( /

,

. )

( ,

) , .

.

(

), , . , ( ) , . , , , , . . , . 1968, , . Harvard 1968 . . ( ),

1 

« . ,
 

» , . ( ( , ( , ), , . , . , , , , , « . , ), ),

2

», . ( , , . ) ,

.

(

) .

, 

(

)

. ( ) 1968. , Coma , '60, , Ciba Foundation :« »(1). 20 , . , . , , 15 1966

Depasse,

3

, , . 1967 Christian Barnard . Life, Time, Newsweek . Marius 

. , . , 1968, Harvard , . ( ) . Harvard :« , Harvard ». Harvard . , , J 1968 (2). , Mita Giacomini, 1997 Social Science and Medicine(3). : 1. , ,

,

,

4 

. 2. . 3. 4. . 5. . ( )

. 6. ( . 7. ( ), ( ). Mita Giacomini « ( ) . , , ( ). ( ) ». , , ( , , . Truog, ) , : )

5 

2003 Truog: «

Harvard, Critical Care Medicine(4)· ( ) . ( . )

,

( ; , ,

)

. , , . ( ( ) ) , &|au; , ». . Ohio State 1997 ( ) , , .

6

University Taylor, Seminars in Neurology(5) ,

(

) , (6). 

« ( . Harvard :« ad hoc ( , , , . .« ( ). )»(2). )

( ) » (7).

.

Harvard

.

» (8). . . ; ( ) , « « », « » ». ; ( ) . , , , . ( ) , ,

7 

, , . . , . , -

, , ( . ( , ) , . ( ) . , (9) 1981 , )

,

Uniform determination of death act « ( ( ) , . ,

) ». ,

8

(

), ( . , , )

(

), . , 

, . Anaesthesia 2004 (10) Addenbrookes Cambridge , . (11) , Anaesthesia -

, ,

9
.

, « , ». , , ( .« ( « », « », « reqviem )», « ( ) », « ( )», ) 

(

).

». ( ). Alan Shewmon . 60

:« » (12). 200 Shewmon ( , (

) . )

. , « 123 » (13) : «... ,

10

, ». ( ) UCLA Los

Angeles Alan Shewmon 1998 Neurology (14). 70 :« , , ,

Shewmon

, , , 

, . , .

,

. ( ) editorial , , « « » (15). ( ) Shewman , .

11

, ( ) ». Shewman , : , . , . . , , . 

-

(16). 13 , .

. ( : ; , )

-

. , . , , , . , . , . . , ( , ) . ( ),

12 

(17). . 1997, , Meisner, StatementAllgemeine Zeitung (25 « ( ) 1997) ,

(

)

, -Offisial Frankfurter : ». ,

.

5-20 , , . , , , . ,

13

.

. , . , , , 

. . « ». : ; , , , . », « » . « (13), , . . , , . , , , ». . . 55 , :« . . 68 ( ) » ,

« «

»,

14 

. 25 ( ) :« . ( ) ». , , ( , ; , ) . , , 12

; 13 :« , , . . . , , . ».

15

, , 

, . ; , ;

.

,

« «...

; : ». . :«

, , »;

16
. «... ...» , . , , , . : «... ' ' . ' , , , , , ' , ' ' , , 

...»(18) , , , : «... , , , ,

: «... , ' ..» (19). .

, . «.. , ( , ), , , ...» (20). ,

,

' . . , ( ), . , ; . : «... , , , , ...» (21). ' ' : ' , ' , ' , -

17

, , '

,

«... 

' , ,

, . . . ' , , , , , ' , ' , , ' , ' , . , ' , '

, ·

.

' · . .

18

, ...»(22) , : «... ,

...» (23). : «... ... ...» (24). , , , 

, , , . . , Jung . Undiscovered Self «... ' , ...». , , ...» , », , . , , . , , « , , . , . . , , », . « «... , The :

19

(25). ( ),

' 

. , . : «... , ...» (26). «... ...» (27). «... ...» , .

. , , . ,

20

. , . ; , ; , , ; , 

, .

, . , . , , (5-7- 1998), : «... , ... , , ...». . Breck), « , : « ... , , , . . , . , , . , » « , . » , (John

21 

. , ...» (28). , , . , ; ( , ' ( ), , ' ) . ( . , , ( , ) . ) '

22

.

,

, , . « , , . 2004, Medicine,

, ,

» , Intensive Care 

( ), Harvard.

'

(

) ( ( ) » , ).

«

(29). . , 2003, ( ) ( », 10 : «... , , , ( ) , . ...». . 273 , : «... ), 24 « 25 ( ) . ,

23

. , ( ), ... , . 

(

)

,

' .

(

); ( )

;

;

, . , , , , ; , . , , . , . Potts Journal of Medical Ethics , Evans, 2005 (30), , ,

24

. ( ) ( ) 

.

. , , , ,

.

, , ,

,

.

, , : «... ,

25

.

...». : «... , , , ...» (31). . , 

,

. .

, , ( ) . , 1991 New Jersey , , ( ) , , . ,

26

, . ( ) ad hoc Harvard, ( , .
: 1. Ciba foundation symposium. 1966. Ethics in medical progress: with special reference to transplantations. 2. A definition of irreversible coma: Report of the ad hoc committee

) , 

of the Harvard medical school to examine the definition of Brain death. JAMA 205: 85-88, 1968. 3. Mita Giacomini: A change of heart and a change of mind? Technology and the redefinition of death in 1968. Soc. Sci. Med., 33: 1465-82, 1997. 4. Truog R. D., Robinson W.M. Role of Brain death and the deaddonor rule in the ethics of transplantation. Crit. Care Med. 31: 2391-6, 2003. 5.Taylor Robert. Re-examining the definition and criteria of death. Seminars in neurology 17: 265-70, 1997. 6. Raper Pf, Fisher M.M. Brain death and organ donation. A point of view. Anaesth. Intens. Care. 23: 16-19, 1995. 7. Hill David. Honesty is best policy. Letter BMJ 325: 836, 2002. 8. Power B.M.,Van Heerden V. The physiological changes associated with brain death. Current concepts and Implications for treatment of the brain death organ donor. Anaesth. Intens. Care 23: 26-36, 1995. 9. President's Commission for the study of ethical problems in medicine and biomedical and behavioural research, Defining death. Medical, ethical and legal issues in the determination of death. Washington D.C., U.S. Government printing office, 1981. 10. Young P.J., Matta B.F. Anaesthesia for organ donation in the brainstem dead. Why bother? (Editorial Anaesthesia 55: 05-106, 2000. 11.Anaesthesia for organ donation in the brainstem dead. (Correspondence). Anaesthesia 55: 590, 2000. 12. Shewmon Alan. Recoverv from "brain death". A Neurologist' s apologia. Linacre quarterly, 30-95, Febr. 1977. 13 .« » . 2001. 14. Shewmon Alan. Chronic "Brain death". Meta-Analysis and conceptual consequences. Neurology 51: 1538 -1545, 1998. 15.Cranford Ronald. Even the death are not terminally III anymore. (Editorial) Neurology 51: 1530-31, 1998. 16. Powner D.J., Bernstein I.M. Extended somatic support for pregnant women after brain death. Crit. Care Med. 31: 1241-9, 2003. 17. Hershenov D. The problematic role of "Irreversibility" in the definition of death. Bioethics 17: 89-100, 2003. 18. , . , ., .

27 

.« 19. 20. 21. 22. .« 23. 24. 1995, 25.

»,

.

»,

', . ., , , . ', , ,

. 143, ' . , ' . . 124, 5,

. '. . 146, . . 1, . 481 . 156. . . 12-19. . 110.

'. .« '. , , ».

,

. 164. ,

, . ', . ': , ' PG 37, 453-54. 26. , . , , . « », . ' . 42, . '. 27. , , G 46, 29. 28. . (John Breck). , .1998. 29. Zamperetti N., Bellomor et Als. Irreversible apnoeic coma 35 years later. To more rigorous definition of brain death? Intensive Care Med. 30: 1715-22, 2004 30. Potts M., Evans D.N. Does it matter that organ donors are not dead? Ethical and policy implications. J. Med. ethics 31: 406- 409, 2005. 31. . . 51: 319-326, 1985. 32. Olick R.S. Brain death, religious freedom and public policy: New Jersey' s landmark Legislative initiative. Kennedy Inst. Ezthics J. 1:275-92, 1991.

28