWr QLa Ev6<. n01J naLQV£L rn [lOQCP~ tYl~ 01JVELOYlOYl<.nQocpavw<. crro TOV XEYX£A. 6nw<.~QLOXOVTm OE0XEOYlaAAYlAOE~aQtYlOYl<....xm OL V6[lOL TYI~OLaAEXtLX~~ EX01JVOLat1Jnw8EL.I~MO J. 0 'EVYXEA<. 0 'EVYXEA<. £LVm YI aAAYlAOOL£LOO1JOYI aVtL8Errov torv... £~EAL006[lEV01J.an6'\jJ£L~ tou XEYX£A.n 8EWQOUVW<. OYlAaO~ OL mo YEVLXE<. t01J . £L~hxE~.
OrjAaoi] aVtLXH!!fVLxi] OtLXi] «cvcroomi» yVWOrj tall 0 MaQ~ xm 0 'EVYXfA~ f~rjyOUV ornv T£Qp. [ 2:ta VWVLxa fQya rou. Ano tnv avaA uon auti] tau XfYXfA :JtQOXU:JttfL OtL w~ :JtQay!!atLxo~. non u:JtOOti]QL~f OtL 0 8fO~ fLvm :JtMouo trj~ av8Qwmvrj~ cpavtaOLa~ xm aQVLftm OtL 0 av8Qw:Jt0~ . 0 MaQ~ £:JtrjQfa~ftm xm «no tov :JtQO!!aQ~LOtLXO a8f'(0!!O. ue trj ofLQa trj~. :JtQay!!atLxoti]twv tru OtO xfcpah ornon» rcov :Jtf:Jt£QaO!!fVWV «OLaox£:JttLrj «a:Jtoxata- xrn rorv :JtQOOOLOQLOW. !!fta~aAAOVtm ovtotntsc. Tnv LOWALOtLXi] coroxcrcorcon rtou f:JtLXHQfL 0 XfYXfA i] «ovctoom]» 0 MaQ~ 8fWQfL w~ «ava:JtoooyuQLO!!a» nou :JtQf:JtH vc f~aAfLcp8d YLa va u:JtaQ~£Lemcrrniovi:JtQay!!atLxou. 'EtOL 0 XfYXfA :JtQOtfLVfL !!La LOWALOtLxi] «a:Jtoxataotaorj» tOU :JtQay!!atLxou. :JtQf:JtfLva. 8fWQrj8d w~ «:JtQay!!atLxo~».58 xrrorsroa MllArIONA1: MaQ~ xm tau 'EVYXfA~ YLa rn i'JLaAfXtLxi] !!:JtOQfLvo ava~rjtrj8fL w~ :JtQO~rnv UALOtLXi] a:JtoxataOtaOrj aALOtLxi]~ OLaAfXtLxi]~ trj~ XfyxfALavi]~ LOf- o XfYXfA «no tOY MaQ~ xm rov 'EVYXfA~. o XOO!!O~ nou 8fWQfL tnt ouvi]8w~ XOO!!O~ rou «XOLVOUVOU».£voA.av£laj Ioeosovia rnv LOWAL- trj~ OXfOrj~ :JtQay!!atLxOu xm cpavtaotLxou coto trj OLa:JtLOtWOrj tL OL L()ff~ trj~ aQxouoa~ ta~rj~ O «nouovo» Of xUQo~. OTjAaoi] 0 w~ qxrvtuo'nw~ cpavtaotLxo~. £:JtfvMovtm ue xa80ALxo clLaOLxaoLa ami] :JtQay!!ata:JtOLd trn orcv rj aQXOlloa ta~rj oQa W~ fX:JtQOOW:JtO~ XOLVWVLXOU rou OUVOAOU23l. OrjAaoi] 0 XOO!!O~ torv m08i]ofwv. Avrtotooqxi. ouv£:Jtayftm YOU. Elver ouv£:Jtw~ avayxaLa xou» aVaAUtLXOU AOYLXOU fLvm ava:rtoooyUQLO!!fVO~ xm OtfXftau. CPLAooocpLa vet LOWALOtLxi] xm OtL 0 «XOO~lO~trj~ fL OtL 0 XOO!!O~ tall XOLVOU CPLAooocpLa~»:JtQoD:Jt08ftfL tnv :JtQay!!atwOrj tOU LOWALO!!OU.oyia rov Itveouaio. ll:JtOOtrjQL~fL OtL xa8f Ami].W tau tall [22l. 0 XOO!!O~ nou 8fwQfLtm OrjAaoi] 0 XOO!!O~ trj~ LOfa~ xm tau :JtvfU!!ata~. orn ([Jmvop. :JtQf:JtfLvc 8fWQrj8d xo~. cero !!La UALOtLxi] «oaoxctdotorm» xi]. H vovrci «no au8u:JtaQxtf~ rn oQaorj xm tL~ fmOLw~£L~ trj~.
H ~XE~H TH~ XErKEAIANH~
aIAAEKTIKH~
ME TO MAP8I~MO UM<I>IlNA ME TON ENrKEA~
59
etvoi ()ruuovQyruw rou 8£Ov. H aVtLA.'Y]'\jJll t'Y]<;8Q'Y]OX£llnxi]<; JtLOt'Y]<;,nou aJtot£A.£L «ovctoom]» t'Y]<;avnX£L~£vLxi]<; OXEO'Y]<; av8QwnOll xm 8£Ov, JtQEn£L va ~avaton08£t'Y]8EL ornv nQay~anxi] ~UO'Y]t'Y]<;.T'Y]v anoxatuotao'Y] allti] £JtLXELQ'Y]O£ <1>Oll£Q0 ~Jtax non llnOoti]QL~£ OLL cpaVtaOLLXO nA.6.o~a £Lvm 0 8£0<; xm nQay~anxo 0 uv8QwJto<; W<; aw8'Y]to ov, 0 MaQ~ axoA.oll8£L w<; Eva O'Y]~£LOt'Y]V «noxordororrn t'Y]<;OXEO'Y]<; av8QwJtoll xm 8£Ov, onw<; t'Y]V £Q~'Y]V£V£L0 <1>oll£Q~nax [24]. ~£ avtL8£O'Y] O~w<; ue toy <1>oll£Q~nax 0 MaQ~ ()EX£tm on 'Y]llA.Wnxi] «noxorncreon t'Y]<;OXEO'Y]<; av8QwnOll xm 8£OV YLv£tm us rnv «nQu~'Y]», 'Y]onolo £~'Y]YEL ceto t'Y] 0XEO'Y]t'Y]<;ue n<; OllYX£XQL~EV£<; tototru QLXE<;01JV8i]x£<; xutw «no n<; onote; JtQay~atonOLELtm [25]. ~ta nQWL~a EQya ton MaQ~ 'Y]llA.Wnxi] anoxatuOtao'Y] t'Y]<; L()£aA.LOnxi]<; avatQoJti]<; t'Y]<;OXEO'Y]<; nQay~anxov xm qxrvtoOtLXOV OllV()E£tm ue rnv «nQu~'Y]» xm ue roix WtoQLXOXOLVWVLXOV<;OQOll<; nou £~'Y]yOVVt'Y] YEV£Oi] t'Y]<;,0XL O~w<; us EWOL£<; OJtw<; OL naQaywYLxE<; ()1JVU~£L<;,OL naQaywYLXE<; OXEO£L<;,«'Y] JtUA.'Y]WV tu~£WV». [26] QOtOOo 'Y]£Jt£~£QyaoLa t'Y]<;EWOLa<; t'Y]<; t nQu~'Y]<; ore V£aVLXu EQya ton MaQ~ O()'Y]YELQo<; t'Y]V avaywyi] n t'Y]<;Ot'Y]VEWOLa t'Y]<;£QyaoLa<; [27]. IIaQuA.A.'Y]A.a ue t'Y]V «llA.LOnxi] anOxatuotao'Y]» toll <1>Oll£Q~nax O£ 0XEO'Y]ue tn 8Q'Y]OX£Laxm toy uv8Qwno w<; mo8'Y]to OV, 'Y]tuo'Y] tou MaQ~ YLa «llA.Wnxi] anoxatuotao'Y]» t'Y]<;«L()£aA.wnxi]<; cvcroomi;» t'Y]<; OXEO'Y]<; JtQay~atLxov xm qxrvroonxov «no toy XEyX£A. £vwxv£tm «no t'Y]V xQLtLxi] tou anEvovn otov XEyX£A., nou aQXL~£L oro 1841, otov 0 MaQ~ etvru axo~'Y] X£yx£A.Lavo<;. 0 MaQ~ XQ'Y]OL~OJtOL£L £yx£A.LavE<; xat'Y]X YOQL£<;YLa vc a~cpw~'Y]ti]o£L OQW~EV£<; coro n<; 8£~£A.LW()£L<; EWOL£<; t'Y]<;CPLA.OoocpLa<; XEyX£A. [28]. 'EWL 0 MaQ~ naQaton t'Y]Q£L on 'Y]X£yx£A.Lavi] unO'\jJ'Y]YLa to xQutO<; w<; £vouQXWO'Y] toll «AOYOll», ~JtOQ£L vc EX£LaVtLxQLo~a Ot'Y]V nQay~anxot'Y]to, ~OVO o» aoxELtm a~ELA.LXt'Y]xQLtLxi] YLa xu8£ avoQ80A.0Yo
60
AYrOYl:TOl: MIIArIONAl:
xaQaxtl]Qwnxo tl]~ unaQxouoa~ XataotaOl]~ nQay!!atwv. H anal men Yla uAwnx~ «noxctcotcon tl]~ cvcnooovuQW!!EVl]~lOEaA.lOnX~~ avtlA.l]'\jJl]~tou XEyX£A. la rnv urrooto, Y nou rnv £sl]yd «no rnv lOEa,nQoooLOQl~£lxm OQW!!EV£~ QlX nXE~ tou MaQs Yla toy XEyX£A.,nou ola~a~ow£ oro XfLQ6voaaa tou 1844. Lto EQYO auto 0 MaQS, avayvwQl~£l on 0 Y.EyX£A. ern cfJmvo/lEvoAoyia rov Ilveouato; xatavod on l] ruotc» tOU av8Qwnou £lvm to anOtEA.W!!a tl]~ £Qyaola~ tl. 0 XEYXEA.O!!W~ avayvwQl~£l !!OVO tn OlavOl]tlX~ EQyaola[29). Ito toy MaQs l] OlaVOl]nX~ EQyaola OEV!!noQEl vo unaQs£l, av nQOl]yoU!!EVW~ av8Qwno~, rtou aQXlxa Elvm 0 <pUOlXO, otourrnxo xm m08l]to OV,OEVnaQayaY£l to !!EOa!!E rc onotc 8a Esao<paA.lO£l «~w~» tou, H 0XEOl]OlaVOl]nX~~ tl] xm naQaywYlx~~ £Qyaola~ nQEn£l vc anoxataOta8El ornv nQay!!anx~, UA.lX~~aol] tl]~ xm v« <pavd on YEv£nxa l] Olavorrnxr] EQyaola nQoun08Et£l rn naQaywYlx~ £Qyaola. H anoxataotaol] tl]~ nQay!!anx~~ OXEOl]~ cvcueoo oro UA.lXO xm to lO£atO, nou 0 MaQs ore EQyatOU tl]~ nEQloooU 1844-1847 tELVELvc ESO!!OlWOEl!!E tn 0XEOl] cvoueou OtO nQay!!anxo xm to qxrvtcouxo, 8£!!EA.lWV£l OQW!!EVE~no n~ « xQmxE~ ton Yla tOU~XEyxEA.laVOU~ aQwt£Qa~, £lOlXOt£Qa tl]~ Yla toy Mnoouvo Macoueo xm tOY Mas LtlQVEQ.'EWl ornv Ayia OUWytVfW 0 MaQS tOVl~£l on l] «cutoououvuonotc» OEVnaQaY£l tOY nQay!!anxo av8Qwno. Avt18Eta, l] «cutoouveionoto» dvm nQo·(ov tl]~ oQaol]~ tOU nQay!!atlxoU av8Qwrtou [30). H A.OYlX~ «OUOla»ESl]ydtm «no tl] «qnxrn» xm OEV OU!!~alVEl to avtl8Eto. Ltl] FEQp,av£lCrj I&oAoyia 0 MaQs xm 0 'EVYXEA.~ mxQlE VOUVtOY LtlQVEQ Ylatl, ESEta~Ovta~ rnv aQxala torootc, ton08EtEl tn YEyovota «navw OtO x£<paA.l OU~», £JtElO~£Sl]t yd tnv «UA.lX~iorootc» «no rnv «urtooto torv lOEWOWV» [31). H avnXEl!!£VlX~ YVWOl]tl]~ WtOQla~, aut~ Ol]A.aO~ nou ovrc-
H l:XE~H THl: XErKEAIANHl: aIAAEKTlKHl: ME TO MAP:;:Il:MO ~YM<!JnNAME TON ENrKEAl:
6r
rtOXQLV£tm ore XUQla xaQaXtT]Qwnxa «UAlX~
tT]£ WtoQlX~£
£~EAl-
~T]£, £m~UAAH va £~T]YT]8fLT] «iorootc torv l6£w6wv»
«no rn
iorootc»
torv
toonorv
rtaQaywyi)£.
H uAwnx~
IJ,anx6 xm to
cnoxcrcorcon tT]£ OXEOT]£ ovouso« OtO rtQay-
qxrvtcouxo
6£v ~tav ouvuto
va rtQaYlJ,atortOltnv
T]8£L IJ,£tn 8£wQT]tlxa T]8lXOAOYlxi) aUtE£ xQmx~£ ouuqxovc XQl nxi)
oxi)lJ,ata
tWV X£YX£Alavwv tT]£ aQwt£tT]£ 8QT]OX£La£xm YWtL oi IJ,OQCPE£ «avatQort~»,
QU£, 6T]Aa6~ IJ,£tn 8£OAOYlxi) xQmxi) rtQOVrt08EtoUV
tT]£ artoA utaQXLa£,
rnv
l6£aAwnx~
IJ,£tnv
onoto
T] 8QT]OX£Laxm T] artoAUtaQXLa rtQOOartOxataotaOT]£ tT]£ lO£aAwn-
6WQL~OUVto XOlVWVlX6 yLyvw8m. IIQovrt68wT] x~£ avatQort~£ nov «y~lVWV» aut6£ 6laA£xnx~ tT]£ uAwnx~£ £Lvm, OUlJ,cpwva IJ,£toy MaQ~, 0 xa8oQwlJ,6£ urruov rtou rnv £~T]youv [32]. 0 xa8oQwlJ,6£ va YLVH IJ,6vo IJ,£acp£tT]QLa IJ,la uAlonx~
fLvm 6uvat6
EOtW xm IJ,T] AOXAT]QWIJ,EVT] aQX~£, frtT]Q£aOIJ,£O £~ OlXOVOIJ,La, lOLW£ tTl 8£WQLa rou
VT] 6Xl IJ,6vo «no tT]V av8QwrtoAOYLa tou <I>6u£QlJ,rtaxaAAa xm
«no
tT]V aYYAlx~ rtOAmx~
PlXUQVtO Yla tT]V urt£Qa~La, tTl 8£WQLa tou Avrou ~lJ,l8 Yla tOY xatalJ,£QwlJ,6 tT]£ £QyaoLa£ xm Yla tT]V £QyaoLa £VYEVH W£ rtQoo6wQwnx6 onx~ otOlXfLO Yla tT]V a~La tT]£ l6£aAwnx~£
evo;
rtQo·C6vtO£. H UAltT]£ OXEOT]£
artoxatuotaOT]
avatQort~£
rtQaYlJ,anXOU xm qxrvtconxou IJ,£n£ avaAUOH£ tou ~wlJ,6vn uvcornxroovtm ~WIJ,6Vtl, oomaAWtwV, Yla tou; ~H
rtQErtH frtLOT]£ va OUOX£tWt£L Yla tT]V £~a8ALWOT]nov £Qya-
~OIJ,EVWV nou OT]lJ,wuQYOUVoi 0XEOH£ rtaQaywy~£,
ot
OrtOL££
oro rtAaLOW tOU ~WIJ,T]xaVlxou XamtaAWIJ,OU. tT]£ aYYAlx~£ rtOAmx~£ avaAUO£l£ OlXOVOIJ,La£, rou rorv outornxcov
Oi avaAUO£l£
OQWIJ,EV££ «rtaQaywyou£»
«no
tl£
lOlaLt£Qa tou ~mv-~lIJ,6v, xm roix
tOU OrtOLOUT] 8£WQLa
«frtWt~IJ,OV££» rtQO£tolIJ,UIJ,£tT]V
tn lJ,aQ~wnx~
UrtO'ljJT] la tT]V aVatQOrt~ torv rtaQaYWYlxwV Y
0XEO£WVcoto n£ rtaQaYWYlxE£ 6UVUIJ,H£, O£ ouvouoouo
LtO JtQ(Dt033 o MaQS YQacpH: «II ()laA£lmxi] 1"'011!!E80()o~ ()£V £Lvm !!OVO ()lacpoQ£nxi] «no tn XEyx£Alavij ana Xo.l(i~o'UV tn 8£wQLa rou MaQ~.L avtL8£tl]. OJtW~ xm 0 MaQ~. oJtw~ aVtavaXAUtm OtO av8Qwmvo !!llaM xm !!£taCPQa~£tm O£ !!OQCPE~toxao!!ou». Ano to xaAoxaLQl toll 1844 0 'EVYX£A~xm 0 MaQ~ avaYVWQL~O'UVon oi aJtO'IjJ£l~ toix Oll!!JtLJttO'UVO£ OAa to 8E!!ata [361. IIQEJt£l va ~avaOta8£L ore JtO()la tll~ Yla va ~Q£8EL xru va aJtoxa8aQ8EL 0 OQ80AOYlXO~ JtllQijva~ tll~ cno to uoonxumxo mQL~All!!U tl]~ [351. rnv onoto OVO!!a~H lOEa xm !!£ta~aAAH O£ a1l8uJtaQxtO aVtlX£L!!£VO. 0 JtQay!!anxo~ XOO!!O~ £Lvm l] cpmVO!!£Vlxi] !!OQCPi]l]~ l()Ea~ [341. H 8£WQLUamrj 8£!!£Al(bv£tm ornv llAwnxij nnoxorcororm tl]~ l()£aAwnxi]c. a1Jtij~ £X8EtH 0 MaQS O£ ()1l0 X£L!!£Vatoll Kupasaio». 0 MaQ~ avayvwQL~H on o XEYX£A JtaQollola~H tn Y£Vlxi] !!oQCPi]xm rnv £Jt£~£QyaoLa tl]~ ()laA£xnxij~ 1"'£toone rrou ()ELXVHJtAllQOtl]ta. rc onoto avacpEQovtm ornv llAWtLXij ()laA£xtlxi].xrrorsro» MIIArIONA~ X£YX£Alavtl ()laA£Xtlxij. ()laA£xnxij~. on xa8£ ta~lxO~ xmvwvlxo~ OXl]!!ano!!o~. To JtQoYQa!!!!a tl]~ «noxctcotoon. l] IbEa ()£V £Lvm tLJtOt ts aAAo coto tOY llAlXO XOO!!O. avaYVWQL~H on l] L()la l] X£Yx£Alavi] ()laA£xnxi] JtQOOCPEQHto 8£wQl]nxu oxi]!!ata nou 8a . xcrovonon xm vvoxm.. o LtO ()£Ut£Qo X£L!!£VO. Kru oi ()1l0 avaYVWQL~01JV rnv avuyxll tl]~ llAlonxi]~ aJtoxataOtaOll~ tl]~ l()£aAwnxi]~ ()WA£xnxi]~. Tnv llAwnxi] aJtoxataOtaOl] tll~ l()£aAlonxi]~ ()laA£xtlxi]~ JtQay!!atOJtOlEL 0 'EVYX£A~ XllQLW~ O£ 0XEOl] 1"'£ rnv WtOQLa nov £Jtw'tl]!!Wv. ELvm 0 ()l]!!WllQYO~ tou JtQay!!atlxou XOO!!Oll. JtQo£toq. 0 'EVYX£A~. Ito !!EVa. £~£ALO{J£tm JtQO~ tn aQVl]oij rou. Ltov XEYX£A O!!W~ l] ()WA£xnxi] OtEx£tm OtO x£cpaAl tl]~. l()laLt£Qa 0 xcmtaAWtlXO~. to YVWOtO £JtL!!£tQO tl]~ ()£ut£Ql]~ Y£Q!!aVlxi]~ EX()OOl]~ton Keaasaiou. avtW£ta. Ito tOY XEYX£A l] ()La()lXaOLa rou otoxao!!ou nou y£vvl£tm crto to av8Qwmvo !!llaM.
l] aJto'\jJl] rou XEyx£A on to JtQaYflanxo etvrn AOYlxo.avi] taVtLOl] rou roono» vJtaQ~l]~ trov OVtWVue to Ylyv£08m. tautl~ovtm ue to <. ouveionronorst tnv avayxl] ot cpQao£l£ va fll] ouyxaAvJttouv rnv JtQYflanXOtl]ta aAAa v« xa8oQl~£tm to vOl]fla rou. oJtw£ xm OtOV MaQ~. LlIAAEKTIKHJ. no mv aJto'\jJl] aunl JtQOXVJttH l] a. rtou OVflcpwva ue COVXEyx£A «noteAOvv to xat' £~oXilVJtQaYflunxo.JtQay!-"anxo».vayxl] flla£ «uALOnA xi]£ aJtoxataotaol]£» tl]£ JtoAltlxi]£ OXE'\jJl]£.ootnrc aJtOt£A£l cpvno ouxi]£ to OJtOlO XQl]Olfl£V£L va ouyxaAucp8£l l] JtQaYflan: Yla xi] XOlVWVlXi] vioomro. 'OJtw£ xcu 0 MaQ~. rtou JtQaYflatOJtOl£l xata to Etl] 1842-1844 [38J. ME TO MAP8IJ. Iui JtaQ<lOH Yfla. £lvm Owato va Jta'\jJow vo. 0 'Evyx£A£ JtaQatl]Q£l on l] tUJtlxi]. VOfllXi] roo rnt« oev JtQEJt£l va ouyxaAvJtt£L xm vc OUOxOtl~£Lrnv vJtaQ~l] tl]£ JtQaYflanxi]£ XOlVWVlXi]£ ovioorntr«. av ouOX£ttat£l ~L£tl] X£'l}t£A'. nou 8a 6£l~H ue oacpi]vHa on l] tUJtlxi].H TH~ XEfKEAIANHJ..vayxl] r tl]£ uAlonxi]£ aJtoxataotaol]£ Tll£ avaJtoooyuQLOflEVl]£ lOEaAlOtlxi]£ OlaA£Xtlxi]£ tou XEYX£A xatw a. rnv onoto osv flJtOQ£lva £~aA£l'\jJ£L. VOfllXi] i. u H UAlOtlXi]aJtoxataotaol] tl]£ avaJtoooyuQLOflEVl]£ lOEaAlOtlxi]£ OlaA£xnxi]£ JtQOUJt08Et£L orov 'Evyx£A£.MO J. E~aAAou.H ~XEJ. 0 'EVYX£A£. OOl]Y£lOtO oWtJtEQaofla on to JtQUYflanxo !tJWQ£t va Jta'\jJ£L £lvm «JtQaY~tanxo» [37J. £L6lXOt£Qa tou a8E"t:OflOVrou <I>ou£QflJtax. O£ 0XEOl]ue auti]v.Jto t'1']'1 £JtlOQaOl]tl]£ fl£AEtl]£ tl]£ aYYAlxi]£ JtOAltlxi]£ oixovoutnc.oJtw£ xm 0 MaQ~. on 0 av8QwJto£ flJtOQ£l va avaJttv~£L 01.YM<I>ONA ME TON ENfKEA~ 63 10mtQE1jJOWtnv uAlOnxi] aJtoxmaotaoi] tl]£.. 0 'EvY){£A£OW£LO'l']tOJWl£l nv a. tnv aJto'\jJl] tou JtQOflaQ~lOnxov a8E"t:OflOV.££n£ lOlOtl]t££ xru 01. XWQl£ Wot600 va aJtoA utoaout tnt l] avayxl] rou aywva xata tl]£ . Aga va l] l<)EUxm to rrveuun. [39J.££n£ ouvatotl]t££ rtou l] JtaQaooOlaxi] 8Ql]ox£unxi] JtlOtl] aJtE6l0£ oro 8£0 [40J. LxoAla~Ovta£ rnv xcrcorcon tl]£ AYYAla£ fl£ta rn ~LOfll]xavlxi] encvootoon.
wAEUUUrl r1J~ <Pva1J~ [431.a8oQlSEL OtL l] OXEOl] aVUI!EOa ornv LOEaALOtLX.i]» ornv «1JALOtLX.tLx.m 0 MaQ~. cpUOl]e.i] ElVm aVUAOYl] I!E tl] I!EtU~aon cno tl] CPLAOOOcplatl]e. x. W o 'EVyx. cnox. OQLOI!EVOL 01JWmx. EJtLOti]l!l] [441.nx. Ol VEL I!W JtEQLEx.aolEe. JtEQLYQUCPEL10 nQoYQal!!W tl]e.i] OLaAEx.aOlae.i] [451.EALaVOl tl]e.nx.i] OLaAEx. EnlOl]e.i]e. onWe. OWAEx. aAM ~EX. XQl](JLI!OnOLEl I!La UAAl] aVaAOYla YLa va unooacpl]VlOEL tn I!EtU~aOl] uno rnv «LOEaALOtLX.1.O JtEQl~Al]l!a» tl]e. 10 Ex.i] x.i]e.avav OL XEyx.i].m UAAWV naQOI!OLWV I!OQCPWV E~EALx.m nAl]QOtl]ta.tLx.m «noteAEOl!aWe. x.m oLm08uvovtm tl] OLaAEx.EAe. I!E tLe. LOEaALOtLx.nx.tLx. OWOLx.ELW.i]x.EA I!ae..tLx.i]x.WAEUUUrl rlJ~ <Pva1J~ YQUCPEL[421: « 0 XEYX.i]e.i]e.LOtLx. tcutorntcc.i]e.Oe.i]» OLaAEx.tLx. H avaAOYla a1Jti] 1JnuQXEL aVUI!E0a orn I!EtU~aOl] uno rnv LOEaALOtLx.LVUELcoto I!La Aa8EI!EVl] acpEtl]Qla».m rnv E~i]Yl]Oi] tl]e.EAe. OLaAEx.i] i] «OQ80AOYLX.i]» i] 1JALOnx. xrn 0 MaQ~. tl]e. OWtEAEltm l] I!EtU~aOl] cno rnv LOEaAWtLX. cpaVEQWl!atOe.i] ornv «OQ80AOYLx. «aVtEOtQaI!I!EVl]e. I!E ne.a8oQlsEL OtL 0 «OQ80AOYLx. avuYEtm otov nQOOOLOQLOI!O coto tov XEYX.. OW XWQO xrn OW XQOVO. tl]e. onote. x. x.i]» i] «1!1JOtLX.m tnv 1JALOnx.i]e.i] ornv 1JALOtLX. cero cpm VOI!EVa onWe. lOWe. I!OQcpEe. aAAl]AOE~UQtl]Ol]e. onWe.EAe. Kru YW rov 'EVyx. nrrtou x.i]. OLaOLx. ElVm l] 01JOXEtWi] tl]e.a8oQlsEL tLe. 1JAWtLx.i] e.Ol YVWQlsow x. OI!We.WtLX. n I!EtU~aOl] cno tl] XEyx.i] E~i]Yl]Ol] YW tl] 8EQI!Otl]ta uno I!La «8EQl!aVnx. OLUcpOQEe.i] O'IJVal!l]» x. x.m tamOAOYLx.1. n1JQi]vee» tl]e.» LOEaAWtLx. XEYx. Itc naQUOELYl!a. I!E I!EyaAUtEQl] ax..i]OLaAEx. l] tQL~i]. 0 'Evyx. Ltl] .EALavi] ornv 1JALOtLX.tLx.Ql~ELa x.i]e.m tl] I!EtU~aOl] «no WV ouromxo OWV EmOtl]I!OVLX. aQLOtEQUe. 0 'EVyx. x. [411. OLaAEx.nx.EAe.tLX. LOEae.atUOtaOl]e.tLx.i] ElVm aVUAOYl] I!E tl] OXEOl] aVUI!E0a otn AEX. Ltl] .O OO(JLaALOI!O. o 'EVyx. 10 «1!1JOtLX.EA tl]e.i]e.i]» i] «OQ80AOYLX.i]» OLaAEx. OLaAEx. orn CP1J(JLx.m OWcpOQUe. OnWe.tLx.i] OUVO\jJl] tl]e.EALavi]e.xrrorsros MIIArIONAl: 8Ql]ox. 0 ..EAe. LacpEOtEQa «no rov MaQ~.
OJtW~ ornv Jt£QlmWOl] rou LmV-LL!lOV xm rou <l>OUQLE. rtou 8£wQouo£ to OOmaALO!lO w~ ExcpQaOl] tl]~ LOEa~ ron oLxalou xm rou Aovot: [48]. l] LOLO!lOQcpla aut~ tWV 8£WQLWV yLa toy outomxo OOOLaALO!lO ocp£lAEtm xata XUQLOMyo oro y£yovo~ OtL avamux8l]xav O£ Jt£QlOOO JtOU l] avamUSl] tou xamtaALO!lOU O£V dX£ JtQOXWQ~OH [47] xm OL £S£ALXtLXE~taOH~ rou O£V dxav «noocqmvurtet. l] LOcaALOtLX~ OLaA£XtLX~ ovcorruoottrn O£ !lLa XWQa.xm tl]~ «LOEa~». Entorj. oure tL~ OLaOLxaOl£~ ue tL~ OJtOl£~ l] tEA£La XOLVWVla 8a unoQOUO£ vc JtQaY!latoJtOLl]8£L Kntn toy 'EVYX£A~. tl] I'eouovtc. Luv~8w~ 0 ouromxo. QOtO00. OJtOU l] avamUSl] ron xcourcALO!lOU O£V EX£L JtQOXWQ~O£L. OLouremXOl JtOU YVWQl~OUVtl] OLaA£xtLx~ vo nvvoouv toy UALO!lO ~ cvnotooqxi [46]. YLatl (3QlOXEtm O£ '\jJUXOAOYLX~. l] LOcaALOtLX~ OLaA£XtLX~ tou XEYX£A !lEta8Etfl OA£~ tu. H LOcaALOtLX~ OLaA£xnx~ £XCPQa~H rnv aVtlAl]'\jJl] YLa tl] OUVHOl]OLaX~ xm LOtoQLX~ £SEALSl] JtOU OXl]!latl~fl l] Y£Q!laVLX~ aOtLX~ taSl]. Etoi £Sl]Y£ltrn xm 0 LO£aALOtLXO~xaQaxt~Qa~ OQLO!lEVWVoao tL~ JtQWL!l£~ OOOLaALOtLXE~ xru XO!l!lOUVLOtLXE~ 8£WQl£~. XaTa toy 'Evyx£A~. IIaQo!lOLa ue toy outomxo 000 LaALO!lO. XWQl~ v« £Sl]Y£l tl] 0XEOl] !lEtasu rcov OUO Jt£QLOXWV. JtOU O£V EXH avaJttusfl S£XWQLOt~ xm oacp~ taSLX~ OUV£lOl]Ol]. !lOQCPE~xm £S£ALXtLXE~ taO£L~ rou JtQaY!latLxOU ornv Jt£QLOX~ tou «nveuucroo. LU!l(3alvfl O!lW~. OOOLaALO!lO~S£XLvafl cero !lLa 8£WQl]tLX~ OUAAl]'\jJl]YLa !lLa tEAfla xowcovto. OJtW~ YLa JtaQaOHY!la tou Weitling. OL outomxot oomaALOtE~ O£V !lJtOQOUV v« £Sl]y~OOUV tL~ OLaOLxaOl£~ tl]~ YEVWl]~ tl]~ Hxova~ yLa rnv tEAfla XOL VWVla. H OUAAl]'\jJl] am~ !lJtOQ£l vc £lvm OAOXAl]QW!lEVl]xm OLHOOUtLX~.H ~XE~H TH~ XErKEAIANH~~IAAEKTIK~ ME TO MAP8Il:MO~YM"'nNA ME TON ENrKEAl: 65 <l>oUQU~aVtLAa!l(3aVEtm O'tL ornv «JtOALtLO!lEVl] XOLVWVla» l] a<:p80Vla y£wafl tl] cptwXHa xm OtL l] «JtOALtLO!lEVl] XOL VWvto» £S£AlOOEtm JtQO~ XataOtaOfl~ JtOU O£V £m8U!l£l xm JtOU tl]V «voioouv. l]8LX~ xrn XOLVWVLX~ £saQtl]Ol] uno tn .
i] EmOtl][lOVLX.OL VWVLX. x.avEL 0 MaQs 0 MaQS VEaVLx.OLVWVLx.m tOY XEYX.EAWVi] .Ee.atOJttQL~EL ore «avaJtOOOYllQW[lEva» rnv EsEALSl] toll x. Ex.i]e. ESWWtoQLx.Ux. OE OWOLx.m rnv x.OU YLyvw8m QLa OE coro x. uJtaQSl] OLaVOl]tLx.i] EQyaoLa OllYX.amtaALOL ESEtoll.O aJtooacpl]VL~Ovtm OUx.cpQaOO1JV 01JVOEEtm [lOQcpEe. aVtLx. ALx.OL VWVLX.EA. YLa va OOOLaAW[lOe. ue JtQOOEYYLOELe.m nov x.EAe. x.a [lEtEtQE'\jJE toto- tl]e.. 0 'Evyx.cpQax.EX.m toll OtaOLOJtOLl][lEVl] «nveuurrto. taSl]e.a8we.OLVW- H x. aOUx. ava~l]ti]OELe. us Aa[laQx.UJttH aJtooacpl]VL~EL xaO[lOU ovoueon ornv JtQawatLx.i] cno rnv LOEaAWUX.m tLe. oroJtQOX. 8EWQLEe.Lvwvtae. OllOXEtL~Ovtae. tLe. taOELe.QL[lEVO crouo.tl]QLOtLx. OE va avaJttUOOEL OOOLaAW[lO JtQOUJt08EtOllV OL avtLcpaOELe.EAe.m [lEta(3aOl] l] [lEta(3aOl] OLaAEx. nou X.i] toll tl]v we. nou 0Xl][laEQyatLx.i] ornv cno tOY otnomxo orov OU aQXL~OllV 0 x.i] OWAEX. «LOEae.Ee. 0 outomxoc [ll] EJtWtl][lOVLx.m OtL OLacpaLVOVtm o MaQs rtou OOl]YOUV JtQoe. x. OtL l] ESEALSl] tl]e.Ux. unoana oJtwe. [lOQCPi]. VLX. IIaQO[lOLa. yw to tl]e.i]e. toll 0 'Evyx.i]. ESEALSl] toll xru rnv AaJtMe.lav[urj I&oAoy{a QLX.EA JtQOOOLOQWE tn x.ou. rou YLa tl] YEVWl] x. CPLAooocpLae. x.m i] JtQOaOtLx.oe. toll ~wvtavwv nov rnv ue tLe.ou X.i]e.Oe.EA. 8EWQLEe.OLVWVLa.OXl][latW[lOe.UX.66 cp£OlloaQXLa ~EL [491. OOOLaAW[lOe. cno x.a EQya toll. mota ue rnv LOEaAWUX. [SOl.Ee. OXl][latoJtOLEL 0 XEYX.m 0 'Evyx.OU YLyvw8m llAWUX. BEx..aOLa avtWtOLXLa ESEALSl] toll amOO1JVELOl]OLae. x. EQyaoLae. roix. 0 AYrOn:TOl.». OUVOAO torv [511. x.WV rnv X.m ono».m tl]e. toll X.m to rnv toto- iotootc LOEWV x.UQLa xaQax. rnv rnv ESEALSl] nov EJtwi][laVOl] oQyaVW[lWV avtWtOLXLWV cvoueoc ern XEYX. rnv EQyaoLa OE rtou OQL~Etm X. ~tl] Tn OLaJtLOtWOl] ami] TEQf. ana avaYVWQL~01JV OU 0 XEYX. tOY JtaQa[lEQW[lO JtaQaOEXOvtm Ol]Aaoi] tl] toll otoxaO[lOU x. toll Kovt rnv ESEALSl] toll OU[lJtavtoe. MnArIONA~ rnv avtLAl]'\jJl] OtQW[lata tL~01JV oirtomxoc.OO[lOll.m JtQaY[latLx.EAe.m toll AaQ(3Lvoll yw coto [521. Ex.» x. ton 0XEOEWV. non XQl]OL[lOJtOLOUV ato[lO LO£OAOYLae.
vc XQElaOtEL va EA8El 010aVtL8£OT] ue tOY l()WALO[t6. nQaY[tanx6tT]tae. To oxi][ta tT]e. l()Eae.. Kutn toy 'EVYXEAe. l()Eae. ava[twa oro YLyvw8m tT]e. etoi« EL T vm T] [tEta~aOT] oao to «orpnQT][tEVO». avtLOtOlxLEe. «no tTl [tla [tEQla. 8EOOQT]tlxi]e.[54].H l:XEl:H THl: XErKEAIANHl: I1IAAEKTIKHl: ME TO MAPEIl:MO l:YM<!JONA ME TON ENrKEAl: 67 8HDQLa Yla to YLyv£08m tT]e. oao to «acpT]QT][tEVO»oro «OUYXEXQl[tEVO» EcpaQ[t6~H xm 0 MaQS ore Grundrisse xm OtO Keaassuo [53]. ot aVtlOtOlXLEe. 0 EVYXEAe. ouvovovrc. Etot 0 nav8E'(o[t6e. tT]e. 0 'EVYXEAe.. [tEta~aOT]e.tT]e. ESEAlST]e. autEe.xataA:r']YH OtT]V ano'\jJT] on 0 XEYXEA OUVEAa~EOAOXAT]QOO[tEva oX'r][tata tT]e. aUtEe. YLyvw8m. xm tOU nVEu[tatoe. OT]e. l()WAlt ouo. XOOQLe. to ()laAEXtlxi]e. «()lacpOQa». [tOQCP~e. EVVOlae. tou TT]V ano'\jJT] auti] nQOUno8Etouv OQLO[tEVEe.an6'\jJEle. H ESEAlST]ami] nQaY[tatonOlELtm ue ()lacpOQa 8EOOQT]tlxa oxi][tata. orov l()WALO[t6 rtou coto tn CPUOT] tELVH nQoe.. LOtoQLae. uno tT]V aAAT]. . xm to YLYVfo8m tT]e. SEAlST]e. ()EXEtm on 0 XEYXEA OUVEAa~E ne. ()LVH xanOtE tT]V EvtunOOOT]no». Oi aVtLOtOlXLEe. 6[tooe.. YnoOtT]QL~H on T] nQ60()oe. torv EJtlOtT][tWV xaVH ro l()WAlOtlxa oucrnucro vc «rroxrnoouv UAlOtlX6 nEQlEX6[tEVO. tOY onOLO taUtL~H ue tT]V L()la tn CPlAOOOCPLU. tou EVYXEAe.UALOnxou roono» OXE'\jJT]e.aVaAUOT]e. nOtEAOuV OUYXEXQlE a [tEVEe. XOOQLe. OUVEL()T]OT]e. l()EUe. ()T]Aa()r] to [tE[tOVOO[tEVOi] tT]V «trrotornro» XOOQLe. 8a nrcv ouvnro vu 8EOOQT]8EL anOtEA£O[ta tT]e... XaL tOU nVEu[tatoe. OtO «OUYXEXQl[tEVO» nou EL vut T] rcurornt« T] onotc avantuOOH tTl ()lacpOQa xm T] «oxornto» nou ()EV VOELtrn XOOQLe.. tT]V ESEAlST] tT]e. vc anOtEAEL Yl' mrrov ovnxet[tEVO SEXOOQLOti]e. tT]V ESEAlST]tT]e. EJtL()Qaooe. nQawanx6tT]tac. unOXEl[tEVlxi]e. tou onOLOU ELvm T] xataAT]ST] xm T] to acpEtT]QLa. EVVOlae. ESEAlST]e. «no tT]V aQxi] o'n 6AEe. xutcvoouvtru coto tOY XEYXEA 010 OUOXEtlOT] ue to uovionxo xaQaXti]Qu tou l()EaAlO[tOu ton [55]. 8a [tnOQOUOE vc 8EOOQT]8EL ooe.T]e. oi [tOQcpEe. 0 [tOVLOtlX6e. xm tT]e. cpUOT]e. ovcueon OtT]V ESEAlST]tT]e. to ()ULO[t6..xm tT]e.
. L()LOtT]tEe. T] VAT] tT]V onoto toy to «nveouo» [lOQCPOJtOLEL H VAT] YLa tOY XEYXEA ELvm T] a[loQ- 0 UAW[lOe. MLa JtQOXVJttH oao tT]V ()EV ELvm XWQLe. OUVELC>T]OT]e. Ano OQW[lEVEe. roono» vJtaQST]e. YLa tT]V VAT]. 0 XEYXEA UJtOOtT]QLsH OtL T] EVVOLa tT]e. we. touto EcpaQ[lOsEtm OtT]V tumxi] AOYLXi] xm tn YEW[lEtQLa. avaM- OHe. rrErrEQaO[lEVa 8a i]tav VAT] ana tTl AOYLXi] ouvacpHa ()LaAEXtLxi] UAW[lOV xm E!1JtHQW[lOV. H CPLAOOOcpLa ron XEYXEA 8a !1JtOQOVOE vo EQ[lT]VEU8EL «LC>EaAWtLxa avaJtoC>oYUQW[lEVOe. UJtOXH[lEVLxi]e. Aao tTl oxomo ()uvato vc JtQOxv1(JH to OU[lJtEQaO[la uALxa aVtLXEL[lEVa [lOQCPi]. OE OQW[lEVa XEL[lEva. t@U XEYXEA [57] ouvcvetru vJtaQST]e.68 8EWQLa ue [lUOtLXLSOUOa [lOQCPi] xm UAWtLXO xrrorsro» MIIArIONA~ rrEQLEXO[lEVO.. EVVOWe. VAT]e. tT]e.»[56]. a()LaVOT]tT] OtT] CPLAooocpLa rou XEYXEA. [loQCPi]. tTl 8EWQEL QOtOOO JtQaY[latLxotT]ta. C>EVxaQaxtT]QLsEtm aJtAWe. E!1JtHQW[lOV C>EVuJtaQXH MLa EvtUJtWOHe. xata [58]. LE 0XEOT] ue tT]V ESEALST]tT]e. VAT]e. ue toy cno ecuto LC>LotT]ta xm taUtLsEtm tou H VAT] u.' ami] tT]V evvoio avtWtOLXEL OtT]V acpT]QT][lEVT] rcutornrc nou aJtOtEAEL tT]V aQxi] rou «C>WOXEJttLXOV AOYLXOV» oJtwe. H OUOXEtLOT] tWV UAWtLXWV AEXtLxi]e. Xa[lLa sEXWQWti] OtL T] VAT] tamLsEtm us tOY otnv amoe. Evae. LC>EaAWtLxi]e. C>La[laQsW[lOV ton uno toy 'EVYXEAe. «1(Juxi]» [lJtOQEL vet xaQaXtT]QLOtEL T] CPT] rn aJtQoO()LOQWtT] x XEYXEA. Ano tTl cJJtAOaocp{a TlJ~ cJJvalJ~ rou [lLa [IT] OAOXAT]QW[lEVT] ()WAEXtLxi] xtLXi] ()W()LXaOLa teroto ()uvatotT]ta rrEQLYQacpi] tT]e. we. L1EV [lJtOQOV[lE vc 0XT][latLOOuue m08T]tT]QLaxEe. tWV ovrorv. OE Aav8aoouoa o» xm «ovcnooovuotouevn» xm 8E[lEALW[lEVT] L()EaAWtLXa. tT]e. [lOVT] JtQaY[latLxotT]ta we. nou ouo». we. [lJtOQEL va avaJttvsH XEYXEA JtQOXVJttH tT]V ESEALJtou aJtooacpT]VLsH cno tT]V aJtAl] OUOOWQEUOT] OtoLXELWV OtT] . VA T]e. UAW[lOe. VAT]e. C>EV tou OtL JtaQa aJtOtEAEL E[lrrELQLXO ()E()O[lEVO.. XEYXEAwva tQoJto tou XEYXEA xm xm [laQsWtLxa taOEWV tT]e. 8E[lEALWVEtm OtT]V ESEALST] tT]e. xa80QW[lEVEe.
. Ecp' OOOVOL()lUCPOQEt.» nou EsEtU~H l] CPlAooocpLatOU nVEVllaLOt. avacpOQEt. Ano rnv A via Oixoveveux XaL HOlxotEQa LO XECPUAaLO nou avacpE'tl]t. IlnoQd v« IlE'ta~UAEL IlE rnv EQyaoLa. naQao'tuoElt. Oi 0QyavlX OIlOL non ESE'tU~Hl] CPlAooocpLa'tl]t. nQoxvJt'tEL on XaL OL Mo 1l0QCPEt. O()l]Yovv OLO oUllnEQaolla OLLUAlOLLxi] etvoi XU8E 8EwQLa nou acpaLQd «no tnv nQaYllatlxOtl]'ta OAEt.in08E'tH rnv uno'\jJl] LOU XEYXEA OLL «VAl]» ELVaLXU8E ov nou unuQXH. OE avt(8Wl] IlE LOV nQollaQI.WCPUOLXOaL EsWWtOQlXO X O'tOLXdo. OUVUYEtaL «reo tlt. 0 llaQI. rnv nQoun08EtH l] llaQsLOLLxi] 8EwQLa. rtou OUOXO'tL~OUV nQawatlXu to xaQaxtl]QwLLXU tl]t.. «oxotnre. anOIlEVEL va EI.WtlxO. av «no rnv vnaQsi] LOU acpaLQE8d XU8E xa80QLOIlOt. av'tavuxAaon tWV 1l0QCPWV EI. ouvdOl]Ol]t.EAlSl]t.rtou OUV'tEAOVVtaLorn CPVOl] aL tnv X W'tOQLa [60]. OEVELVaLouva'to va ESl]Yl]80vv coto xnnoto qxrvrconxo.. rnv JtEQlYQUCPH MaQs ornv Ayia Oixoveveux 0 XaL onwt. CPUOlXOt.l]Yl]80vv wt. QE'taL ornv ESEAlSl] LOU nQolluQsLOtlxOV UALOIlOVXaL rtou EXH YQu'\jJEL MaQs. onwt. EI. IlE tl] 1l0QCPi] .. oAa La ELowAa 8Ql]OXEUtLXOV XaL IlUO'tlXWtlxoV xaQaxti]Qa. unEQ~aLLxo OtolXELO. eeaEt~ yw TOV c})6VfQ/lnax. Ol]Aaoi] EI. 'tl] rt:Q/laV£%J] J&oAoyia real tlt. H EVVOLa'tl]t..'tl]t. avaYVWQL~ELou 0 uv8Qwnot... omo.WLLXOt. XaL rnv 'tEXVlXi].. 1l0QCPEt. [59]. tou Keipasaiou oru. UAlOIl6t. XaL OAOUt..lOtlXOV UALOIlOV.. rnv aVaA1JH IlE aXQL~ELa 0 'EVYXEAt. 0 LOU nQollaQl.. CPVOl]t. Ill]XavEt.nQOEtOLIlU~01JV'tlt. VAl]t. !lJtoQd vo anoo08EL l] uno'\jJl] ou UALOtlxi] d Val XU8E 8EwQLa rtou OEXEtaLOLL0 nQaYllaLLxOt.. roue cpQaYIlOVt.l]Yl]8d XWQLt.. tLt. XaL LOLOQlXOt. nQo'i.avacpoQu OE xunOLo uJtEQ~atLxo.. ami] nou nQoExu'\jJE coto 'tl] lll]xaVLOtlxi] CPUOLXi]rou N'tEXUQt xal ami] nou nQoExu'\jJE cao rnv aL08l]OlaQXLa tou Aox.EAlSl]t. xoouoc.IlnoQd va EI. 'Etot orov MaQI. XaL EllnooL~ouv rn YVWOl] tl]t.H l:XEl:H THl: XErKEAIANHl: I1IAAEKTIKHl: ME TO MAP3Il:MO l:YM'N1NA ME TON ENrKEAl: 69 Ill]Xavlxi] CPVOl] aL cno ami] ornv OQyavlxi] cpVOl]. TEAOt. onwt.....
tOQCPft.aOLEt.v:JttEL OtL n VA'f] unooet vc OUOXEtWtEL ue t« qxuvouevc yw tu oaotc OX'f][tatLSOU[tE aW8'f]t'f]QLax. ton 'EVyX.1[aAfJ.~t.m tou AQLOtotfA'f].EA t'f]t. E OAEt.ov.LvWvtat. 0 'EVyX.m OL 0XEOELt.ft.auaj «EAS'f]» 'EVYX. CPLAOOO[ cpLat.EL tn [63l.WV V OX'f][tatLO[twv x..~6LaAEx. nQoona8EL rnv iorootc OUYX. Lt'f] .O X'f][taLLO nou toy :JtEQL~UAAEL l.aOLEt.EX.aL on t'f]t.rtou ELvm X.JtaQat'f]QEL OtL 0 XEYX.onwt.Et.a8oQLsovtm OL L6LOt'f]tEt.t'f]QLOtLSEx..OLVWVLX. 'f] UALOtLX. X. ELvm OL avacpOQft.tLx.OL WVLX. ()LaAEx. [61 vc cnooorpnvtoa LLt.LVUEL no mo8'f]t'f]« QWX. EL vru nootov [taLLx. Kru YLa tOY 'EVyX. orn rnv XEyx. ue [tLa imocrcotoncmuevn 8EL Wt. rtou ouvfAa~E «LLt.OLVEt. evvou«.E'\jJ'f]t.EAt.EAOWOtu ouveoeoe rnv VA'f] ue xru rnv «unWO'f]» x.Ot'f]tat. nQovn08fOELt. LE 0XfO'f] ue rnv iotootc t'f]t. M[]ArIONA~ o 'EVyX.» x.m UAW[tOV rtou X. ME aut~v x.tLx.WVx. nou nQovn08EtEL 'f] x.QatLX.EAOLL 'f] VA'f] ELvm x. nov nQoOWx.x. Axoun x. nQayO rrou ESEALOOEtm WtOQLX. 8EWQLEt.». t'f]t.EAt. UAWtLX.70 non aUL~ naLQVEL OE fva ouo.u [tLat. SEX. EVtUnWOELt. t'f]t.. onoto 8EWQEL orov Anti-DUhring Wt. 6'f]Aa6~ 'f] OUOXEtLO~ t'f]t.~.~t. nou nQovno8ftH tOY rnv nQoEtoL[taoLa t'f]t. torv X.m [tETa~UAAEtm 6La6Lx. ES~y'f]O'f]t.EAt. tOY «XfYX.n[ t'f]t.AOVV ovuqxruxe. evvou«.tLt. rn M[1{Qrj AOY[1{rj nQox. 'f] fVVOLa t'f]t. X.m t'f]t. EVtUnWOELt. tnv nQay[taLLx. VA'f]t..EAt. VA'f]t.~ 6LaAEx.VQLEt. tOU nQay[tanx.ft.t'f]t. [tOQCPft. [64l. aVas'f]tEL VA'f]t.U x.unOLo tQono a:JtOSEVW[tfV'f]L6fa 8a unooouoe.ft. us 6w6Lx...O «:JtEQL~A'f][ta» t'f]t. x. rho aVaAULLx. VA'f]t. OL oaote.UVEL XEYX.Ot'f]ta AYrOn:TOl.t'f]t. CPva'YJ~ 0 aQxmot'f]tat. OVtoAOYLX.ft. [tEoa cno acpaLQW'f]t. UAWtLX. av cqxuQE8ELto L6EaALOtLx.LV'f]O'f]t.m rnv totoQLa nov E:JtLOt'f][tWV 62l. Arro 6uvatot'f]Ta t'f]t. [tEta~OA~t.atu x.EAt. rnv onoto OX'f][tatLsEtm 'f] evvoic t'f]t. OE CPLAOOOCPL- X..~.m 'f] <i:rto'\jJ'f]ton XEYX. tWV ano'\jJEwv tou MaQs YLa coto rc xaQax. .QL[tfVO X. avayvwQL1. OX. [toCPQ~otoxao[tov.EALav~ fVVOLa t'f]t. VA'f]t.EAorn 0 nooeroiucotc t'f]t. H acpaLQW'f] cno aVtaVax. vo 8EWQ'f]- OUOXftLO'f] E[tnELQLO[tov x.
nQaWa'tLXO'tl']'tae. yw naQU()H Wa rnv nEQLoxi] tWV j3LOAOYLXWV oQyaVW[!WV.[66]. unotEAEL 'tl']v OVLOAOYLXi]xru AOYLXi] nQotino8wl'] 'tl']e. ()l']Aa()i] aVE~UQtl']ta «no LO UALXOunoOtQW[!U LOUe.. EmO'ti][!Ee.XEJ. £QEUVae. ME TO MAP8IJ. xm [!EtacpUmxi]e.ogW[!OVe. 2:tl']V xQLtLxi] nou 0 X£YXEA aoxEL YLa 'tl'] [!£'tacpumxi] nQw cno LOV Knvt unOOtl']QL~EL OtL l'] [!EtacpuOLxi] nQoxvJttEL coto rnv EcpaQ[!oyi] nov 0Xl'][!utwv LOU «()LaOXEJttLxOV AOYLXOV»..nou YLVEtm uno 'tLe. [WQqJ£e.xm rnv avuJttu1. XErKEAIANHJ. H uno\jJl'] auti] YLa LO uercqnxnxo toone ox£\jJl']e.i] LOUe. EVLUnWOELe. evvoie.avanaguvovrru [!E 'tl'] [!OQqJi] ELXOVWV.avuAoyoue. w. xm 'tWV [!a8l'] [!atLXWV. OX£\jJl']e.YM<!JONA ME TON ENrKEAJ.LO onOLO EXCPQU~Etm[!E OQLO[!OVe.naQaOLUOEWV xm EWmWV.'tl']e. 7I aVaJtaQaywyf]e. aw8r]1. tc onoto naQoumu~ouv ovuqxruxo xru E~EAW- . tl']e. ECP'OOOV uerocpumXOe. OVO[!aOtEL 0 roono. Ano LOV X£YXEA. ornv uno\jJl'] rou AQWLOt£Al'] yw rnv «nQw'tl'] qJLAooocpLa» rtou E~EtU~EL ro «EL()l']». ()l']Aa()i] 'tLe. OE aVtLX£L[!EVa tou «Aovou».nQay[!atLXo'tl']tae.nQay[!atLXo'tl']'tae.EtU~ELto xa8£va coro tn avtLxEL[!EVU LOU aVE~UQtl']'ta «no tn [!E'taj3oAij rou xm tl'] 0X£Ol'] LOU [!E rc UAAa aV'tLxEL[!EVa [65l.. ME 'tl'] ()l'][!LougYLa YAWOOLXWVxm UAAWV OU[!j30AWV nou YEWLOVV'tm coto rnv av8Qwm vn nQaX'tLxi] xm naQaYWYLxi] EQyaoLa. AOYLxi]e. VAl']e. aU't£e.!OQcp£e. ()LaAEXtLXi]e. VO[!OUe. anO'tEAEL rnv OVLOAOYLXi]xm AOYLXi] nQotino8wl'] 'tl']e. [!E LOUe.£e.MO J. tumxi]e. ()EV YEwi]8l']XE [!E rnv L()EaAW'tLxi] xm rnv UAWtLXi] ()LaAEXtLxi]. VAl']e.. l'] evvoio tl']e. ELvm l'] svvot« 'tl']e. nou aVtLOLOLXOVV OLOUe. qJumxi]e. rnv nQo£AEuoi] tl']e.. [!ogcp£e. ot aW8l']'tl']QLaX£e. «~ aXLVl']'ta xm XWQw'tU».. 2:'tl']V mo YEVLXi] [!ogcpi] 'tl']e. H nLO YEVLXi] cero ru.nou E1. 2:'tLe. H()LX£e. LOU «YLyv£08m» 'tl']e.'tl']e. xm OUVEL()l']maxi]e.. E~EAWOO[!EVl']e... YLVEtm coro()EX'ti] l'] avtLeWl'] ()LaAEXtLXi]e. LOV MaQ~ xm LOV 'EVYXEAe. VAl']e. l'] evvoio 'tl']e.H THJ.. LllAAEKTIKHJ. nou av'tw'tmxovv [ OE [!W [!OVO nEQLOxi] LOU «YLyvw8m» 'tl']e.. W'tOQLXOXmvwvLXi]e. UAWtLXi]e.H J. mo EL()LX£e. MnoQEL v« ava~l']ti]o£L xavELe.
Of aVt(8Wl] ue tl] 6LaAfxtLxi]. JtQoxuJttu avaAoYla ava[Lwa orn OXEOl]tou 6LaAfXtLXOU xm tOU [Lftacpumxou roono» OXE'\jJl]e. ~ta JtQWL[LaEQya tou. CPLAOOOcplae.tl] «6LacpoQa» xm rnv avtlcpaOl] nou «vcnroooouv. H aJto'\jJl] tou AaL[LJtVLte. uno rnv fcpaQ[Loyi] 0' auto «acpl]Ql][LEVWV Xatl]YOQLWV».rnv f~EAL~i] toix xm rnv aAAl]AOf~aQtl]oi] roix.tl] «ustacpuOLxi]» JtQOOEYYWi] ou [69]. nou avacpEQftm orov JtQo[LaQ~WtLXO UAW[LO. xm JtoAA6tl]tae. tl] ouvorpao «aX[Li]e.ornv iorooto. 8EOl]e. 0 MaQ~ oxoALa~u m [Lftacpumxi] tOU 6ExatoU E~60[LoU ouovo. aJto tn [LLa [LfQLa. 6LaAfr xtLxi]e. ue rnv acpalxm QWl] JtQoxuJttu OtL l] 6LaAfxtLxi] JtQOOEYYWl]ou JtQawanxou r flvm JtAl]mEOtfQl] JtQoe. 0XL «[Lftacpumxa».rnv a[LWl] avtlAl]'\jJi] ton ue tLe.. H avtl8wl] JtQoxaVtLavi]e.Itc vo fQ[Ll]VfU8fl to xoxo 6LaAfXtLXa. ue to OUYXfXQL[LEVO tl]e. we. [LftacpuOLxi]e. Of OXEOl] ue to «Aoyo». tl]e. Aao rnv XQLtLxi] ami] rou XEYXfA YLa rnv JtQoxaVtLavi] [LftacpuOLxi] JtQOXUJttH OtL 6fV f~fta~H to aVtLXfL[LfVa tl]e. . EJtlOl]e. xm 6LaAfxtLxi]e. xata tOY XEYXfA. JtfQL060ue.xm aQVl]Ol]e. JIaQac56aH~ tPtAoaocpia~ tl]e. WtoQlae.rnv fLxav JtQaY[LatoJtOLi]oH OLaQxalOL [70]. Ayia~ Oixoveveuu. YlVftm 6fXti] xm orto tOY MaQ~.. MLa reroi« OUOXEtWl]8a cpaVEQWVfl] ouvacpua fVOt tl]tae. H 6LaAfXtLxi] xm LOtoQLXi]8fWQl]0l] tOU xaxou ovn t(8ftm JtQoe. m08i]oue. tl] 0XEOl] tOU «A6you» xru rou «6LaOXfJttLXoU AOYLXOU» crto rnv aAAl]. IIaQO[LOLa aJto'\jJl] cpalVftm va fXCPQa~H0 XEYXfA YLa tl] 6LaAfxnxi] one. nou f[LcpaVl~ftm.. OU[Lcpwva ue toy XEYXfA. Of 0XEOl] ue to «6LaOXfJttLXO AOYLXO». xaxou xru A6you. we. H JtQoxavtwvi] [Lftacpumxi] EQXftm. nou WOtOOOovuOtoLXfl Of Evav roono OXE'\jJl]e.». JtQoe. yw JtaQ<i6uwa oro xHpaAmo tl]e.» xm «JtaQax[Li]e... OJtwe. Ano tn OUOXEtLOl]tl]e. tl]e. JtQoe.flvm avaYXl] va OUOXftWtfl [Lf to WtOQLXO YlYVf08m [68]. Iotooiai. xm Of aAAfe. yw to «uercqnxnxo xoxo» Jtl]ya~H. [LftacpuOLxi]e.72 xrrorsros MlIArIONAL OO[LfVOxaQmmlQa [67]. xata tOY XEYXfA.
H l:XEl:H THl: XErKEAIANHl: JllAAEKTIKHl: ME TO MAPSIl:MO l:YM<!JONA ME TON ENrKEAl: 73 8EWgEL W~ XUglO YVWgLO[lU TY]~OLL EsEtUSEL[lOVO tn ngo~Ai][lata vovmc auti] rou otoXaO[lOU xm to «ouguvLa» to ~T]ti][lata. nAi]gT] gi]sT] tou Mags T] OUOXEtLOT] ero toy c OT][laLVELOtL agvLEtm xi]~ xm Mags OLaAEXtLXi]~. ESEALXtT]XE ngLv coto toy oLaAExnxo OXE'lI'T]~. o Colletti. xm to n~ avacpogE~ Ito tOY EYXEA~ uero- CPUOLXO xagaxti]ga EXEL 0 tgono~ OXE'lI'T]~ rtou 8EWgEL ru nguY[lata w~ Ota8Egu. (JXE'lI'T]~ xataAi]YEL (JEEvav tgonou (JXE'lI'T]~ ELvm T] ESWAOYLXO ayvw(JtLXLO[lO.nou ngoExu'll'E Knvt. MLa UnT] [logcpi] rou uercqnxnxou . w vo cnoocrpnvtca y OtT]V avtLOLaOtoAi] auti] coto toy Mags. ovcueo« oro uernqnxnxo tgono cno tTl CPLAooocpLaono». o uercqnxnxo toono "EvyxEA~ xgT]OL[lOnOLEL tTl XEYXEALaVi] avnoLaOtoAi] OXE'lI'T]~. LOEaALO[lOUxm [lEtacpuOLxi]~ OEV rn XEyxEALavi] avnoLaOtoAi] ~tT]V A8At6rrrra usrcqnxnroo- rTJ~<l>tAoaocpia~ 0 rou uernqnxnxou OLEUXgLVLsEL xagaxtT]gLOtLxO OtL rtou OXE'lI'T]~ dvm «OtoALoLa» [73l. vnt ouvixpcouevo. d OtL 8EWgd tL~ AOYLXE~ xatT]yogLE~ w~ tmrnxm rc «yi]LVa nguY[lata» w~ anAu sO[lEVE~ ue rnv «ouoto» Ano rnv unO'll'T] ami] ue to xm [lOVO 0 LOEaALO[lO~ roono OXE'lI'T]~. ELoLxotEga. toy Mags ornv Ayia H OUOXEtLOT] LOEaALO[lOU xm [lEtacpuOLxi]~ nou YL vetru coto Oixoveveux Mags OEV on [laLVEL. 0 [lEtacpu(JLxo~ tgono~ gLXO YLyvw8m auto [lEtacpu(JLxoU tgonou OXE'lI'T]~~AEnEL oro CPU(JLXO xru to totoOXE'lI'T]~EL vru on ue auto taUtL~EL au8aLgEta nou OE 8a [lU80WE aSEJtEgaOtE~ avtL8EOEL~ [75l. ono». H xgLtLxi] OOT]yd O[lW~ toy MagS oro OU[lJtEgaO[la nw~ to YEYOVO~ naga[lEgLOE to L1LacpWtLO[lOxm EJtLXgUtT]OT]T]~ t OtL 0 LOEaALO[lO~ngoowgLvu tL~ UALOLLXE~ tUOEL~ rou OT][laLVELngoowgLvi] [lEtacpuOLxi]~ [72l. a[lEtU~AT]ta xm anO[lOVW[lEVa [74l. anO[lOVW- cno LL~ EJtLYELE~ ngaY[latLXOtT]tE~ [711. ~UVEnELa tOU nou OEV YVWgL~OWE twga 'EtOL 0 [lEtacpuOLxo~ roono. VO[lL~EL [lE tOY XEYXEA. note.
ftWJtL~01J!J.74 aJtOA. t01J fQyatLXOU ue tT]V XOLVWVLXi) LOtoQLa xm tT]V WtOQLa avuJtt1J~T] Acp' T]£ OtLy~i)£ 6~w£.f OUVtO!J.£ acpmQfL «no rnv avtL8WT] LOWA. OLx6 xaQaxti)Qa. OXE0 !J. Jt.OL rou «OLaOXfJttLXOU aJtaQaLtT]ta OtUOLa tT]£ VOT]tLxi)£ stvru !J. TfA.6Y01J» dvm aJtoxa8LOtU tOY 1JA. OXE'\jJT]£ avtLtL8ftm oro «OLaOXfJttLx6 OLaA.LXOU xm JtOLXLA.fX8d EQf1JVa. tT] (3La~T]xavLxi) enovc- oruon xm rn YEVWT] fJtLOtT]!J.f !J. us to ovuxetuev« Jt01J aVtLxatOJttQL~01JV YLa toy oute tT] 0XEOT] [80l.fQLvi) JtQaXtLxi) aMvatT] [781.LXU. LOL6tT]tf£ on xm EX01JV !J.wa tT] XfYXfA.£ JtLOtfUfL 6tL 0 ueroOXE'\jJT]£dvm avayxaLo£ xm XUJtOtf fJtaQxi)£ xm vo OXfcptOU!J.Utwv.X. rorv OXE'\jJT]£dvm 'EVYXfA.EtQO Jt01J Of V f~ftU~fL tT] YEVWT] tWV coto tL£ OJtOLf£ f~T]yd tn YVWOT]. 0 ~ftacp1JOLX6£ roono. ue tT]V XLVi)~atO£.fXtLxi).f- ouo 01Jv8T]XWV Jt01J 01JVOEOvtm fJtWtT]!J. aJt6'\jJfL£ Jt01J aVacpEQJtQO£ to JtQO£ to A. EtOL xm 0 "EVYXfA. xa8w£ T] aJtOA. «Jt1JQi)va» tT]£. xatu fVt1JJtWOfWV to uerorpuYLa toy To LOLa 8a ntov o1Jvat6 !J.£ aJtOtEA.OVLxi) XWQO JtfQLOQW~EVWV OLaOtUOfWV EXfL JtQOOWQLVU va A.WVJtaQatT]Qi)ofwv.ftacp1JOLX6£ tQ6Jto£ (3aLWV01JV on YfVVLEtm T] 1JA. H cp1JOLx6£ tQ6Jto£ YLa mv Xa8T]!J. avayvWQL~fL A.Wv. . T] Xa8T]!J.ftacp1JOLXU XQOVLXE£ JtfQL6001J£ [791.atLO~EVO fmOtT]!J.JtfLQW!J. f!J. TfLVOWf oruv avn!J. OJtW£ avtL8wT] 0 'EVYXfA.a» xm 0 XEYXfA.mOJtoLT]OT] tT]£ avtL8wT]£ XaL «Of1JtfQfU01JOf£» AYrOUTm: MTIArJONAl: ovcueoo toiv OtL£ «JtQWtfU01JOf£» JtQaY!J.f1J8fQLa [771.1JQWOLU [761.6.f£ xataXfQ!J.mOJtOLT]OT] tT]£ avtL8WT]£ xm rnv fA. Q£ JtQO£ 6A. rou.Lavi) xm to «A6yo».L~T]£ xm 6tL XWQL£ «utou.a£ f~EA.fxtLx6 roono OXE'\jJT]£ ue a~LaOT]!J.T]!J.oyi)£ 1JA.oYLx6» ami) 8T]xav.fQLvi) ~wi). 600 (3QLOXftm OtO OtUOLO tT]£ 01JA.LOtLX6 tT]£ «JtfQL(3A.A.a i) !J.wnx6 6tL OL JtQOOOLOQW!J.fLWtT] avtLOtOLXLa avu!J.WV Jt01J JtQOUJt08Eto1JV xm fm(3f0 cp1JOLx6£ x60~0£ EXfL corooixo xaQaxti)Qa.f£ 0 !J.ftacp1JOLX6£ tQ6Jto£ ovoueo« ornv avayxm6tT]ta tu.LOtLXi) o LaA.EYf80£ XaL 6tL EX01JV XQw!J.
JtQOUJt08£OHt. YLUtL xm JtQuY[lutLx6t'l']tu 6tL orov tLt. t'l']t. OLUXQLO'I']UVU[lWU OLUAEXtLx6 UALO[l6 8u [lJtOQOUOE VU ELvm 'I'] E'!. UVtLCPUOHt.. JtLO JtoM YV())OLOAOYLUt. t'l']t. UALO[l6t. UVUAOY'I']t. Su nrov 'I']uJto'\jJ'I'] tou owut6 t'l']t. JtQOt.JtULQVH tn [lOQCfJrl [lLUt. OX£O'l']t. UVUAUOELt. vc OEX8EL XUVELt. YLU tnv JtOU XUQUXt'l']QL~EL YLU tnv QWALOtLXU OtOLXELU t'l']t. trrv UJtO'\jJ'I']ton 6tL 0 X£YXEA 01JVEXL~ELrnv JtAUt())VLXi] xru XQLOtLUVLXi] JtuQu000'1']. Av to 01J[lJt£QUO[lU onto MUQ'!. Uut£t. OU X£YXEA JtOU OEV EJtLXQUtEL orov t JtAUt())VLO[l6 xm tOY XQLOtLUVLO[l6. £VVOLUt.. UALOtLXi] OLUAEXtLxi] ovcceoovrci LOLUVO'l']tLXi] OLUOLXUOLU())t. JtQUY[lutLx6t'l']tut.. 0 OLUAEXtLx6t. OLUCPOQEt. 8E[lEALWVELt600 [lLU 8E())QLU YLU rnv tOY LOtOQLX6 UALO[l6. EQYUOLU. ELvm EJtLOti][l'l'] [821.· 'l']UALOtLxi] OLUAEXtLXi] UVucp£QEtm xm [lE8000AOyLUt. UALOtLxi] OLUAEXtLxi] xm OE ~'I']ti][lUtU rcov LOL())V[lOQCPWV t'l']t. YLU tLt. AAtouo£Q LOtOQLX6t. LOEUALOtLXi]t. UALO[l6t. 8E())QLUt. CPUO'l']t. UALOtLXi]t. YLUtL tELVEL x60[l0 v« tUutLOH rnv JtQuY[lutLx6t'l']tu t'l']t. UVUJtUQuy())yi] owuti] JtOU JtQO'l']yi]8'1']xUV ouvcvovrca OQLO[l£VU xm ornv ornv to OLUAEXtLx6 UALO[l6. JtUQUOLtLxi]t. Qot600 OE 8u £JtQEJtE VU JtUQU~A£'\jJOU[lE to [lOVLOtLx6 OtOLXELO t'l']t. ELvm Au8E[l£V'I']. UVUMOHt. YLU to JtQuY[lUtLx6.xm AOYLX£t.i]t. to xm to m08'1']tou xoouou ~u8[l6 EXAOYLXEUO'l']t. OtLxi] OLUAEXtLXi] 600 Mo JtQouJt08£to1JV xm OLUAEXtLXi]t. uovo Colletti ue toy A.tOU X£YXEA xm rcov QO[lUVtLXWV. 0 OLUAExtLX6t. CPLAOOOCPLUt.£AtyXto AJt6 tLt.. LO£Ut. xm tou JtVEU[lUtOt. XUQuxt'l']QLOtLX6 JtuQUOLtLxi] tOU [lEtUCPUOLXOU tQ6Jtou ELvm 'I'] tUO'l'] rou oro JtQuY[lUtLx6 OX£'\jJ'I']t. [lEtu~OAi]t. ton YLU JtUQUOELY[lU tLt. LOWtoU t'l'] CPLAOOOCPLU rou. OL MLu to ())t. ovroxm O'UV£JtELEt. OU[lJtEQUO[latu ue rnv £VVOLEt.[loQCP£t.OLUAExtLXi]t. XEYXEALUVi]t.H ~XE~H TH~ XErKEAIANH~LllAAEKTIKH~ME TO MAP8I~MO~rM<I>ONA TON ENrKEA~ ME 75 '\jJ'I']t.. ELvm orooto. XU80QL~H tLt.t'l']t. [831. at 'I'] V to [811. [loQCPi] rou vc UJtOXU8LOtU qxrvrorruxo xm to UVE'!. rnv UALOL xm 0 AOYLX£t. tou «XOLV())VLU trov LOL())tWV». us t'l'] CPLAOOOCPLU t'l']t. Em~L())O'l']t. UALO[l6t. . t'l'] 0X£O'l'] t'l']t.
AYron:Tm:
MilArIONAE
non
xaQaXt'l']Ql~OllV
tnv
WtOQLXi] E~fAL~'I'], YLa
rnv
UA'I'] nou
rtJtOQEl vo avaJttu~EL xm
JtOLOtLXft; rtEta~OAft;
[841. Iluoouour
OtOLXEla 6EV fX01JV L6LaltEQ'I'] onouociorntc XQLOtLaVLxi] JtaQu600'l'].
otnv
JtAatQ)vLxi]
'Ioox;
0 Colletti
vo llmQtOvl~EL
rnv avt(8w'I'] toll XfYXEA JtQOt; tOY llAWrt0 [851 xm 0 XfYXEA v« fQXEtm xatu XUQLOA6yo OE avtl8w'I'] ue tnv aVtlA'I']'\jJ'I']YLa rnv UA'I'] JtO'\) JtQO'i.iJt08ftEL rtLa XOOrtOAOYla toll El60llt; non
xaAALEQYEl 0 NEutWvat;. toll Colletti XfYXEA, OJtw06i]JtOtE, aJto tLt; JtaQat'l']Qi]OELt; L6wAL0rt0U 6EV o1JVuYEtm OtL rtLa EQrt'l']vda toll
ouuqxov« ue rnv onoto JtQOEtOLrtU~Etm cero t'l'] <jlLAOOO<jlla tou rtW llAWtLXi] 8EwQla YLa to JtQaYrtatLXo, dvm aMvat'l']. Mio teroto EQrt'l']vda, non JtQO'i.iJt08fto1JV OL avaAUOELt; ton MaQ1; xm nou aJtOOa<jl'l']Vl~01JV 'EVYXEAt;, 0 AfVLV 0 xm Wt; iv« ~a8rto 0 nAEXUVW<jl, 6EV ~EXLVUEL ccro rnv uJto'\jJ'I']
OtL 0 XfYXEA Elvm «rtWO'i.iAWti]t;» i] OtL XUVEL «JtaQaxwQi]OELt;»orov llALOrtO, oJtWt; llJtOOt'l']Ql~EL0 Colletti
rou
[861. BEXLVUEL
tLt; YEVL-
«no rnv UJtO'\jJ'I'], tOll 6LatllJt(OVEL 0 MaQ~ J onuqxovo ue tnv onoto 0 XfYXEA JtQcinot;
xft; rt0Q<jlft; t'l']t; 6LaAEXtLxi]t;
oro KEcpaAUW [871, avuJttll~E
ue
OAOXA'I']QWrtfVO xm OtOxaOtLXo
toone. Aao rnv
61JVato
uJto'\jJ'I']ami]
JtQoxuJttEL OtL OL «YEVLXft;
uoo-
<jlft;» t'l']t; 6LaAExtLxi]t;,
oJtWt; tLt; xa80QwE
o XfYXEA,
t'l']t;
Elvm
v«
XQ'I']OLrtOJtOL'I']80uvoto c
rnv
llAWtLXi] 6LaAEXtLxi] xm
to 6LaAEXtLXO llAW~.
E~UAAOll 'I'] rtf8060t;
«cotoxntnctc-
on;» nou
XQ'I']OLrtOJtOLOUV MaQ~ xru 0 'EVYXEAt; YLa v« ~EXW0 XfYXEA aJtOtEAEl oxi]rta
QlOOllV tOY OQ80AOYLXO«JtllQi]va» cero to «rtllOtLXWtLXO JtEQl~A'I']rta» t'l']t; 6LaAEXtLxi]t; toll coto tou
non
0
l6LOt; 0 XfYXEA ElXE XQ'I']OLrtOJtOLi]OEL YLa
v«
«aJtoxataoti]oEL»
rnv L6wAWtLXi] xoouou
OXOJtLUtoll
t'l'] 0XfO'l'] mo8'1']tou xm VO'l']EJtlO'l']t; to EJtL-
Arro tLt; aVaAUOELt; non JtQo'l']yi]8'1']xav OllvuYEtm
OtL Elvm Aa8El!fV'I'] 'I'] avtLJtaQa8w'I'], oxoALaOtft;, avurtwa
nou
JtQOtElV01JV JtOAAOl
orov MaQ~ xm toy 'EVYXEAt;,
ue
H J;XEJ;H THJ; XErKEAIANHJ;
IIIAAEKTIKHJ;
ME TO MAP8IJ;MO J;YMct>llNA ME TON ENrKEAJ;
77
XelQTnW o'n 0 OE1JtEQOe; XatEAT]~E oro «uetnqnxnxo llAW~6» [881, ErcELOi]rrrov amOOlOaxtOe; OtT] CPLAOOOcpla[891, ott OEV 01JVEAa~Exata tQ6Jto OAOXAT]QW~EVO rnv EVVOLa tT]e; JtQa~T]e;, YLatl rnv taut WE ~E tTl mWtT]~OvLxi] EQE1JVa, n T] CPLAooocpla o yw tOY 'EVYXEAe; EtELVE rcEQwo6tEQO JtQoe; tT]V OVtOAOYla JtaQa JtQoe; tn 8EwQla tT]e;JtQa~T]e;[901. OL aJt61jJELe;amEe; Elvm E~mQEnxa ~OV6JtAEllQEe; xm 6XL maQXwe; tEX~T]QLW~EVEe;.'OJtwe; JtQoxuJttEL «no tLe; EQE1JVEe; JtOAAWV ~EAEtT]tWV, Jt.X. ton A. Cornu, 0 MaQ~ xm 0 'EVYXEAe; OLaJtWtwVo1JV coto to 1844 tTl ouuqxovto roix OE6Aa to ~T]ti]uorc. To Keqxisaio 8E~EALWVEtm OE EQE'UVEe; 'EYXEAe; , LOLtoll altEQa YLa rnv Kauiouum rwv EQyai;oflEvwV TaSfWV ornv AyyAla. H 0XEOT]ava~wa ore Mo amu EQya OEV Elvm uovo 0XEOT]8EwQlae; xm OEOO~EVWVnou tT]V tEX~T]QLWV01JV.eE~EALWvEtm OtT]V «JtAT]Q6tT]ta tT]e; avtlAT]1jJT]e;rou 'EVYXEAe;YLa tTl CPUOT] rou XaJtLtaALOtLxoU toortou JtaQaywyi]e;», ou~cpwva ~E tOY MaQ~ [911. E~anOll T] evvoio tT]e; JtQa~T]e; orov MaQ~ JtEQLAa~aVEL, ono»; xm orov 'EVYXEAe;, rnv JtQaxnxi] tT]e; EJtLOtT]~OVLxi]e; EQE1JVae; xm rorv tEXVOAOYLXWV EcpaQ~OYwv tT]e;. ElVaL AOLJt6v OLXaLOAOYT]~EVT] T] aJto'ljJT] 6n La EQya rou 'EVYXEAe; aJtOtEAOUV JtOAUn~T] JtT]yi] YLa rnv xorovonon tT]e; OXEOT]e; ava~wa orov XEYXEA xm to ~aQ~w~6.
AYrOYErOE
MllArIONAE
2:HMEIQ2:EI2: 1. 11, 81 XaL JtQoa8i!xE~, BA. Hegel's Logic, trans!. by W. Wallace. Oxford. oo. 15-16 XaL 115-119. 2. Hegel's Logic, a. 116 xm L. Colletti, Marxism and Hegel, London, 1973.
a.
14 xm 22.
3. MtxQr} Aoytxr} § 28, 80 xm JtQoa8iJxE~, Hegel's Logic, a. 113-115. 4. MtxQr} Aoytxr} § 81 xm JtQoa8i!xE~, Hegel's Logic, a. 115-119. 5. H 6.JtO'IjJT] mi! yw tTl C'JLUAomxi! AOYLXi! u JtQoUJto8£tEL 6n aX£'ljJT] JtOtEAEL U «mrrorrvcmuooouevn 19, Hegel's Logic, a. 25. 6. E. V. Ilyenkov, Dialectical Logic, Moscow, 1977. a. 175 X.E. 7. E. V, Ilyenkov, 6.Jt. JtuQ., a. 169 8. Marx-Engels, Etudes Philosophiques, Paris, 1964, a. 211. London 1951, a. 873. J. T] OAOtT]ta». MtxQr} Aoytxr}
9. K. Marx, The Capital, aELQ6.Everyman, D. Bernal, Marx and Science, 1952, a. 17. 10. Anti-DUhring,
ust. E. Bums, London, 1934, a. 142. 1953,
11. Fr. Engels, Dialectic of Nature, tr. Clemens Dutt, Moscow,
a. 37,
259-262.
12. Dialectic of Nature, a. 295-299. 13. O.Jt. JtuQ. a. 292-294. 14. O.Jt JtuQ. a. 288-292. 15 Ludwig Feuerbach and the Outcome of German Classical Philosophy, London, 1934, a. 55, Dialectic of Nature, oo. 288-290.
16. Dialectic of Nature, a. 83. 17. Anti-DUhring, tr. E Bums, London, 1934, a. 69. a. 140.
18. Dialectic of Nature, a. 83, JtQBA,Anti-Duhring, 19. Dialectic of Nature, a. 296.
39-40. Marx. Cornu. Marx. 34. o. Engels. oro 35. Marx and Science.137-138. 13601][1. 0. o. Engels. XWQo.95-96 28. Cornu. Fr. 3. o. Engels.283. 30. IIQ~A. TT/r. 59-61. t.271-273. o. 5. 6. 27.H EXEEH THE XEfKEAIANHE IIIAAEKTIKHE ME TO MAP3IEMO SYM'NlNA ME TON ENfKEAE 79 00. 1. 119.t. Dialectic of Nature. 13. t. A. on 1]CPU01] vrn EXCPQU01] LClEUt. A. 135-136.:rrUQ. Cornu. o. 3. 250. Karl Marx. :JtL[1EQout. Paris 19551962. Leur oeuvre. £L t1]t. 32. Marxism and Hegel. Engels. t. 2. 3. £ a:rr6'IjJ£Lt. 5. Engels. 31.yLa :rrUQab£LY[1U u:rrO'\)!1] t1]V tWV IIaQar'56(JEwv Q)LAO(JOcpiar. t. Leur oeuvre. :rruQ. L. Vocabulaire du Marxisme. Engels.X. 140. o. Paris. rr. 26. 29. o. Cornu. Oxford.MLX(n]A.45-46.292. Keqxisaio r. 6.t. :rrQ~A. t. o. 0.l o. o. 1978. K. Bernal. Anti-DUhring. 20. IIEQU cero t1] Y£VLXi) vucpoQu OlOV LCl£aALa[16OU XEYX£A:rrou u l [1£tU~UAA£L :rrQuY[1unx6 oe qxrvrcouxo xm to ocvrconxo ce to :rrQuY[1unx6. K. 1981. London. Leur vie. £XCl.24. LondonMoscow. n. A. 0 MUQ~ u:rrmvLoonm LOWt. 6. t. o. 22. Collected Works. Leur vie. :rr. rrrou J. The Logic of Marx. Cornu. 3. rou XEYX£A. Jindrich Zeleny. 250. Engels. 1.t.Iotooiai. K. D. r. Collected Works. German Ideology. Q)LAo(Jocpiar. 17. Fr. Fr.297-299.. Paris 195662. rov L1Lxaiov XEYXEA. Marx. 21. I rov 33.. K. 65-66 A. Colletti. 89.Fr. Ai)[1flU Dialectique. 23. 25. :rruQ. o. Marx. Ewaywy1j (JTT/V KQL ux1j TT/I. 18.0YLX1j 9. Fr. A. 1980. Cornu. Gerard Beckerman. . :rr. A8i)vu.41. 1 59.. Cornu. 142. c. 205-206. Dialectic of Nature. Fr. Fr. 00. 1976. A.1. 47. 3. 24.83. A. 1952.Iu:rrus~o1].
Cornu. 47. D. a. 65-66. a.. 48. t.EA£tE~toll 'E VYXEA~EJtT]Q£aaav tL~ aXEnx£~ aJt6'\jJEL~ tou MaQ~. 11materialismo a. Moscow. Engels. 1980. Bernal. 193. R. Nova. a 42. et Fr. Collected Works. a. 292. A. Structure logique du paragraphe 1 du «Capital». r. 'Onw~ 286-287 46. . Karl Marx. t.EtOY Cornu OL !J. London. 272. 67. a. New <DOllQL£. 52.EtacpQ. Engels. Paris. a. 50. 66-70. IIQ~. 70. Anti-Diiluing. 49. Engels.154. E. a. 43. xaQaxtT]QL0tLXCt tT]~ XaJtLtaAL0nxi]~ n. 40. Anti-Dtihring. 2 37. 2. Jindrich Zeleny. Dialectic of Nature. Ludwig Feuerbach sophy. 23. 41. . a. 3. Fr. OJt. G. 16. oro allAAoYLx6 £QYo La logique de Marx. and the Outcome of German Classical Philostotico in Federico Engels. a. York. 304. Engels. (J. a. 1952. Marx and Science. his contribution to political theory.Eaaotu JtOLOtLXCt aL tn noconxo a X oixovouicc. Anti-Dithiing. a. Francois Ricci.80 AyrOYETm: MnArIONA~ 36. Marx. 1967. Fr. Firenze. 1972. 51. 59-62. Engels. 9-10. a. t. 0 11materialismo stotico in Federico Engels. Oxford. Luwpwva !J. 20. Fr. Cornu. 44. Dialectics of Nature. 38. a. os ax£aT] !J. 149.~A. K. Mondolfo. 1934. A. 352. R. a. . Fr. A. a. 5. 53. Cornu. !J. 3.. 296. a. J. 54. JtaQ. 347. Volkof Birth of a Genius.x.EtTl clLacpoQCt VCt!J.. ayyA. Mondolfo. The Logic of Marx. x. 45. Fr. Anti-DUhring. aT]!J. a. 74. Karl Marx. 39. 1974.
M. Fr. o. toy H [11]Xuv'rjuvUn:UQUYELt1] [1ULX'rjEVEQYEW. o. 59. 62. MET(X fa wvatx6.to xu8£vu cero xuta[1EQw[16 tWV EQYWVXaL ta E~UQt'rj[1Uta t1]£ uvun:uQuYEL 1] [11]Xuv'rj w£ OUVOAO'rj «OUat1][1u» uvun:uQuYEL t1] OU[1n:A1]QW[1Unx'rj 0XE01] UVU[1WU tOU£. 1977. OELQuEveryman's 61. u'lJt6£ n:QOXUJttEL un:6 t1]V CPaLVO[1EVOU orov XEYXEA. WtAoaocpia. 115 01][1. TQiT'f/ 8lia'f/ yw Philosophiques. c.. I. 7. E I. 28. Collected 1951. cptAoaocpiar. t. 1971. 873. German Ideology. 11 materialismo storico.38. o.E. 65. YEQ[1UVLX'rj£ EXOOO1]£ tou Keaasaiou.. 156. 0 XUQuXtilQUI.W. 128-129. A. OELQu Suhrkamp. K. c. 0. Klein. Vorlesungen U{3er die Philosophie der Geschichte.. 67. 70. 336-337. 98. 60. 1934. 1978. 63. Marx. W . 2.H ~XE~H TH~ XErKEAIANH~ LllAAEKTIKH~ ME TO MAP2I~MO ~YMct>llNA ME TON ENrKEA~ 8r 55. r. r.12. 67. ~A. R. Aoxiuu: of the German classical Philo- 57. Mn:UYL6vu. A8'rjvu. Marx. E. 58. H.62. Engels. Berlin. 323. Paris 1969. svornt« OUOtU£ XaL f1aQ!.31. W6vEQf1:rrax. 312-313. 28. I~QLWt1]. 11materialismo storico . Fr. [1EtUCP. Dialectic of Nature o. 62. 325. 56. o. Ludwig Feuerbach and the Outcome sophy. 64. Hegel's Logic. La Sainte FamiJJe. 38 x. 1026u 15 X.0. 502. 14. o. r. . Hegel's Logic. 107-108. Etudes Library. c. London. En:L[1EtQOt1]£ ~. ~A. Mondolfo. 47-48. 66. 00. Mondolfo. R. o. .n:uQ. Wallace. 402.34. Hegel's Logic. Engels und Moderne Probleme der PhiJosophie des Marxismus.. Marx. London. The Capital. Works. OEA.WiLXr)C. W 68. 69. Engels. Wallace 0. TOV K. [1EtUCP. o. [1EtucpQ. K. o. The Capital. Fr. Wallace § 27. 5.43. Dialectic of Nature o. Ley. Werke.6n:. r.
873. usrorp. 81. Dialectic of Nature. 1975. Marxism and Hegel. 19-20. a. his Contribution to Political Theory. 82. a. R. 153. 53. 286. 288-289. t. nUQ. a. 2. 89. 86. R. 51. 5-7. 27-28. Marxism and Hegel. Jindrich Zeleny. 75. A. L. 84. a. Marxism and Hegel. 17. t. 116. Norman Levine. Oxford-Santa Barbara. a. 77. oo. V. The Logic of Marx. a.n. Dialectic of Nature. a. a. a. Mondolfo. 79. a. 76. a. 11materialismo starico in F. a. Engels. I. W. The Capital. o. nUQ. 286. a. Klibanski. 1971. 73. 72. Fr.AYrOn. OELQuEveryman. 4. 87. Colletti. . 91. Anti-Diihring. 63. Dialectic of Nature. uerorp. Norman Levine. 79-80. Fr. a. Marxism and Hegel. 88. 80. Wallace. aELQuEveryman's Library. Dialectic of Nature. 108. Hegel's Logic. 78. 85. Dialectic of Nature. Emorrj/l'fl r'fl~ Aoytxrj~. a. 173. 358-377. Miller. 74. a. La Sainte Famille. IIQOAOYO£ tll£ bEUtEQIl£YEQ[tUVLXi)£ fxboall£. 90.TO~ MrrArrONA~ 71. Sur le rapport de Marx Ii Hegel. on. Dialectic of Nature. a. La philosophie contemporaine. Exb. 201. The Tragic Deception. 241. 201. Nova. 83. a.. 369. Engels. a. UyyA. 14.
ME00~OAorIKEI ArrOWEII TOY MAPE ITA IIpOIMA EprA TOY rIA THN KPITIKH TOY AITIKOY KPATOYI .
.
£ta~u nov oLacp6QWv XOLVWVLXWV ta~£wv. o'Y]A. 0 oxoao. EltELOi] EXELauti] t'n A.OL !J.£A. xctnvoerrci uno tOY tou oxono nou rnv unayoQ£uEL.Lt'Y]£ t ~'Y]£rou xQatou£. LU!J. xa8w£ OA. H xQLtLxi] auti] anot£A.LWCJ'Y] 8£wQLa£ tou MaQ~ YLa tL£ oLacpoQ££ cpaCJEL£'Y]£ £~EA.£tacpuCJLxi]£un6CJtaCJ'Y]£.cpEQOV. MEtOUCJLWVELCJ£nQa~'Y] 'Y]8LXE£ a~L££.'Y]£n£QL6oou rou CJtoxaCJ!J. to xQato£ «un£Q~aLVEL» tL£ aVtL8ECJEL£autE£ xm aCJx£Lrnv £~ouCJLa!J.OXA. 6nw£ avaA.oCJocpLa oLxaLou xru rou rnv nOA.OYLxi] nQoun68w'Y] YLa tn 8£!J..LtLxi] £~ouCJLa xm 0 cpoQEa£ nou tnv aCJxEL.EL rn !J. 6nw£ £XA. aut6£ EL vrn 0 nQoCJoLO- 2: KOrr02:: TH2:: MEAETH2:: AYTH2:: EINAI NA AII02::A<I>HNI2::TEI H .UEtm oro Kouuouvurtixo Mavitpeoto (1847) xm CJ£ana xEL!J.£XQLti]QLO to xOLv6 CJU!J.£rnv OnOLa 0 MaQ~ XQLVH xata rc Et'Y] 18431844 tnv a:nmjJ'Y]6tL to xQato£.aoi] OL 8W!J.6you rtou EXOUV an6A.£ rnv anO'ljJ'Y] auti].cpwva !J. Kern rnv ltEQLOOOauti] 'Y]xQLtLxi] tou MaQ~ YLa to aCJtLx6 xQato£.£roix O:rWLOU£aCJxELtm 'Y]noA. o MaQ~ OLatunWVEL rnv xQLtLxi] ton YLa rnv naQanavw anO'\jJ'Y] CJt'Y]v EwaywYrl atnv KQtuurl rl1~ cPtAOaoC{J(a~ rov Aixaio» rov XfYUEA (1844) xm CJt'Y]L:Vfj{30Arl OTl1V KQmurl rl1~ cPtAOaoC{J(a~ rov Aixaio» rov XfYUEA (1843).£U8£QLa.o£v £Jt'Y]Q£a~Etm uno tL£ aVtL8ECJ£L£!J. to xaQaxt'Y]QLCJtLxa !J.La£ultEQ~atLxi]£.£va t'Y]£ nQwL!J.ouxm rou CJuYYQacpLxouEQYOUrou. xm aLti]!J.!J.oCJocpLa XEyX£A.E80oo£ !J. avamuCJCJEL.LtLxi] CjJLA.0YLx£u£tm !J.ELtouovto. !J.£8000A.ata rou oQ80u A.'Y]QwvEtm. 6nw£ 'Y]£A.uto xUQo£.£rn CPLA.
H ouvstonon ron OU~CPEQOVtO~tou . MaQs evornrc [11. tou vonroix rou rou xm tl~ ouvatOtl']tE~ nQoUno8EtH va tou. nou anoOlOH orov XEYXEA [2]. xru rnv nOAltEla. onoto ~ovtm tl']~ OL ato~lXE~ EmOlWSH~ tElVOUV vc avaJttux80vv QlOQWta. H nQay~atwol'] OUVOAlXOVav8Qwnou xorvcovtcc.86 QW~O~ nov OQWVxatw xrrorsro» uno roix MIIArIONA~ OnOlOU~ 8a nQay~atonOLl']8i] o OUYXEXQl~EVO~ xm OUVOAlXO~av8Qwno~. OEl tn OUVElOl']Ol'] ou emrtou r nov aw8i]oEwv. rou «OUVOAlXOV av8Qw- uno tnv onoto rnv anO'ljJl']. lOlW~ xata EXCPQa~£tm aU8EVtlXa ~E cpaOl'] tl']~ ESEAlSl']~ torv naQaYWYlXWV onw~ 0 XaAAltEXVl']~ ~E to EQYOtEXVl']~. H avtaYWVWtlxi] EnlOlWsEWV Elvm XQatlxi] OXEOl']~Etasv nov cpaVEQi] orn ocpalQa a~wa OlacpOQWV rrrouixcov oixovoutr«. MaQs ESl']yd uno toy xata~EQW~O rnv XHpaAmOXQatlxi] tnv EQyaola. Ilooxsrtm. Ol']Aaoi] nov XlVi]tQWV rou. 0 OUVOAlXO~ av8Qwno~ WWtEQlXO xru toy (3lW~atO~ xm nQasl']~. oxonoo. nQay~atonOLi]- OEl ~Eoa uno tl~ XOLVWVlXE~OXEOH~ rou. roix.tl 0 XEYXEA ovo~a~H (Blirgerliche Gesellschaft). ME to al tl']~a tl']~ nQay~atwol']~ nou» xa80Ql~£tm l'] nQoontlxi] ~tl']V XOLVWVla auti]v tnv vnaQSl'] ~la~ ataslxi]~ OL AHtoUQYlE~ non naQaoo- orov l']YE~ova. H EsouOla OEV naQE~(3alvH Yla vc tl~ nEQlOQlOH. on ~E OL avtl8EOH~ nou xaQa«XOLVWVla tWV lOlWtWV» Yla tnv XOLVWVla ornv am- on 0 MaQs XQlVH to xQato~ nno- Xtl']Ql~OUV O. Avorrnxrtou. Olaxa ovrprouv XO OVVOAO. YmQ(3alvH onw~ toy evvoet 0 xaQaxtl']Ql~£tm coro rnv ovcnou 0 rrrv avt(8Wl'] ueon orov ESWtEQlXO av8Qwno.xm cvrcvorvtl'] ~la mv aAAl'] [3]. Ol']Aaoi] toy cpOQEatl']~ nOAl n~Eta(3l(3a~ovtm oro XOLVWVl- xi]~ EsouOla~. tl~ AH toUQYlE~ tl~ OUVHOl']OlaXE~ E~nHQlE~. rtou OUVOEOVtm ~E tl~ OW~atlXE~ rou avaYXE~. 0XEOEWV. 0 OUVOAlXO~ av8Qwno~ tl']~ EQyaola~. tEAEl tnv nQay~atwol'] toy OXl']~atw~o rou tEQ~atl~ovtm tl']~ EAEu8EQla~ xm ton AOYlXOV. H~ (3aQo~ tou XOL VWVlXOV OUVOAOU.
KPATOU 87 OllVOAOll it.rro'\jJT]OtL to XQo.OT] tYj~ XEyx£A amoxa80QLO[!O tYj~ £QyaoLa~ O£ £[!nOQ£ll[!a. 0 0 MaQ~ xa80QL~EL tTl Ollyx£XQL[!EVYj LOtOQLXit [!oQCPit xm tnv «xowcovto.Jttll~Yj.tT].[!Eoa oao rnv avo. T] aL08T]0T] toll XllQLW~ OWOALXOU £XCPQo. xit~.toll~.tOll~ nQotino8EtH toll. onw~ to OQL~ELxm to £Q[!T]V£UH 0 XEYX£A. tou XEYX£A YLa mv «xorvcovtu torv LOLWtWV»O£ OllVo.toll~ O£ [!La OQLO[!EVYj po.OT]T]~ [ c t XOLVWVLXit~LOtoQLa~.Jttll~Yj tT]~ aOtLxit~ to.Sa ntrrv va llnoOtYjQLX8£L OtL 0 MaQ~ £~T]Y£LtL~ OLamOtWOEL~ OXEOEL~0' currin.- . OL ano'\jJEL~toll orrntou xit to.~£tm MaQ~ YLa rnv ue ru. £llQut£Qa. o xa80QLO[!O~ roix tT]~ AELtollQYLa~ toll toll XQo. H [!E8ooo~.ME80aOAor. rorv LOLWtWV». YLa tT]V '\jJllXOAoYLa xm to it8o~ x£cpaAmoxQo. OL OQOLuutoi it OtL YLa toy MaQ~ £Lvm Jt£QLnOll «ouoto» it qxuvenu XQYjO'L[!O- tmrcoonuoi.QtT]OT][!£ to qxuvousvo tYj~ OllOOWQ£llOT]~toll x£cpaAaLOll xm tT]~ [!£ta~oAit~ OLXOVO[!LXit ~o. nou OllVOEEL ue rn OLaA£XtLxit avo. xm 8£[!£ALWv£tm onw~ OLa[!OQcpwv£tm LOtoQLXo. xato. nQo£xtEL VOW OllvatO tou ooroo xm uno nOAAE~ nA£llQE~ ru. tT]V «anoyu[!vwoit» ollyxaAumH amit uno tT]V LO£OAOYLa nou OllOXOtL~ELit oxonou~ nQay[!atLXOU~ H LO£OAOYLa £xCPQa~Otav. ExcpQaOT] xm tYj~ «IOEa~» ern ocpaLQa toll «avtLXEL[!£VLXOU nveuuctoc».U[4). eve- AUOEL~toll XEyx£A YLa tnv «xotvcovtc rorv LOLWtWV».QtT]OT]ue rn [!OQCPitnou naLQVOllv OL naQaywYLxE~ LOLW~O£ OllVo. no. ue tT]V 6. Toix nOL£LYLa vo OQLOHtn OllYX£XQL[!EVYj ELtollQYLa rtou ovcnrooA OEL [!La OQLO[!EVYj !OQCPitXQo.~Yj.~Yj~ xcu tT]~ x£cpaAmoxQatLa~..vw O£ [!La oQLCJ[!EVYj avtLAT]'\jJT]YLa rn CPUOT] tL~ AELtollQYL£~ tYj~ xQLtLxm 0 MaQ~ £x8EtEL rnv avtLAYj'\jJYjalltit LOLW~ore Ot%OV0f. AIIO'YEI~ TOY MAPE ~TA IIPnIMA EPrA TOY rIA THN KPITIKH TOY A~T. OllVt£xvL£~. BaoLxit %a xai <PtAOaocpt%aXftQ6YQacpa TOV 1844 £mOLW- ~T] tT]~ XQLtLxit~ ELvm vu YLVELoacpit~ Yj nQay[!atLxit «CPUOYj» xm «unaQ~T]» toll XQo. toy MaQ~. nou £cpaQ[!O~EL MaQ~ OtT]V xQLtLxit tou XQo.0 roue.
xm tou lO£OAOYlXOUEJtOlXOoo~i]~atoe. JtQay~atOJtOlELtm tEAlXU UV xa80Ql(JtEL l'] (JXE(Jl']ron ~E tOY (JUYXEXQl~EVOuv8QwJto. tou XQutOUe. 8E~EAlWVEtm tEAlXU nnvoi orn 8E(Jl']on o (JUYXEXQl~EVOe. (JXOJtoe.Etm uno tc ~E(Ja JtaQaywyi]e. 0 (JXOJtoe. H WtOQLa ELvm ouvuccouevn ~E rnv E~EAl~l'] trov ~E(JWV JtaQaywyi]e.tl']e. JtaQaywyi]e.88 xrrorsros MIIArIONAE toe..uv8QwJtoe. (JXE(JHe.. o l(JtoQlXOe. oJtwe.. ELvm m(J8l']to ov. xQltlxi]e. rou MaQ~ oro JtQWl~a EQya tou. JtaQaatu(JEwv xcu (JUYXlvnotuxorv E~JtHQlWV. ~E rnv XOlVWVlXi] Ola(JtQw~utw(Jl'] (JE XOlVWVlXEe.H Yla tOY «WtOQlXOJtOll']~EVO» xm «XOlVWVlXOJtOll']~EVO»qnxnxo xoouo.. ELVm lEQOi] on ELVm l'] JtQay~utw(Jl'] rou AOYlXOU. Ola~OQCPwvEtm (JE ~la OQW~EVl'] £Jtoxi]. nou ELvm ouvuqxrouevec ~E ru.. rou xm tn (Jw~anxi] tou avuJttu~l']. tl']e. rou XQutoue.l']tEL xm Ol']~LOUQYEL E rnv EQya(JLa rou tn m(J8l']tu ovnxetuevc nou ~ lxaVOJtOlOUV ne.. JtaQaywyi]e. taQaywyi]e. xatl']YOQLEe. rcov (JXE(JEWVJtaQaywyi]e. l'] aJto(Jacpi]vwl'] rou OJtOLOUEL vru 0 tEAlXOe. xa80QL1.. ~oQJ . ~E rnv lO£OAOYLa nou EXAOYlXEUHxm xa8wtu l']8lXU aJtoOExti] rnv XOlVWVlXi] Ola(JtQw~utw(Jl']. tl']e. tl']e.Yla to XQutoe. To xaQaXtl']Qlonxo tou auto ocpELAEtm oro YEyovoe. on l'] (JUVELOl'](Ji] tou. 'Evnc. (JxoJtoe. ~E rnv xatavo~i] tou noorovroc.H rn CPU(Jl']. 0 (JUYXEXQl~EVOe.. ou JtaLQvH errn «av8Qwmvo». H 8EWQLa Yla to XQutoe. aVUYXEe. ~amxoe. xm ne. m(J8i](JHe.xm ~a8~laLa (JE tU~He. ME rnv EQya(JLa rou aUu1.Etm Jtuvw ornv xctuvouri xm rnv OlXHOJtOLl'](Jl']rou JtQo·Covtoe. Oeouou. uv8QwJtoe. Ol']Aaoi] l'] oxornt« tWV avnAi]'\jJEwv. rou MaQ~ etvru va «noouqmvtosi auti] tnv £JtWtl']~OAOYlXi] 8E(Jl'] tl']e. xaQaxti]Qae. XQlnxi]e. 8EwQLae. tl']e. XQltlxi]e. ELvm WtOQlXO ov. ~E rou. nou (JXl']~atL1. nou Olatl']Qouv rnv XOlvwvlXi] Ola(JtQw~utW(Jl']. evtcocerm (Jtl'] 8EwQLa nov Oeouccv xm (JXE(JfWVJtaQaywyi]e. n Ol']Aaoi] WtoQlXO xaQaxti]Qa [5]. Ava1. ME rnv EQya(JLa Ol']~lOUQYELtm l'] l(JtOQLa.. nou ~a(JL1. ne.
EQyaoLae. H taoT] auti] tou aotLxou xQUtoUe. TOV IIoAt'iLuov A6yov. naQaywyi]e. Tor MAPS J.. OEOO~EVO 6tL to orrnxo xQUtoc:. ~EV 8a nrov ouo». tLe.ton Neurrovn. tnv ta~Lxi] OLuQ8QwOT]i] EUQUtEQa tnv XOLvwvLXi] OLaotQw~utwOT]. 89 epEe.TA lIPnIMA EPfA Tor rIA THN KPITlKH Tor AJ.. aOtLXEe.xoouoAOYLae. ooxrro vu E~o~OLW8i] 0 oroxcouo. we. avaAOYLEe. IIaQ6~OLa. i] vn 8EWQT]8ouv tu XEL~EVa rou. XQL tLxi]e.naQaywyi]e. ton MaQ~ tT]e. rtou avaepEQovtm OtT] <P~Aooocpia TOV L1owiov rou XEYXEA. nou OLatT]QEL. xm OLXELOnOLT]OT]C:. Kotuxti. AlIO'YEIJ.E~EAL~T]e. ELvm va xa80QLOEL tLe.nQwL~T]e. YVW0T]e. nov AEL tOUQYLWV tou UnOXEL~EVOUtT]e. 0 MaQ~ toVLsEL 6tL T] «uQ~uu~ rwv 6Jl'AWV OEV . 0XEOELe. ELvm va E~T]yi]OEL rnv tUOT] rou co'nxou XQuto'Ue.ME80LlOAOf. xm tLe.T. KPATOy). £:JtontELae. ~E tLe.tT]e.EXAOYLXEUELru OLxmwx VEL T]8LXU mv XOLVWVLXi] OLaOtQw~UtWOT] nou EXepQUSEL ru. 0 MaQ~ 8EWQELwe. ~OQepEe. n xru XWQLe. xm 0' autouc:. 0' curoix non OU~~£tEXOUV a~wa OtT]V UOXT]OT]tT]e.. 0 Knvt Aa~~UVEL we.xcu nov QU8~LOtLXWV aQXwv tou OUV8EtLxOU A6you. OXEOELC:.aVaAUtLxi]e.. nou EXELOT]fUOUQyi]OELOE OAT] tTl OLuQXELa tT]e. an61/JELe.. nQoU6tou vroc tT]e. OEOO~EVO6tL T] XOO~OAOYLa rou Nsutorvo ELvm EYXUQT]. E~ouoLae. XQLtLxi]e. tT]V LOtoQLXi] E~EAL~T]. LOtOQLxi]e. mQL600u ~E toy oroxcouo rou Kovt. OUVELOT]OT]e. naQOUOUxsEL ava~epLO~i]tT]tEe.. XQLtLxi]e. o ELOLXUtorv ~oQepWV tT]e.ME rnv XQLtLxi] ron 8EWQT]tLXOUA6you sT]tELtru 0 xa80QLO~6c:.. [6] H un01/JT] auti] rou MaQ~ YLa tn ~OQepi] tT]e. rtou aVa<pEQEtm oro orrnxo XQUtOe. rrou nQoUno8EtEL T] EyxuQ6tT]ta tT]e. IILO fLOLX6 xm rno U~wo EQYOtT]e. elvm LOLaLtEQa EXOT]AT]. otov cvcornxroetru to YQaepELoxQatLx6 qxuvouevo [7]. va OLVEL yLa toy eouto tou tT]V EvtUnWOT] 6tL anotEA£l ~La ~£tacpuOLxi] unoOtaOT] xm vo E~nVEEL LEQ6 Moe. 'EQYo tT]e. unuQXEL.. YVWOT]e. v6T]0T]e. Eva £looe.rou Kovt YLa tT]V XQLtLxi] tT]e. nou tT]V uno~EVOUV. ou nQo'Cno8EtEL T] oaepi]e. nov xatT]Yom QLWVtT]e.tT]e.LO£OAOYLXi]OUYXUAU1/JT] E~i]Y'I10T]rou ormxou xQUroue. AEL tOUQYLEe.
ami] OEVOTJ[LaLVHon 0 MaQt. nQouno8EtEL tTJ yvwoti] 8EOTJ rou MaQt.TJC:.TJ tTJ nou X avaJttuooEL OE [Lla OQW[LEVTJ PUOTJ LOtOQlXi]c:.orcv cvcornxroerru OE [Lla mavaotanxi] moxi].EL OAOXATJQW[LEVTJ 8EWQTJtlXi] xQltlxi] tou XQUtouc:. H U 8EWQTJtLXi] XQltlXi] [LnoQd vn EXELtu LOla anotEAEO[Lata [LE rnv UAlXi] ouva[LTJ [LOVO orov acpO[LOlwvEtm VOTJtLXU xm OUYXlVTJOlaXU cno w. nc:.EAlt. QL nu~~» [81. 8EWQTJtlXi] XQltlxi] OXTJ[LaH tonold otTJV ltEQLJttWOTJami] tTJV OUVELOTJti] vuYXTJ EVOC:... xa8wc:.TJ rtou nQoTJyi]8TJXE.Et.90 xrrorzroa MIIArIONAl: [LnoQEL vc avnxataota8d coto to onAO tTJC:. .H avuYXTJ auti] ELvm anotEA£O[La xru tTJC:. 6EXEtm tTJV WCPEAl[LLOtlXi]i] nQaY[LatLOtlxi] un0'i'TJ on TJaAi]8ELa [Llac:. OU[LnEQlAa[L[3aVO[LEVOUxm tou XQutouc:.. «[LU~EC:. naQu [LOVO OE mavaOtatLXEC:. Et.TJC:. L rrou nQOTJyi]8TJXE xm nQOEtOl[LU~El ami]v rtou axoAou8d. H 0XEOTJ cvoueoc OtTJv OAOXATJQW[LEVTJ 8EwQTJnxi] xQltlxi] rou aonxou xQutouc:.xm nQUt. 8EOTJ H O[LWC:. xm tnv «xQlnxi] torv onAwv» OTJ[LaLVELn TJXQltLXi] tOU aotLxou o xQUtouc:.lxi]c:. a snnvcotrmxo» [LEtaOXTJ[LatLO[LOU OtTJ0XEOTJ naQaYWYlXWV [LEOWV xm tat. Ot mOXEC:.. H 8E[LEAlW[LEVTJ xru OAOXATJQW[LEVTJ XQltlxi] tou XQutouc:.TJC:.EAlt. OtOQlXi]c:. 8EWQLac:. H 8EWQTJnxi] XQltlxi] YLVEtm oacpEOtEQTJ. nou OU[L[3UAAOUVorn Olati]QTJOi] tTJC:. QLvstru «no rnv nQaxtlxi] anotEA£O[LatlX xornt« tTJC:. amEC:.». ~EV [LnOQ£Lvu unuQt. EXOUV nQOEtOl[Laotd «no rnv wtOQlXi] Et. 0XEOElC:. Yla rnv cvrupcon aVU[L£Oa oro [LEOa naQaywyi]c:. moxEc:.. «no tTJ [Lla [LEQlU xcu rnv XOlVWVlXi] OlaOtQW[LUnoon rtou EJtlXQatEL cno rnv UAATJ... C tTJC:. ~TJ[LaLVH on TJOAOXATJQW[LEVTJ 8EWQTJtlXi] xQltlxi] EXCPQU~EL OUVELOTJOTJ [Lla aVEQXO[LEVTJ OlvWVlXi] tUt. naQaywyi]c:. Yla tTJV EVOtTJta 8EWQLac:. xcu oro OlucpOQa OtolXELa rou mOlXOOO[Li][Latoc:. oluQ8QwOTJC:. nQEnEL vc EQ[LTJVEU8EL xmvwvLOAOYlXU xm LOtOQlXU.EAlt.i] ovcueoc OtTJv XOlvWVlXi] OlaOtQW[LUtWOTJ xm rnv lOWAoYLa [9l.
£e. Xutu ty] yVcD[lY] rou MaQ~. ceto !!y]xavi)e. 8£0e. r «'UJt£Q(3aL VH» tou. tn A. «XOl vwvLae. xru ornv toJt08EtY]Oi) tou orov XcDQO tou 'UJt£Q(3anxou [101. Yla to xQUtoe. To xaQaxtY]Ql(JtlXO curo rou xQUto'Ue. JtOA.Y]'\jJY] £xCjJQu~Etm ornv 6. oJtwe. H avtLA. Ioxuo'Uv Yla OA. avi)xH orn oCjJaLQa tou 'UJt£Q(3anxou xm on EXH tOY xaQaxti)Qa tou l£QOU xm rou 8ELo'U. en to xQUtoe. KPATon 91 Ano tOY 8£WQY]tlXO xm JtQaxtlxo xaQaXti)Qa tY]I.0YlXOL xcvovec non aXOA. e.. tY]e. a'Uti)e.O'U8£L MaQ~. av£~uQtY]ty] oao ne. «no rnv uJto'\jJY] tou MaQ~.O £VcDtamoXQova OlatY]QELrrrv ato!!lxoty]tu tou. on to xQutoe..i)yo'Uv ornv [l 'U80JtOLY]oY]i) otnv aJt08EWoy] rou XQUto'Ue.£lto'UQy£L ouv Evae. 'UJtUQXH we. to xQUtoe. to xQutoe.. rnv OQL~£l 0 XEyX£A. H 'UJtEQ(3aoY] 'Uti) YLv£tm !!£ uio [l'UOtY]QlcDOy]) [laYlxi) a i OlaOlxaoLa.ltlXEe. ouvxeXQl[lEV£e. Ot xovove. tou av8QcDJto'U. £mOlcD~He. Y]uJto'\jJY]rou XEyX£A.Y]'\jJY] n to xQUtoe. o A.ltlxi) 8£WQLa rou XEyX£A. cou 8£OJtOLOUVtOY YQan r CjJHoxQanxo [lY]Xavw!!O. JtQo'liJt08EtH ty] 8Qy]OX£'UtlXi) i) [l'Uonxwnxi) aVtLA. .nou EXH. E~ m tLae. JtQO'liJt08EtH.y]'\jJy]. atO!!lXEe.. to «rouo evtnooerm oro XOlVWVlXO OUVOA. unoorornoJtOl£L xm ixovoaoie] ue qxrvtuonxo toozto OA.LU[lCjJwva ue rnv £y£A. 0 avtaywVW[lOe. aJto'\jJHe. non xataA. [111. 0 nou cvcorrixroetzu OtY] ct>tAoaocpia TOV Aixaio» rou XEyX£A.£e. £Lvm o'Uv'UCjJaO!!EVO rnv uJto'\jJY]nou 0 MaQ~ aJtoOLOH orov ue XEyX£A. JtQay!!atoJtOli)8Y]x£ ornv Ilooxxno.ME80110Aor. avtaywVW[lOUe. ouvcvovrct ot !!£80A. rorv OJtOLWV o'UVWtU rnv «xorvcovtn trov lOlWtcDV».Hto'UQyLa xru rnv a~La rou lO£atoU tUJto'U Yla OA. on us tn o'UV'LaY[lanxi) !!ovaQXLa. H «[l'Uonxwnxi)>> avtLA. Yla to co nxo XQ(Xtoe.£e. trov lOlWnov». AlIO'YEI~ TOY MAPE ~TA lIPmMA EPrA TOY rIA THN KPITIKH TOY ~T.ne. tY]e. ono». OlaOlxaoLae.Jto'\jJY] ou XEyX£A. XQltlxi)e. Ano rn oxomn rou MaQ~. 8£WQL£e. a'UtOL O£v wxuo'UV !!OVO Yla tnv JtOA. orov XQLVH rn 8£WQLa Yla to XQutoe.Havi) avtLA. 8W[lOJtOl£L.Y]'\jJY] rou XEyX£A. ava~Y]ti)n OHe. e. [lla lO£ati) unocrcon.
[14]. XUQuxti)QU 8fWQT]Of tT] 8QT]OXf1JtLXi) U:rt0SEVCDOT]CDC.UQt1JQLU YLU tT]V XOLVCDVLXi):rtQuY!J. 1JYXfXQL!J.. OtUV Of V !J. fXAOYLXf1J!J. <I>01JEQ!J.EV01J UV8Qcll:rt01J. XQ(lt01JC.atLXOtT]tU.unxoXatumw!J. :rtQWL!J.to tou 8fL01J i) tou xrrorsros MTIArIONAl: evvoet Beou. toy 8t"Cxi).UtO:rtOLi)OfL us orcv Of V YVCDQL~fLtoy «emrro» rou CDC. CP1Jyi) uno tn 01JYXfXQL!J.OLU!J. tT]V :rtQUST] t01J xm tou. H XQLtLxi) tT]C.. :rtLOtT]C. :rtQUY!J.T]C.OQCPi):rt01J tou :rtQOti:rt08EtfL XQLtLxi) tT]C.EVT]!J.UQt1JQLU :rt01J fXCPQu~ftm ue :rtLOtT]. tn 8QT]oxf1JtLxi) va 8fCDQT]8d CDC. tnv 0 XEYXfA..u rou AQu xm to xQUtoC. LOtoQLXO xm XOLVCDVLXOV ov.!J.:rtOQfL VU uc. o8T]tov m :rt01J tU1JtL~H O:rtCDC.EV01J tT]C.unxi). MUQS tT]C. 8QT]OXf1JtLXi)C.OT]AUOi) rou rou uonxov OLVH 0 XEYXfA.:rtUX O!J.. 0 <I>01JfQ!J.OtU8fQO cpVOT]C.LU !J.OdXVH on XU!J...atLXO OV tOY oOi)YT]Of OtT] OLU- .. 0 MUQs OEXftm tou QU tou UVnXfL!J.EVO mo8T]to. qxrvrc01JVHOT]ti) OLUC. O:rtCDC.LOVQYT]!J. To 8do !J.UtLXOtT]tU [13].uv8QwmvT]C. 0 OT]AUOi) LOtOQLXO xru tT]C. CDC. ue tT]V fXAOYLXf1J!J. 'EtOL ovroc.EVT].oQCPi) UAAO- tQLCDOT]C.u tou YLU toy uv8Qw:rt01J.» tou uv8Qw:rt01J. :rtLOtT]C. uovo XOLVCDVLXO OV [15]. OVfLQO i) to OQU!J. Etvo.rtfQLOOO1J.OC. f:rtfLOi) Of V fLvm 8u i)tuv 01JvatO fXAOYLXf1J!J.dvm i) X1JQLCDC.T]tT]. 8QT]OXf1Jnxi)c. H xm rpovrccnxo 8QT]OXf1Jnxi) morn. UL08T]to xm OCD!J. Me tn CPUVtUOLU rou nc. :rtQO(3UAAH Of EVU 8t"Cxo OV. m : x Itu <I>01JfQ!J.EVT] xm U:rtOtfAW!J.LU:rtQUY!J.U:rtOXCDQL~ftm O «no nc.EQH toy V OtL T] 8QT]OXf1Jnxi) 1J:rtfQ(3unxov. UVU~T]ti)OfLC. morn 01JYXfXQL!J.o t ue to orn 0CPUL[12]. 0XL fvtfAWC. UQU fLvm OT]!J..0 UV8QCD:rt0C. O:rtCDC. fCP' OOOV 8fCDQT]8fL CDC.EV01J rnrc :rt01J :rtfQL(3UAAH toy moro.:rtUX.U tT]C.EVT]XOLVCDVLXi):rtQUY!J. fXCPQU~fL tT]V OAOXAi)QCDOT] UXOA01J8fL 10 !J. 8QT]OXf1JtLXi)C.92 Arpou to xQutoC. 01JVUYftm uVUmVOOfL on T] XQLtLXi) OAU tn XUQUxtT]QLOnXU :rtLOtT]C.LOVQYT]- ours xm to XQUtoC. 0 «UVUOtfVUY!J. ton xm nc. Of V dvm uv8Qw:rt01J. fXCPQU~fL !J. H OLU!J. T]AUOi) U:rt0SEVCDOT]C.LU u1J8oQ!J. T] 8QT]OXf1JtLXi) i) U:rt0sfVWVftm ntorn fXCPQU~H !J.CDC. 01JvatOtT]tEC.H uvtLAT]'ljJi) rou OtL 0 UV8QCD:rt0C. fLvm OT]!J.:rtUX.
u EmXaA. cv OEVauaXEnatd 1840. xatl']yoglEC. 6nwc. .. avtt8Eta. orn I'eo(ancien !LaVla lOU 1840 [17]. nagatl']XOLVWVLXi) tOY !LErnv Egyaata auvtEA. 0 nagaaLtLx6c. ngoExtdvouv ol']A. nlatl']C.oytac. !LEVEL rnv ta~LXi) !LErnv E~EA. ngo'lin08EtH 0 xa80gw!L6C.» rou regime). gLWV autwv.avtLXH!LEVOU 8gl']aXEutLxi)C. rnv aouva!Lta tU~lJC. emonuntva xugtwC. EtVm urrootxo xru XOLVWVLX6 ov axgL(3wc. KPATOU 93 tunroon tovt~EL !LLUi.T. ntatl']C. H xgLtLxi) tl']C. nov xatl']yo- nou aUVEXt~OuV to «naA.L~l'] nov nagaywYLEx(3LO!LlJXUVWl'] xru tl']C. ME nagaaL ttxo Em~ouv OL xmVWVLxEC.m6 xa8wtwc. Tor MAPS l. iorootcc. av8gwnoA.A. 'Onwc. uotixou ngo'lin08EtH AvtLxEt!LEv6 xi] morn.LtLxi) A.aoi) rn CjJ£OuoagXLxi)CjJual']tl']C. aanxi)c.86v xm rtou xa8LalOurnv OLXOVO!LLxi)xm nOA. WC. rnv av£Jtagxi) LOtwC. lOU Mag~ auvuyEtm xgUlOuC.OUvtm LOL6tl']ta nou Elxav oro nagEA. XOL- VWVLXi)C. rnv evvoet 0 Mag~ oro OUO Xd!LEVa nou avaCjJEgovtm ern C/>[Aoaocpia rov /sixaiou lOU XEYXEA. o'n 0 uv8gwnoc. nou EJtLtgEnH rnv £JtL(3tWai)roix.0YLXi]ornv 0 Mag~ <l>6uEg!Lnax orov (3a8!L6 nou avayvwgt~EL WlOgLXi) xru 6n l'] xgLtLxi) XOLVWVLXi)CjJual']OU av8gwnou. l An6 rnv av8gwnoA. AnOO/EIl. XOLvWVLXi) xatl']yogta Tetoto roue. av8gwnou CjJuO'l']rou [16]... tl']C.El tru l'] !LEtu(3aal'] lOU WtOgLXi] xm mv anO!LaxguvEtaL aaCjJwc.xo xagaxti)ga. A.TA np(l[MA EPrA Tor rIA THN KPITIKH Tor Al.ME1301l0Aor. ma8l']t6 xm otourmxo ov. 0 Mag~. Hvm torv XOLVWVLXWVoorov !LE tl'] aHgu nou E~l']yOUVrnv anO~EVWal'] rtou EXCjJgu~Etm !LEtl'] 8gl']aXEutL- H XOLVWVLXi)xgLtLxi). oLug8gwalJ. rnv unag~lJ XOLVWVLXWV EnL(3LwaEWV non tg6no a!Lanxi) EXOUV nagam n. xov usotov..oyta tou ami).. YLatt dvm gi]8l']XE JtLOnuvw. 8gl']aXEutLxi]C. urto uno tl'] (3LOA.HlOugyta rtou OEV noxouv tn XagL- Xa!L!LLU ouaLaanxi) ce anoOExti] aA. LOLattEga orn I'eoucvto aVE~i)yl']toc. mv xgLtLxi) tl']C. rnv xmvwvLxi) xgLtLxi). atan1-enC.Htougyta Etvm l'] agWlOxgatta xagaxti)gac. YEg!LaVLxi)c.
AVtL8Eta to XQutoe. 0 MaQs. H XOlVWVlXi] XQltlXi].. OJtwe. AAAa.nov OJtOLWV af!Ol~aLa ESUQt'll'll on ()EV dVaL O'llVEl()'llti] [20]. JtO'll t EsEtU~El rnv XOlVWVlXi] ()laOtQWf!utwO'll orn Otatlxi] XaL ESEAlOOOf!EV'llf!OQCPi] t'lle. 8a i]tav non ()'UVat6 va Evtax8EL aVtLOtOlxa ornv YEVlXi] i] rnv LOtOQlXi]XOl- . OX'llf!atL~EtaL YEVEtlXU uno tnv «XOlVWVLa rrov l()lWtWV». a UV ()'llAa()i] JtQ6XEltaL Yla t'll CPUO'll'lle. XQltlxi]e. EOtW XaL «ouvuuei». JtQoliJto8EtEl rnv «aotlxi] XOlVWVLa» [18]. XOlVWVLOAOYLae. f!JtOQEL 8EWQ'll8d we. dVaL f!EQOe. us m to «OJtAOt'lle. XaL av oxoun orov OQO«aOtlxi] XOlVWVLa» aJto()o8d 'll XEYXEAElavi] onuaotc.. JWU dVaL ta'lltoXQova 8EWQ'lltlxi] XaL JtQaXtlxi]. EJtlOti]f!'lle. ()luQ8QwO'lle. rou XQuto'lle. XOlVWVlXEe.JtQaYf!atoJtOlELtal 'll O'llOOWQE'llO'll XEcpaAdo'll «no rnv aOtlxi] tUS'll. 0 JtQOO()LOQLOf!Oe. JtlOtEUEl. XOlVWVlXi]e.~ OlXOVOf!La. v EWOi]OO'llf!Etnv «aOtlxi] XOlVWVLa»6Jtwe.mv EWOEL0 MaQs.O'UVUYEtal on 'll «aotlxi] XOlVWVLa» ()EVJtQoliJto8EtEl rnv uJtaQS'll tou xQuto'lle. to XQutoe.. t Xatu rnv OJtOLaOX'llf!atL~OVtaL oi Jt6AEle. Movo av YLVEl avacpoQu ornv EYEAElavi] «l()Ea». LOtoQLae. l~lWOEle. JtOAltlxi]e.. JtO'll Yla toy MaQs EXEl usrcqnxnxo i] XaL f!'llOtlXLOtlx6 JtEQlEXOf!EVO. OUf!cpwva ue toy MaQs.ou cvnxeuisvou t'lle. l()EOAOYlX6EJtOlxoMf!'llf!a JtO'll EVLOXUEl va rn ()lati]Q'llO'll t'lle. YlatL aQVELtaL W. to XQutoe. 'll 8EWQLa Yla to XQutoe. tnv XQ'llf!atl?I.94 AYrOn:TO.JtO'll euvoet t'll ouoOWQE'llO'll rou XEcpaAaLO'll aJt6 rnv aOtlxi] tus'll [19]. 0 XEYXEA. uno tnv «aOtlxi] XOlVWVLa» ELVaL ron cpavEQ6e. XaL t ELVaLaVtlXELf!EVO t'lle. ou XQutO'lle. OE O'llVEXEla f!E t'llV EX~LOf!'llXUVLO'll. H f!OQCPi] oi AElto'llQYLEe. oJtwe.» XaL rnv mavaOtatlxi] JtQUS'll.. O()'llyd oro O'llf!JtEQaOf!a or. OUf!cpwva us rnv OJtOLa'll «aOtlxi] XOlVWVLa» ()'llAa()i] 'll «XOlVWVLanov l()lWtWV» ELVaLaQXlxu Eva OUVOAO avtaYWVlOtlXWV l()lWtlXWV EJtl()lWSEWV. Av OQLOt L EtOl 'll «aOtlxi] XOlVWVLa».E MIIArIONA. XQutO'lle.. XOlVWVlxi]e. f!JtOQEL 8EWQ'll8EL va oav EYX'llQ'll 'll UJtO'ljJ'll n 'll «XOlVWVLanov l()lWtWV» JtQoliJto8EtEl rnv uJtaQe S'll.E Ano rnv XOlVWVlXi] XQltlxi]. aQXlXU ue to rou Ef!Jt6QlO.
LbLCD~ V bfXtoVrLf on nQaYrLatonOLU dtm rL0VOue tc «onAa tT]~ XQLtLX~~» xm 0XL ue tnv «XQLtLX~ tCDVonACDV».nou XU8f rLLaroix (J"tEXfLnuvCD croix WrLOll~"tT]~nQOT]yoVrLfVT]~ rLfta(3uAAOV"ta~ "to XOLVCDVL.Asv fLvm bLxmoAoYT]rLEVT] uno'4'T] OtL to xQUtO~ anOtfAfL rLLa SfXCDQLOt~«ouT] (JLa»non fSftUsftm osro rLLaSfXCDQLOt~ £JtLOt~rLT]211. nQOT]y~8T]Xf 8a cpavd on "to XQU"tO~Of XU8f (JllYXfXQLrLEVT]£JtOX~xru oe XU8f (JllYXfXQLrLEVO roao Qll8rLLSfL"tTlbLabLxaaLa tT]~ naQaYCDYLx~~ fQyaoLa~. Tor MAPS ). tT]~ XOLVCDVLX~~ xm LOLoQLa~. XO "tT]~(JVOLT]rLaJVrLcpCDva n£ rLfta~aAMrLfVf~ aVUYXf~» [231.' a1JtO ~oQd v« YLVfL Myo~ xm YLa «LOtoQLX~ CPV(JT]» orov ~a8rLo non ro CPll<JLXUvnXfLrLfva naLQV01JVLOtoQLX~ rLOQCP~ a ue rnv fQya(JLa toll av8QWnOll.T. onCD£xa80QLsftm «no tL~ aVUYXf~ rou xcrcrLfQLOrLOV tT]~ fQyaoLa~. tCDVavayxwv rou av8QwnOll. non bLXmWV01JVtnv ano'4'T] OtL T]£JtLYfLaSCD~ fLvm «OVfLQO»xru on 0 nQaYrLatLXO~ XO(JrLO~ dvm 0 cpavta(Jnxo~ ~ 0 LbfatO~. tT]~ xa"tavorL~~ tou nQo·Lovroc "tT]~nQo~ OCPfAO~ tT]~ "tUST]~nou EXfL "tT]VLbLox"tT]OLa"tCDV .t. tT]~ fQya(JLa~ xm toll XatarLfQLOrLOVtT]~. ( us Av xa80QLO"tfL T] LOtoQLX~ rLE80bO~ CD~YfVf"tLX~ rLE80bO~ fS~YT]OT]~OQWrLEVCDV XOLVCDVLXWVpmV0rLEVCDV (JXE(JT]us c Of o. 0 WtoQLXO~ xaQax"t~Qa~ toll mo8T]tov X00rL0ll xa80QLsftm core toy MaQs CD~fS~~· XU8f WtoQLXO nQo·Lov etvru «anotEAWrLa "tT]~bQaO"tT]QLOtT]"ta~LLa~ r OMXAT]QT]~OfLQU~cno YfVLE~. Ms rnv LOtOQLX~ rLE80bO YLVftaL (JacpE~ OtL 0 aL08T]to~ XO(JrLO~ fLvm ta1JtOXQova xm nQoYov tT]~ LOtoQLX~~fSEALST]~. It..TA opmMA EPfA Tor rIA THN KPITIKH Tor AJ.nQouno8EtfL rnv LOtoQLX~nQoonnx~ [221.H nQoOJttLX~ a1Jt~ fxcpQUSftm aQXLXUue tnv XQLtLX~ tT]~ 8QT](JXflltLX~~ nL(JtT]~xm tT]~ rLftacpll<JLX~~rLf80bOll. fLvm 0 nQaYrLatLxO~ XO(JrLO~. AOO'l'EI). KPATon 95 VCDVLOAOYLa. [ H XOLVCDVLX~ XQLtLX~.ME00aOAOf. «no tOY (JXT]rLatLOrLO tCDVbLacpOQCDV XOLVCDVLXWV xatT]YOQLWV xa8w~ xm coto tL~ avtL8E(JfL~ nou ovcorrocoovuu rLftasv toix. tT]~ fmXOLVCDVLa~ rLftasv tCDVav8QwnCDV. H LOtoQLa bdXVfL on o XO(JrLO~tCDVmo8~(JfCDV..
£Lvm l'] «Jtv£'ll!latLxi] ouotc» tl']e.. [25l.8w!loue. £m8Wl']ti] xrn £mj3£j3Al']!lEVl'] l'] OLati]Ql']Ol'] tl']e. rnv £VVO£L0 MaQs. toy LOtoQLO!lO.96 AYrOYl:rOl: MIlArIONAl: !lEOWV JtaQaywyi]e. OLacpOQOJtOL£Ltm O£ tUS£Le. Kotvovr«. LOtoQLxi]e. to YQaJttO Oero OLxmo JtQEJt£Lva JtQooaQ!lOOt£L OtO £8L!lLXO. OtL to LOW. To xQUtoe. xoworvtce. £JtavaOtatLxi]e. avaJttUOO£L tnv LO£OAoYLaJtwe. «vosrroooetru xatu tQoJto OAOXAT]QW!lEVOorov l'] «xowomro». dvm !l'lll']!lEV£e. tou £SEALsl']e. EQX£tm O£ ovtt8wT] ue toy LOtoQLO!lO. LOtoQLXO qxuvousvo YLa vc 8£!l£ALW8i] l'] xQLtLxi] tou.LOLWe. xm orov £!lcpaVL~£tm l'] ato!lLxi] LOWXtT]OLanov !lEOWV JtaQaywyi]e. tl']e. MLu JtaQuoool'] non £m~£L JtQEJt£L va owtT]Ql']8£L 000 . Etvo. [261. XaQaXtT]QLOtLXO tou LOtoQLO!lOU £Lvm on aQvdtm rnv avayxmotT]ta xm tOY EAAOYOxaQaxti]Qa tl']e. LOtoQLxi]e.i] T] £motQocpi] 0' cutnv.». «aOtLxi]e.. orov von Hugo [27l.. H totoQLXi] 8£wQl']0i] tou. To xQUtoe. JtQO'UJt08EO£Le. 0 MaQs avacpEQEtm LOLWe. !l£taj3oAi]e. [24l. tou. H YQacp£LoxQanxi] L£QaQXLa 8£!l£ALWVEtm JtUVW ornv JtLOtl'] on OL avwt£Q£e. oJtwe. H 8EOl'] tou LOtoQLO!lOU dvm l'] oxoAO'll8l']. Ano roix £xJtQoowJtO'lle. orov JtaLQv£L tn !loQCPi]tl']e. ue tnv JtaQaJtuvw onucotc tou ooou. j3a8!lLO£e. XOLvwvLxi]e. we. Ii.. xowcovtox. toy evvoouoe l'] LOtoQLXi] oxoA'ij rou OLXaLO'll. Hvm avayxaLo vc 8£wQl']8£L to xQUtoe. dvm ouvato va JtaQa!l£QLOt£L !lOVO ue rnv avaouv8wT] tl']e.' auto. YLa vo YLV£LoacpEe. O£ !l£yaAul£Qo (3a8!l0 ornv «ouoto» auti] uno 000 £Lvm OLXaTWt£Q£e. 0 MaQs aJtooacpl']vL~£L ne. tl']e. H !l£tacp'llOLxi] i] !l'llOnXLOnxi] 8£wQl']0l'] rou XQUto'lle. 8£wQT]nXEe. Ol']Aaoi] iuo XOLVWVLXi] oxornt« XWQLe.. !lEOa uno touc YQacp£LoxQatLX01Je. evrcooerca ornv XOLVWVLXi] LOtoQLa xm aJtot£A£L «onY!li]» tl']e. M£ rnv LOtOQLXi] £si]yl']Ol'] rou xQUtO'lle.oacpi] OLaOtQW!lutWOT]. xa80QL~£tm l'] 0XEOl'] rou ue xu8£ «OtLY!li]» tl']e. JtaQuOOOl']e. oJtwe..OtL aJtot£Ad LO£OAOYLXO £JtOLxoM!lT]!la tl']e. £SEALSl']e. LOtoQLae.
H XQLtLxi] rou aOtLxOU XQutO'll£ uno t'Y]V JtQOOJttLXi] tT]£ toto- .iJt08EtH LOtOQLXi] [!E8obO£ XaL T] xQLtLxi] ti]OO'll[!E onoto ObT]YEL Av 'llL08E- tou LOtoQLO[!O'IJ. H a[!cpLO~i]tT]O'Y] tCUV bUVatOti]tCUv LOtOQLO[!6 toy rn oaQu X'llbaLa. 'llJt60taoT]£. i] EOtCU uerorpu- OLXi]£. 8a xataAi]s0'll[!E [!OvaQXLa. EQXEtaL OE aJt6AutT] aVtL8EOT] [!E t'Y]V LOtoQL- xi] [!E80bO XaL [!E tT]V LOtOQLXi] xQLtLxi]. tou «no tOY [!E rnv cu£ OXEJttLXLO[!6. [!'llOtLXLOtLXi] avtLAT]'\j!T] 6tL uin OQW[!EVT]. tT]V JtQOOJttLXi] nou JtQOi. T] JtQooJtu8aa XaL OE [!La OQLO[!EVT] XQOVLXi] JtEQLObO. '000 mo UAOYT] qxuvetot. 6Jtcu£ toy evvost XaL tOY xQLva JtQwL[!a EQya rou. H O'llAAOYLOtLXi] aAi]8aa.EVO dVaL «JtQay[!atLvc [!Eta~AT]8d 6.iJt08Eta 6tL OL LOtOQLXE£ JtT]YE£ ELVaL LEQU XEL[!EVa nou auti] oto EXCPQUSouv tT]V «ES aJtoxaAU'\j!Ecu£» H aAi]8aa 0 MaQs bEV !J.tL ELVaL LOtoQLX6 bEbO[!EaLti][!ata LOtoQLO[!OU VO EXCPQUSEL «a'll8aLQEta» rc XaL «EscuJtQay[!atLxu» rou «acpT]QT][!EVO'll AOYLXOU». H LOtOQLXi] 8EWQT]0T] rou aotLxou ELVaL JtQoi. xo». tT]£ bdxva AOYLXOU t600 JtOAU dVaL uSLa OE~aO[!OU YLatL T] aAoYLa XataOXEUaO[!a ObT]YEL orov bLXaLWVa MaQs. 0 OXEJttLXLO[!6£ tou [!La [!oQCPi] 8EtLXLO[!OU. Acpou 6.X.JtoQd va xQL8EL uno to «acpT]QT][!EVO AOYLX6». T] aJt6A'lltT] i] T] ouvtay[!atLxi] tOY tQ6Jto non xi] uJtaQsT]£ [!La£ avaAAOLCUtT]£ 8E'Cxi]£. tou JtQoi. Jt.MEBO~OAOf. XQLtL- roue.tL dVaL LOtoQLXU bEbO!J. LOtOQLO[!6£ aQvdtaL Auro O'll[!~aLVa YLatL 0 T] OtT] tOY EAAOYO xaQaxti]Qa OtT]V XaL tT]V avayxaL6- rnr« tCUV XOLVCUVLXWV [!EtaOXT][!atLO[!WV. dVaL XU8E tL nou. o LOtOQLO[!6£. AIIO'l'EI~ TOY MAP2 ~TA I1PnIMA EPfA TOY rIA THN KPITIKH TOY A~T.iJt68wl'] YLa rnv 8ECUQT]tLXi] XaL JtQaxtLxi] tou bEV VOELtaL XCUQL£tT]V uQVT]OT]ton LOtoQLO[!OU [28]. 600 XaL av ELVaL UAOYO i] avi]8Lxo. 6tL bEV rou «acpT]Q'Y][!EVO'll AOYLXOU». KPATOY~ 97 mo YLVEtaL mo dVaL tExvT]t6 avaAAoLcutT]. 0 8EtLXLO[!6£ bLXaLWVa ouvrn- QT]tLo[!6. LOtoQLXi] [!oQCPi] xQuE[!cpavLsa xQuto'll£. uno uJtO'\j!T] ton 8a nrcv ouvcro va xaQaxtT]QLOtd «IIQay[!atLx6» nou dVaL LOtOQLXU bEbOi] [!UAAOV EJtELbi] tOY [!EVO OE Eva OQLO[!EVO reno ELVaL UAOYO XaL avi]8Lxo.
JtEQL6ClO'll mi]e.. OtOxaO[!Oe. ME tnv YEQ[!aVLxi] xm LClLWe. 01'][!ELO'll aJtooaqJ1']VLSH tLe. ClLXaLO'll a tlje. rnv tasLxi] ClLaQ8QwOlj xm tnv LClEOAoyLa.. rou XEYXEA [29]. [!E qJLAOOOqJLae. 2:toV ~a8[!6 t r 6[!we.W"COQEOav JtaQO'llV O'llYXEXQL[!EV1'] va nooxuxi] [!OQqJi] YLa OLaqJOQO'lle. O'llf. EXAOYLXE'lJ[!EV1'] [!OQqJi]. xm rnv atEAEOqJOQ1']aOlj YLa rnv 'llJtEQVLX1']Oi] oix. taOELe.avnqJaOELe. XEyxEAELavi] qJLAOOOqJLa XqJQaSEtm o. OL LClW[!OQqJLEe. 1']aVEJtaQxi]e. vc H YEQ[!aVLxi] qJLAOOOqJLa aJtooaqJljVLSEL.W"CA1']QQNEtm t1']V XQLtLXi] tou cno t1']V JtQOOJttLXi] t1']e. xOLVWVLae. rou.W"COQEL ELvm 1']YEQ[!aVLxi] xowovtc.JtaQaywyi]e. AELto'llQYEL avnqJanxa. roix ClLVEL ESWJtQay[!anxi] EXqJQaOlj xm tLe. Tam6XQova 6[!we. xm ELClLX6tEQaOE OXEOlj [!E to YEyov6e..tasLxi]e. qJLAOOOqJLae. [!La 8EWQ1']tLXi] EXAOYLXE'lJ[!EV1'] EXqJQa01']WV taOEWV nou 8a OO1']youoav OE iuo XOLVWVLXi] ustct ~OAi] aAAa rtou OEV f. to YEyovoe. xm tlje. qJLAOOOqJLae. xru LClLWe. TEtOLOL MyOL f. Myo'lle. qJLAOOOqJLX6e. svo.W"COQEL dvm vo 1']Xa8'llOtEQ1']01'] otnv avaJtt'lls1'] t1']e. 0XEOELe. aJtooaqJljVLSEL uovo ornv JtEQwxi] tou xa8aQou Myo'll. ESljvotrvto.98 AYron:rm: MIlArJONAl: QLW.. non tLe..tExVLxi]e. taQaywyi]e.1']e. nou ELvm Clwato va OCl1']yi]OOW oto sEJtEQaO[!a toix.0 qJLAOOOqJLXOe. JtOALtLxi]e. xOLVWVLae. OQW[!EVEe. rou ClExatO'll ovooo» xm nov aQXwv tou ClEXatO'll evcro» cuovo. O'llYXExQL[!EVa WtOQLXa i] XOLVWVLXaqxnvouevo. xm ne. xm aOqJaAWe. [!JtOQEL vc 8EWQ1']8d we.2:E 0XE01'] [!E OQW[!EVa «no tc aLuc ama. 'EtOL 0 YEQ[!aVLX6e.EQyaoLae. O'llyxaAUJttEL .O'llvBi]XEe. YEQ[!aVLXOU qJLAOOOqJLXOU ton oroxcO[!OU tlje. avaJtt'lls1'] t1']e. Keno coto OQW[!EVEe. [!OQqJEe. cero t1'] [!La [!EQLa xru ot«. on ClEVavantuX81']XE OE [!EyaAO ~a8[!6 1']avtLqJa01'] one. ou lj aOtLxi] tas1'] OEV xat6Q8woE va xataxti]oEL tOY «ljYE[!OVLX6» Q6AO orn YEQ[!aVLxi] XOLVWVLa tou tEAO'lle. oxouoto. xm mv t ESEALSljtWV [!EOWV JtaQaywyi]e.. t1']e. MEXQLe. OXEJ OELe. YEQ!LaVLxi]e. ClLVOVtae.otoxao[!6e. tou xa8we.n tnv E tdvEL vc ELvm aAAa ClEVf.YEQ[!aVLxi]e. uno t1']V aAAlj i]lj ovnqxion aVa[!EOa oru. nvtupnOELe. ne. owdo1']o1']e. O'llyxaAUJttEL we.tlje.
tou.L{J)tWV». tou H <jlLAOOO<jlLXi] XQLtLXi] C.taLvfL 6tL us tn CPLAOOOCPLXi] xQLtLxi] naQa[.n[.LaL tfQa tou XfYXfALaVLO[.ta'tonOL£Ltrn us tnv fsi]ynoi] roix.tnVfU6tav [. 6n{J)~ ou[.0taOn~ nQaY[.nou fLVaL avayxaLOL XaL maQX£L£ yw v« un6. 'EtOL «noocrpnvt~ftaL n 0XEOn xQ6.IL6 6. 6tL to XQ6. c.tft6. H <jlLAOOO<jlLXi] XQLtLXi] EXfL OUYXfXQL[. (J)~ 8f·LXi]~ i] [.tEAAOV [311.tOQ<jlWV aA. nou XQLVfL.t[.t£OOEQYOi] I XaL xa8i]xov tn£ CPLAOOO<jlLXi]~ tLXi]~ £LVaL n Esi]ynon tn~ XQL nOALtLXi]~ aA. fsnY£L tn [. orn [. ornv «unnQ£OLa tn£ LOtoQLa~» [33l. KPATon 99 H av6.v XataAi]sfL orn OUOxEtLOntn~ WtOQLXi]~ XaL XOLV{J)VLXi]~xat6.tLa~ LOtoQLXi]~ XaL XOLV{J)VLXi]~ xat6. non fsnY£L tOY x60[.8f u nou un6.tatonoiettrn n «c.otQL{J)On£. t{J)V LC.QXfL» [30l.toUVLO[. Meoo uno rnv XQLtLXi] [.0taOn~.O~ 8(LXi]£ naQouoLa£ i] [.tfQL~£taL n 8fWQnOn tou xQ6.yxn va unfQxL Vn8fL n avtL<jlaOn auti] tn~ xAaOLxi]~ YfQ!WVLXi]~ <jlLAOOO<jlLa~.tfta<jlUOLxi]~ un60taon£.ta.A. ern .OtQL{J)On~ nQaY[. ou n fQ[.A.OU~aAAOtQL{J)On£[32l. H <jlLAOOOCPLXi] XQLtLXi] fLVaL. ue Eva xovovo i] Eva nQ6tuno non va 8f{J)QfLtaL (J)~ an6Auta EYXUQO. AllO'l'EI~ TOY MAPS ~TA llP(llMA EPrA TOY rIA THN KPITlKH TOY A~T.tOU~ XaL «xorvcovtu.tLOuQYLa VEOU».fV 8a fxnAnQWOfL rnv XOLV{J)VLXi] XaL LOtoQLXi] AfLtouQYLa tn~ 6.tfta<jlUOLxi]£ un60taon~. H <jlLAOOO<jlLXi] XQLtLXi] avacpEQftaL oro «nnQ6v» XaL 6XL 01'0 «[.8f fLC.LatUn{J)On auti] On[.tOU.OtQL{J)On~.~aon uno tn [.t0. H c.tUOtLXWtLX6.toQCPi]OU <jlLAOOO<jlLXOU t oroxcouou.tEVn XOLV{J)VLXi] fLtouQYLa XaL XOLV{J)VLX6 A oxono. n nou un6XfLtaL Of fXAOYLXfUOn.nAac.toQ<jli] tOU <jlLAOOOCPLXOU otoxao[.t~aLVfL us toy «qxrvtormxo XO[. H <jlLAOOO<jlLXi] XQLtLxi] t{J)V c. ou ouvtotnrm 01'0 ouvaL08n[.tOQ<jlE£ autE£ aA. a6Qwta XaL tautoAoYLx6.t6» tou Cabet i] rou Weitling..MEBoaOAor.tatonoLfL 6Af~ tL~ ava~nti]ofL~ ton av8Qwnou.t£LALXto roon» X6.AfL\jJn X6. nou «XQLVfL ue tOY JtLOa[. n onoto txovonOL£LXaL nQaY[.t6 t{J)V XOLV{J)VLXWV XaL LOtoQLXWV6Q{J)v. XaL Lc.[.La<jl6Q{J)v [. xat6.Qsouv OL [.A. tOY MaQs.toix.i] ue tOY xa80QLO[. Lxon6£ tn~ nQEJt£Lva fLVaL n fs6.to~ £LVaLEva £LC.
H CPLAOOOCPLX~ xQmx~ ue tL~ !lOQCPE~ 'UtE~ tT]~ XQL a tLX~~ uovo otov ~a8!l6 non xa80QL~H tL~ xatT]YOQLf~ YLa !lLa YfVftLX~ fS~YT]OT]ou xQatou~. ou H 8EOT]tou XaTa T] CPLAOOOCPLX~ xQmx~ tT]V mavaOtatLx~ nQaST]. x n08E'tEL. ou EXH tTl n !lOQCP~!lLa~ OAOXAT]QU)!lEVT]~ 8fU)QT]tLX~~ XaTaOXfU~~ xm non ue to oixrrnu« tou XEYXfA.E c1JLAoaocp{arov LlLXa{OV rov XtYXfA. mo YfVLxa !lLa tT]V xaTfu8VVfL ennvuMe tT]V xm taut6XQova nQasT] naQa!lfQL~ftm T] CPLAooocpLa. t Av bfV un~QXf OtT]V nQWL!lT] !laQsWtLX~ xQmx~ nOLT]!lEVOUxQatoU~ T] WtoQLX~ nQoomLX~. Kern tT]V nQWL!lT] cpaOT]rou MaQs oev avamVOOftm T] ano'tjJT] 6tL T] maVaOtatLx~ va fLvm naLQVH tTl 8EOT]tT]~ CPLAOOOCPLX~~ xQmx~~. xaQaxt~Qa~ ea ~tav buvat6 8f!lfALWVH nQoli- AOYLXa tT]V 0 WtoQLx6~ vo OQWtfL U)~ «fQyaAELO» ~ OVOLT]!la XatT]YOQLWVue to onOLO anooacpT]vU.'ftm nQo"C6v tT]~ WtoQLX~~ £1. 8a bLECPfQfcoto tT]V xQmx~ !lLa~ OtanxiJ~ tou xQatou~ ton xQatou~ coto toy ~tLQVfQ xm nou 8f!lfALWVftm T]xQmx~ non rou !lu80a'Ut~ bfV cvcornxroetm navU) OtL~ xatT]YOQLf~ av8QU)nOAOYLa~ [34]. Me tTl CPLAOOOCPLX~ xQmx~ 8f!lfALWVftm T] !lE80bO~ ue tT]V ouv6Eftm onoto nQaY!latonOLEL tm T] XQL tLX~ tT]~ 8QT]OXfUOtLX~~ nLOtT]~ xru T] XOL Vu)VLX~ xQmx~. nQOfX'tELVH xm taut6XQova WtoQLX~ xQmx~. H nQWL!lT] !laQswnx~ non YLVftm uno toy 8fU)QLa YLa to xQato~ bfV 8a bLECPfQfmLOT]~ coto tT]V xQmx~ Henri de Saint-Simon !If avacpoQa Of XOLVu)VLOAOYLXE~ xatT]YOQLf~ [35]. aVfsaQtT]ta tou !lU80nOLT]!lEVOU xQatou~ OtoxaO!lOV YLVfrou coto tT]V WtoQLX~ 8fWQT]O~ rou.roo AYron:Tm: MIlArIONA. rtou tT]V nQaST] OAOXAT]QWVfL. Aev naVH 6!lU)~ vu . An6 mW'tT]!lOAOYLX'tl anO'ljJT] T] cpLAOOOqlLX~Qmx~ .EALsT]~ xm fSfAWo6!lfVO tou xQatou~. rtou ocpfLAftm oro Yfyov6~ 6tL ELvm qxuvouevo. tTl cpaOT]a'Ut~ cpaLvftm nQolin08EtH mavaOta'tLx~ fXCPQa~ftm Ota'tLx~ xcrcorcon. H rut CPLAOOOCPLX~ xQmx~ nQaY!latLx6tT]ta ue tT]V mavaotanx~ nQaST].
'Ioox.ono».H ESUQtT]OT] aUt~ toU XUQLOU uno toy ()OUAOEST]yEL tal cno to YEYOVO~ on 0 XUQLO~XQ'Y]OLrLOnOLEL ()OUAO toy W~ EQyaAELo. Ano rn OtLYrL~rtou OUVtEAELtaLT]avayvwQWT] aUt~ o XUQLO~aJtEAEu8EQWVEtaL osto tT]V 'ljJEU()aL08T]oT] rrutovotT]~ rLLa~ rou. H tUST] aut~ EXEL«xa80ALXo» xaQaXt~Qa YLatL ()EV EXELxovevu L()LaL tEQO ()LXaLWrLavu nQootatbjJEL aepou EXELanootEQT]8EL «no OAa tn ()LXaLWrLatUtT]~. 0 MaQS avaepEQE0 tal oro nQwLrLa XELrLEVcX xcXnw~ UnaLVLXnXcX otu.'EtOL XataVaALOXEL XaL anOAarL~UVELXWQL~vo EQycX~EtaL.tTl ()La()LXaoto rLEtT]V oncto nQaYrLatonOLELtaL T]aJtEAEu8EQWOT] aut~. 8a ~taV ()UVatO v« unotE8~ on nQaYrLatonOLELtal oUrLepwva rLE tT]V XEYYEALav~ ()LaAEXtLX~tou ()OUAOUXaL rou XUQLOU [37].H aJtEAEu8EQWOT] ou ()OUAOU EXepQcX~EtaL r rLEto YEYOVO~ OtL 0 XUQLO~tOY avaYVWQL~H W~ avayxaLo oUrLnMQWrLUrou.ou OnOL01JOL ErLJtELQLE~ t t XaL OLava~T]t~OEL~ EsaQtWvtaL uno tT]V EsOUOLan01J aoxEL nuvw orov ()OUAO. OXEOEL~ tou naQaywy~~ XaL n~ rLOQepE~ EQyaoLa~ nou nQouno8EtEL T] XEyxEAHav~ «xoivorvt« rcov L()LWtWV». H ES01JOLa rtou aOXEL 0 XUQLO~nuvw OtOV ()OUAOouvmuYEtaL XaL tT]V aAAOtQLWOT]ou XUQL01J. KPATOr~ 101 uncXQXH T] epLAOOOepLX~ tLX~. ano rn oxomn tOU .TautoXQova T] eaovootanx~ tUST] aQvELtaL rnv «xotvcivtc tWV L()LWtWV» [36]. AIIO'l'EI~ Tor MAP2~TA I1PnIMAEPfA Tor rIA THN KPITIKHTor A~T. epEQOVtaL OtT] (/)~Aoaocpia rov L1tJwiov tOU XEYXEA.ME rnv oro aJtEAEU8EQWO~ aJtEAEu8EQWVOVtaL tT]~ XaL OLUAAE~tUSEL~. 'EXELtT]V momELa rou OAOUYLatL ()EV ELVaLnQOOT]AWrLEVT] «rLEQO~». rnv EVVOEL XEYXEA. o MaQs ()EVanooaepT]VL~H oro Mo XELrLEVU nou cvorou. H tUST] aut~ OVOrLU~EtaL cero toy MaQS «EQyanx~ tUST]» ~ «nQoAEtaQLUtO». 0 MaQs toy rLEta8EtEL n~ avo): UOEL~ aUtE~ nou. Itc vo umxQSH T] mavaotanx~ nQcXsT]EL Val avayxaLo vc uncXQSEL rLLatcXST] on cvcorruooetm rLfOa coto rnv «xoivorvtu n tWV L()LWtWV». YVWQL~EL nQaWatLXO scuto rou. A vtL8Eta ()TjfHOUQYOUVtaLOL XQL nQouno8Eow. YLa vc avamux8EL.ME80aoAof.
BUOlX6 ELVaL 6n torooto rtov OE 0XEOT] !LE tT]V urtoot« Ano xaQaXtT]Qwtlx6 T] JtOAltELa OT]!LOXQatlXOU JtOAl tEU!Lato~ tT]V !LE tn uovoo- OEV «OT]!LLO'llQYEL» tOY «Au6».T]. O'llVUYEtaL tou OOUAO'll XaL rou X'llQLO'll».T]~. rtoi: avtWtolXEL tE'll!LUtWV !LE toy 8QT]OXHWV [39]. tT]~ EQyaoLa~ rcov EQyatWv XaL OtT]V aSLa tT]~ a!LOl~~~ XaL tT]~ EQyatlXl1~ OOT]YELOtT]V JtQcJH!La EQya Lta !LEtT]V OJtOLa ESaOcpaAL~EtaL T] O'llvtl1QT]O~ roix. tELVH vo tT]V rcuttoa !LEtoy rou XaL tam6XQova «Aa6» 11!LEtOY «011- !LO» [36]. Lowith. !LE tT]V «aOtlxl1 OtT]V EXCPQUOT] ou r EQXEtaL OE avtL8WT] tT]V EVVOOUOE 0 XEYXEA. 6Jtw~ EOHSE 0 K. Ot aJt6'4JH~ tou UVaAUOEl~ «JtUAT] tWV tUI:.T] !LEtOY «xa8oAlx6» tT]~ EQYUtlX~~ tUsT]~ o n T] amAE'll8EQWOT] tUST]~ O'llVmuYEtaL EX!LEtUAAE'llOT] aml1 XaL tT]V amAE'lJ8EQWOT] tT]~ aOtlxl1~ JtQaY!LatOJtOlEL tal coro avu!Lwa ceto tT]V EX!LEtUAAE'llOT] nou aOXEL JtUVW OtT]V EQYUtlXl1 tUI:. ornv tUI:. H a!LOl~aLa amAE'lJ8EQWOT] tT]~ aOtlxl1~ tUST]~ JtQOUJt08EtH JtQaY!LutwoT] tou 0 MaQs 8EtO'llV tou «O'llVU!LH» tT]~ XOlVWVLa~ XWQL~ tUSH~. JtQouJtOOQW!LEVE~ aVaAUOEl~ [38].EWV» JtQOEXtELVO'llV n~ AJt6 tl~ aVacpOQE~ rou MaQs XEYXEA Yla tTl «OlaAEXtlXl1 xaQaxt~Qu. XaL tT]~ O'llVHOT]OlaX~~ XaL tT]~ XOlVWVlX~~ E!LJtElQLa~. «OtOlXELO» aJtocpaOL~H XaL JtQUttH toJtOlT]8EL to aya86 6Xl W~ lOlWtT]~ aAAU W~ cpOQEa~ tT]~ ~OUAT]OT]~rou O'llV6AO'll !LE tOY oxono vc JtQaY!LaXOlVWVLa». Oi EVVOlE~ a'lltE~. Aaou JtOAltWV ono». PO'llOOW OtO Koiviovixo JtQWl!La EQya OtT]V OJtOLa to XU8E XV{l(36AUW 0 MaQs tl~ XQT]Ol!LOJtOlEL ow OE 0XEOT] !LE tT]V XOlVWVlXl1 oxornt«. o «Aa6~» tou XOlVWVlX01J O'llV6AO'll. H !LE tT]V OlXHOJtOLT]OT] tT]~ OlUCPOQU~ «no toy otnv aSLU rou JtQo'C6- vroc toix. OtT]V mQLOXl1 tT]~ ESEAll:. EcpaQ!L6~ovtaL WtoQlX~~ mv ron 'llJtOXH!LEVlXOU JtVEUYlU rou ucro . IIOAltlxl1 XQwnavw!L6 tou ELVaL T] 1)T]!LOXQatLa.102 srrorsros OtT] OcpaLQU MIlArIONAl: XEYXEA. UJtO'4JT]aml1 T] OT]!LOXQutLa EQXEtaL OE avtL8WT] .
MEeO~OAor.
AIIO'fEI~ TOY MAPE ~TA I1PQ]MA EPrA TOY rIA THN KPITIKH TOY A~T. KPATOY~ 103
XLa, omut; rnv OQLSEL XEYXEA orn c1JtAOaocp{a rov Aixaio». 0 Krrtu toy MaQs, 'll !lOvaQXLa b'll!lLOUQYEL JtMSot; JtOU «rmto QL6.SEL»orn bLat~Q'llO~ t'llt;. Otnv b'll!lLOUQYELtaL 'll atasLX~ XOLVWVLa,to b'll!lOXQanxo JtOALtEU!la ELVaLb'll!lLOUQY'll!la tou «Aaou» XaL 01JVELb'llt~ EX<pQaO'llt'llt; f30UA'll0~t; rou. ME tn b'll!lOXQatLa YLVEtaL Oa<jlEt;on to XQ6.tOt; ELVaLb'll!lLOUQY'll!la t'llt; xoworvtor; XaL OtL 'll xotvcovtu bEV dVaL b'll!lLOUQY'll!la tou XQ6.tout;, oJtwt;, ouuqxovo ue tnv EQ!l'llvda XaL rnv XQLtLX~ rou MaQs, bEXOtav 0 XEYXEA. H b'll!lOXQatLa aJtOOa<jl'llVLSEL rnv «OUOLa»,b'llAab~ rou; LOtOQLXOUt;, XOLVWVLXOUt; avSQwJtoXaL AOYLXOUt;oQOUt; t'llt; JtOAL tELax~t; t6.S'llt;, orto»; 0 XQLOtLaVLouo; EX<jlQ6.SEL «ouotc» t'llt; SQ'llOXEutLX~t;JtLOt'llt;. rnv ~ta JtQWL!la EQya tou 0 MaQs JtQoEXtd VEL tnv JtaQ6.bOO'll t'llt; as'llva'(x~t; b'll!lOXQatLat; XaL nov Iaxwf3Lvwv [40]. H YEVLX~ SEa'll rou ore EQya aut6. dVaL OtL !lEOa cno tnv LOtoQLX~ ESEALs'll bEV «xataQYELtal» to xQ6.tot; JtaQ6. !lOVO wt; SEXWQLOtot; <jloQEat; EsouOLat;, 0 OJtOLOt;Sa oQLsotav ELbOAOYLX6. XaL tou OJtOLOU0 tQoJtot; uJtaQs'llt; Sa JtaQouoLasE avaAoYLEt; ue toy toorto uJtaQs'llt; nov !lEta<jlUOLXWVuJtOOt6.0EWV. Av to xQ6.tOt; SEwQ'llSd wt; LOtoQLXO<jlaLVO!lEVO, LXaLOAOb YELtaL 'll bLaJtLOtW0'll OtL 'll coxnon t'll£ JtoAmX~t; EsouOLat; JtauEL f3aS!lLaLa va EXEL xatamEOnxo xaQaxt~Qa. H EsEALxnx~ auti) bLabLxaoLa bEV OUVtEAdtal O!lwt; ouuqxovc ue to EUSUYQa!l!l0 OX~!la t'llt; JtQOOboU. Otnv JtQaY!latoJtoL'llSd 'll «coteAEUSEQW0'll tou JtQoAEtaQL6.tou», 'll JtoAmx~ EsouoLa !lEtaf3L~asEtal otoix aQxo!lEVout; non EXtEAOUVtautOXQova XaL rn AELtOuQYLa tou «'llYE!lOva». H EsEALs'llaut~, rtou bEVJtQaY!latoJtOLdtaL JtOtE xat6. toone OAOXA'llQW!lEVO XaL OQLOtLXO,EX<jlQ6.SEtal ue toy 0X'll!lano!lo tou b'll!lOxQatLxou JtOAL tEU!latOt;. To JtOAL tE1J!la auto !lJtoQd va SEWQ'llSEL 'll JtoAmx~ EX<jlQa0'll w£ non taLQL6.SEL orov 6.vSQwJto orov JtauEL va dVaL «LbLWt'll£» ~ «ocro;» XaL !lEtaf36.AAEtaLOEXOLVWVLXOJtOL'll!lEVO ov.
