, ; " " ; " ; " "; "; .
" . " ' '
" ' ' , , '. ' ' , . ." . , , UCLA ( ), Dr. Alan Shewmon.1 " , , , '
1
", . 2001, 1999, 1999, 1995, (R.D.
( . . 1998, . 1999, . . 1995, . . 1999, . 1999, A. . 1999, . 1999, . .) Truog 1992, D.A.Shewmon 1997, R.M. Taylor 1997, . .), " "
" ".2 " O ' ' ", Harvard . . . Dr. Robert D.
Truog " . ( A Jersey ) ."3
,
New , " ".4
Ohio, Dr. Robert M. Taylor
" (the process of dying) (the process of disintegration)" ".5 A 6.
"
2
,
. " " , . , , " ' . ."8 , , " , , " ". 9 Dr. Alan Shewmon, ", " ( ) " " ' , " '
, "
." 7 "
,
' .
"
."10 "
1967 , . 11 ' hoc " , (sic) ) ' ."12 Mita Giacomini, ad hoc . " ' ' . , ' '. ' ' , , Harvard, ' , , , 1968 : ad Harvard o "E " ) .
3
. .) ."13 , (Taylor 1997, Truog 1997, Raper & Fisher 1995,14 " " ('harvesting') " 1. " " " ."15 " ( 1981 " , : ) , ) , .16 1971 Minnesota, " ("uniform determination") , 1968, " ), Harvard . "
Mohandas " "
Chou .17 Minnesota", , 1981.18 . . . . ( " " , 1996 ", " "
" 1971,
) ", " ("uniform") 2
. 19 " "
( ."20 2. " -
)
",
"
."21 ' " ' ."22 3. " , .23 O Truog (1992), Shewmon (1998), K " " 36 6 6 17 " ". ," ' ."24 , . " " 1989 42% 25% , ."25 1999 39% , " '
,
4
2
(2001)
' 4.
"
"
, " "
.26 " , " .27 5. , "
, Mayo Clinic ( , , "
),
E. Wijdicks, 93 " 22%
' " " , , ( 6. . . . ) . 28 ",
'
, ,
9/20-3-1985
" , "29. , " " .30 7. Sign", , Plum . 8. " , " , "; 32 " , , " (semi-directed) " , " "; Fred (semi-purposeful) ' ' "31 "Lazarus " 1996
5
" .
"
" " 2002 1 Shewmon DA. "Brainstem Death", "Brain Death" and Death: A Critical Re evaluation of the Purported Equivalence. Issues in Law and Medicine , 1998, Vol 14, No 2. 2 ibid & Truog RD. Is it time to abandon brain death? Hastings Cent Rep (United States), 1997. 3 ibid 4 Olick RS. Brain Death, Religious Freedom, and Public Policy New Jersey's Landmark Legislative Initiative, KENNEDY INST , ETHICS J, 1 991. 5 Taylor RM. Reexamining the definition and criteria of death. Sem Neurol 1997, Vol. 17, No 3. 6 Bernat JL. The definition, criterion and statute of death. Sem Neurol 1984: 4. 7 . . , 8, 17, 1998. 8 , 'Nemecis', 2001. 9 ." " ; University Studio Press, ' 2001, .107. 10 1 11 7 12 A definition of irreversible coma. Report of the ad hoc committee of the Harvard Medical School to examine the definition of brain death. JAMA 1968, 205 : 85 -88. 13 Giacomini M. A Change of Heart and a Change of Mind? Technology and the Redefinition of Death in 1968. Soc SciMed 1997, Vol 44, No 10 : 1465 -1482 14 Raper RF, Fisher MN. Brain Death and Organ Transplantation. A point of view. Anaesth. Intens.Care 1995. 23:16 -19 15 ." " ; University Studio Press, ' 2001, .92. 16 ibid . 90, 18. 17 Mohandas A, Chou SN. Brain death. A clinical and pathological study. J Neurosurg 1971 35: 211 -218 18 7&8 19 . , 1995. 20 15 21 ., , , . et al., 'E ' 12/9/99 22 ibid 23 Truog RD, Fackler JC. Rethinking brain death. Crit Care Med 1992, 20. 24 1 25 , . ; 1999, 76: 3 26 Van Norman G. Can Brain Death Testing Be Perfect? Anesth 2000, Vol.92., No 4. 27 Wijdicks EFM, Rochester MN, Bernat JL, Lebanon NH. Letter to t he Editor. Neurol 1999, 53 28 , , , et al. 10/10/1999 & A . ( ), , , 2000, 14. 29 9, . 74 30 Machado C, Garcia OD , Roman JM, Parets JM. Four years after the "First International Symposium on Brain Death" in Havana: could a definitive conceptual re approach be expected? In: Brain Death. Developments in Neurology 9 , Amsterdam 1995. 31 Plum F. Clinical standards and technological confirmatory tests in diagnosing brain death. In : The definition of death. Contemporary controversies. Youngner SJ,
6
Arnold Rm, Schapiro R, Eds, The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore and London, 1999, . 34-65. 32 19 & . , , 2002 & , , ' , , . , 2001, . . 96.
. . ,« », , . 2003 . 2003. (http://www.orthros.org/Greek/Keimena/StefStefEkklMetamsx.htm). 2. ,« . . µ ¶ », , . 2003 . 2003. 3. ., " µ ¶ ± ;», , Univ. Studio Press, / 2001. 4. Shewmon DA. " 'Brainstem Death', 'Brain Death' and Death : A Critical Reevaluation of the Purported Equivalence" , Issues in Law and Medicine, 1998, Vol. 14, No 2. 5. Shewmon DA. "Chronic 'brain death' Meta-analysis and conceptual consequences." Neurology 1998; 51. 6. Shewmon DA. "The semantic confusion surrounding 'bra in death'." Arch Neurol 1989; 46. 7. Truog RD, Fackler JC. "Rethinking brain death." Crit Care Med, 1992; 20. 8. Taylor RM. "Reexamining the Definition and Criteria of Death." Seminars in Neurol 1997; 17. 9. . . " ", , 1998, 8: 17. 10. " Nemecis", I 2001. 11. Giacomini M. "A Change of Heart and a Change of Mind ? Technology and Redefinition of Death i n 1968." Soc Sci Med, 1997, Vol. 44, No 10. 12. , , , . et al. " ' ' ", H K 12 / 9 / 99. 13. , , , . et al. " ", 10 / 10 / 99. 14. , . " ;". 1999, 76 ; 3. 15. , , . et al. " 2737/1999 ". 1999. 16. Van Norman G. "Can Brain Death Testing Be Perfect? " Anesth . 2000, Vol 92, No 4. 17. Beresford R. "Medical -Legal Issues Facing Neurology". Neurol Clin 1999, Vol 17, No 2. 18. , ." ' , , . , 2001, . . 96. 19. . ( ). " ". , 2000, 14. 20. . , " ' ' ; 25 ". , 2002, 22.
1.
7
21.
. . . . , 2002.
.
.
.
,
.
.
.
« ,
» , .
«
-
» .
, . , , « ,
,
8
, . » . . 1968 », ad hoc . , Harvard ,
«
,
. ., . :« , ». , , « , ».
,
,
,
, ' , , , , . , , . , . , -
. , , , . . . . 5-15
9
, . . , . « ». « » ; , . , . , ' , « » , . ,
,
«
»
,
,
. , , « 2001 68 , . , , , , ». « « . « », « » . 55 , « , ». : « 25 , 13 », , », , , . , », : « -
10
, .
,
».
.
, -
, , . ; , ; , , ; , , , , ,
, , « , . Truog, « , », . Harvard
, ,
», 2003 CRITICAL CARE MEDICINE (31.9:2391-96), : « . . . . . ». : « , , . . ;». « , , . , . . , ». , , , . ., , , . . . , , . , . . . . . . , . ' . . , , . .
-
,
:
11
,
,
, .
, , . ,
, , . , . ., , . . », . 24 , , , ». . , 273 , , . , « 25 , 10 :« . ., . . ,
12
: «
. , , ». . , . . . . .; . . , ; , , , ; , , -
, ,
, . ,
, , , . -
, , .
,
. , , . , . , Jersey 1991 New . , , -
13
. . « . .», . .
